Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

News for nerds, stuff that matters

Slashdot Log In

Log In

Create Account  |  Retrieve Password

PC Gaming Suggestions for Console-like Fun?

Posted by timothy on Thu Apr 24, 2008 07:57 AM
from the twister-seems-more-fun dept.
jayminer writes "We are a relatively newly married young couple who enjoy spending our spare time at home. We don't own a console but have a gaming laptop with DVI output to play games on our TV. My wife is also a CS major so she's computer literate enough. She does not like strategy games, MMORG or any other role-playing game. Apart from "Find the Sausage" jokes, we need quality gaming advice, preferably games which we can play with a single laptop connected to a single large screen, with two gamepads, a console-like experience. What are your suggestions?"
+ -
story

Related Stories

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
 Full
 Abbreviated
 Hidden
More
Loading... please wait.
  • Obvious answer... (Score:5, Insightful)

    by richy freeway (623503) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:01AM (#23181322)
    Just buy a console.
    • by Aranykai (1053846) <{moc.liamg} {ta} {resnogls}> on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:10AM (#23181450)
      Simple and sweet. Its really the truth though.

      Ive sat here and tossed around all the game I can remember playing over the years, and the ones worth the time all equate one pc with one player.

      Consoles are the king of multi user gaming hands down. Like suggested above, nab an old console. PS 1 or Nintendo 64 or such should be had for under 75 USD with several games.
    • I've got a second hand Dreamcast at home for 50 euro's (roughly 75 US$) with a bunch of games. Consoles of around this generation (N64, PS, GC) onwards have all the types of games you'd want for a fraction of the cost of modern consoles.
      • Re:Obvious answer... (Score:5, Interesting)

        by 0100010001010011 (652467) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:18AM (#23181580)
        The load it with Emulators. Most of my friends aren't the huge gaming type. When we get together to hang out we don't want to sit through a tutorial on how to play SuperHappyBallComando4. We want the games we grew up with (and some from before then).

        Super Mario Bros 3, Pong, Frogger, PacMan. Plus they make excellent drinking games (One shot for every fruit you didn't get on a PacMan level.) The best thing is an xBox can store ALL of these games and more.

        Or you could even get some classic looking controllers and play these on the laptop.
            • Perhaps his particular brand of morality says it's wrong to break laws - even though the laws themselves may be wrong.
              • Re: (Score:3, Interesting)

                Sure, that might seem obvious if your idea of ethics is doing what you're told. I suppose that if you were told that you were supposed to pay for oxygen, you'd consider breathing unethical.

                Most of us though have our own consciences and prefer to use them. The simple act of copying a file in the privacy of my own home harms no one. Therefore, it cannot possibly be wrong.
                • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

                  Lost revenue does harm the publisher, which in turn harms the developer. For a wide majority of older software, the publisher either isn't still in business, or couldn't care less whether you pirate a game from 1987... that's what makes up Abandonware. Some companies actively enforce their rights on older IP, even if they don't still intend to profit from it: LucasArts, for example. Others will distribute older software along with newer software... Sid Meier's Pirates!, for example, came with a copy of the
                  • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

                    Sure, easy enough to demonstrate... assuming I would have bought the files I copied for free. And also assuming that I'm not more likely to spend money on classic games when I get to try them for free first.

                    But that's not really the point. The point is that copying a file is a private transaction between two consenting adults. The people who are behaving unethically are those who are trying to control voluntary consenting behavior. They're not losing any revenue because they're not ethically entitled to
                  • Re: (Score:3, Interesting)

                    I am sitting at home. I press a button to copy a file. Not pressing that button would not have generated any revenue for the copyright holder of the file, therefore pressing the button has not cost them any revenue.

                    The "lost revenue" argument is a joke. It may (and probably does) apply to people who produce illegal copies for distribution, but has zero weight with regards to individuals making copies for themselves.
                  • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

                    Pretending to follow the law isn't the same thing as actually following it.
                    Actually following it makes little sense when the law is as convoluted and ridiculous as copyright law is today.
                    • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

                      That's debatable, and I'm not saying you're wrong. The GG...GP asked a specific question though, and that was whether you could do it _without_ breaking the law.
                    • you can technically do it without breaking the law, it's just expensive and requires a high level of expertise to construct the ripping mechanism.

                      at that point it'd be easier just picking up some old hardware too. Obviously by ripping your NES carts you'd miss out on the enthralling experience of blowing on the connector to get the damn thing to boot.
      • Re:Obvious answer... (Score:5, Informative)

        by ShieldW0lf (601553) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:22AM (#23181638) Journal
        I would suggest emulators.

        For arcade games, you can use MAME

        http://mamedev.org/ [mamedev.org]

        Once you've got MAME, you need a set of current ROM files for it. You can find ROMs on BitTorrent or on any P2P application.

        As MAME evolves, the ROM sets get replaced with new and better extractions, so you'll want a piece of software to manage them.

        ClrMAMEPro is a tool that will use the data files from the latest version of MAME, and scan a big huge mess of old ROM files, extracting whatever is useful from them into a nice, neat set that works with the current version

        http://www.clrmame.com/ [clrmame.com]

        To get yourself set up, download any new or old MAME ROMs you can find, then use ClrMAMEPro to make a proper and current set out of them and burn it to backup.

        There are also emulators floating around out there for Playstation, Nintendo 64, NES and Super NES. I've gotten good performance out of Project 64, an emulator for Nintendo 64. MarioCart plays quite well.

        When you're choosing GamePads, you should look for something wireless that has as many buttons as you can possibly find. You want to be able to map the controller you choose to every possible controller from history, so you're going to need something that is flexible.
        • by King_TJ (85913) on Thursday April 24 2008, @10:08AM (#23183270) Homepage Journal
          Most MythTV distributions include a MAME emulator, as well as a SNES emulator, and support for several others you can optionally download, install and configure in their menus.

          The nice thing about this is, it gives you a good excuse to dedicate an entire PC to your TV set, since it works as a very capable DVR, gives you a set-top web browser, and other goodies.

          The downside? At least from all the knoppmyth distros I've used, I've always had some hassle getting MAME working well with it. (EG. You can purchase wireless gamepad type controllers from Logitech that use USB dongles and are detected just fine in Linux. But you'll have to do some creative stuff with the xmame config file so you have all their buttons assigned in a sensible manner. If you don't assign one to simulate dropping coins in, for example, you'll never be able to get a new game to start from your controller.)
          • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

            Pressing a button to put in a quarter is my favorite part.

            When I think of the number of times my weekly allowance was ALMOST enough money to beat Double Dragon... now it's "Hahahah, fuck you Willy. Click, click, click, click..."

            Petty I know. But very satisfying.
      • Atari 2600 (Score:4, Funny)

        by goombah99 (560566) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:27AM (#23181696)
        Here's a site [mightygodking.com] showing the best atari games ever complete with the awesome box covers. So real gems in there, many you probably never heard of. Get an emulator and enjoy the nostalgia.
      • by trdrstv (986999) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:44AM (#23181876)

        Its much cheaper to buy a game or two (maybe 30) than it is to buy a console and then buy games for it...

        Only if you're talking "Current gen". A Used Gamecube is $30 at Gamestop, and a Used X-box is $60. There are a Ton of good Co-op games for cheap (NHL HITZ is an all time favorite). Hell instead of buying the extra controller, buy 2 Gamecubes and an extra memory card in case you both want to game solo at some point.

  • Buy a console (Score:3, Insightful)

    by the computer guy nex (916959) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:02AM (#23181326)
    If you are wanting to play on your television opposed to a monitor, you probably have a pretty nice TV. Chances are your laptop cannot run at a resolution where you would even enjoy this experience.

    The 360 and the Wii cost less than the original NES did if you count in inflation. Do some research in game libraries and pick one. Well worth the investment.

    In terms of games, Guitar Hero is addicting.
    • Re:Buy a console (Score:5, Insightful)

      by Hoplite3 (671379) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:11AM (#23181470)
      Or even cheaper, buy a console from the last generation: xbox, ps2, gamecube. You can get them used for peanuts or new for a bit more. Best of all, there are GOOD lists of what games for the console are actually fun.

      Reviews of modern games are often clouded by hype and irrelevant trends. Many nerds will retrospectively look at their video game library and wax poetic about the ones that are still fun (and they'll do it on their blog thanks to ego^w web 2.0). You can get these games used for $3-$10. A seven-year-old game can still be fun.

      And if you haven't played it, it's new to you.
  • Stepmania (Score:5, Interesting)

    by gatzke (2977) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:02AM (#23181336) Homepage Journal
    Get a couple of USB dance pads and try out Stepmania, a free DDR clone.

    Or get a Wii. Tons of simple flash games through the browser. Fun and simple.
  • Emulators (Score:5, Insightful)

    by Oxy the moron (770724) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:02AM (#23181346)

    Get some old-school console emulators and play some of the great classics.

    I'm sure that what constitutes a "classic" will vary here on /., but I prefer some of the older Super NES games... Tetris Attack is awesome.

    You didn't hear that from me, though...

    • Re:Emulators (Score:4, Insightful)

      by xtracto (837672) * on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:48AM (#23181946) Journal
      I have to second this idea.

      Just get SNES9X and download some games. I used to play that with my GF:
      - Mario Kart (SNES version is one of the best ones)
      - Lemmings (2 player snes version quite good)
      - TMNT (2 player cooperative)
      - Top Gear (one of the few two player coop. racing games where even if one is good enough, both of you will be able to go through the game [and you can cooperate by trying to block the first place cars to make one of you win :P])
      - Super Contra (a bit more "man" oriented, but fun coop too).
      - Rock and Roll racing (another nice racing game).
      - Battletoads in Battlemaniacs (two player kind of coop... a bit difficult [but quite fun if you enable infinite lives cheat])
      - Bomberman (My girlfriend loves these ones. It is OK multiplayer)
      - Joe and Mac (really funny caveman characters, multiplayer coop)
      - Super Mario All Stars (I can never be left out! including Super Mario Bros 3, i have played it with my girlfriend from the beginning to the end)

      - Ninja Gaiden Trilogy (not really multiplayer, maybe not really very good, but it is my favourite game of all time [Ninja Gaiden II for the NES] so I had to include it here =oP)

      Those are all I can think of now. The reason I choose SNES is because such games are not as complex as todays' games; therefore you can just sit start it and begin playing without two hours of tutorial (I am looking at you Wii Zelda ).

      Also, I think the SNES had the best kind of cooperative multiplayer games... these days it is very difficult to find such games in any console. The only cooperative games are FPS like "halo" but they are a turn off for most girls or other "casual" players.

      And, the reason I don't choose Wii (even though I have one, which is in its box since I moved home 2 months ago) is because I hate mini-games, and all the multiplayer games from Nintendo are mini games (wiiware, mario party, rayman raymin rabbits, monkeyball banana... etc).

      Oh! and the last one I would suggest is Worms. That is a really good game in which I have spent hours with my girlfriend and other friends (even a friend who never had used a computer had no problem playing the N64 emulated game =oO)

  • by Anonymous Coward on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:04AM (#23181364)
    "Not only do I have a girlfriend, but we're MARRIED, and she wants to play video games with me! Oh, did I mention she loves Linux?"
  • by Anonymous Coward on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:07AM (#23181408)
    Don't mean to be presumptuous, but I would recommend you spend your spare time outside of your house exploring the world. You will have plenty of time to stay in the house if/when you decide to have children.
    • by Oxy the moron (770724) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:24AM (#23181672)

      Speaking as a geek married with four kids, I say any time spent enjoying each other's company is good. You also make the assumption that they have the desire and means to get out and explore the world... I know we didn't early in our marriage.

      Not saying that exploring the world is bad, but I think if they really enjoy gaming together, it's better than a lot of other alternatives. :)

    • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

      You don't mean to be presumptuous, but why don't they skip doing what they enjoy, and instead do what you think they should be enjoying?

      If you didn't mean to be presumptuous, but knew it was sufficiently presumptuous to include the disclaimer, then why did you bother posting? So that we all know that you go outdoors? Next thing you know we'll be hearing about how you don't own a television [theonion.com] either.
  • Suggestions... (Score:5, Insightful)

    by 404 Clue Not Found (763556) * on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:08AM (#23181422) Homepage
    First, I know this isn't what you asked, but I can't recommend this enough: Instead of wasting money on PC gamepads and half-assed ports, just get a console. You can get a PS2 for ~$100 and an additional controller + memory card for maybe another $20. That'd open up a whole WORLD of great co-op games designed for the exact kind of experience you're looking for. You can rent games from your neighborhood video store or from Gamefly.com for about $5 a pop or $20 a month. The whole process would be much simpler (no installations, no crashes, no gamepad incompabilities) and the availability of games is so much better. I'm not recommending this out of laziness. I've been a die-hard PC gamer for ~15 years (still am), but I recently got a PS2 for Rock Band and have since started renting other co-op titles... and lemme tell ya, the experience is so much more straightforward and enjoyable.

    If you absolutely must play on the PC, well, I'd suggest you simply look for direct console ports or cross-platform titles. "Natural" PC games designed only for the PC are aimed towards a different audience and play rather differently. It's going to be especially hard to find multiplayer PC games that are playable on a single system with gamepad support -- most people who want that style simply go for consoles instead.

    Now, some specifics... are console-style action-RPGs also forbidden? Some good multiplayer games fall into this category, like Marvel: Ultimate Alliance [wikipedia.org] and X-Men Legends II [wikipedia.org].

    The venerable Worms series [wikipedia.org] (specifically, Worms Armageddon [wikipedia.org]) is also great two-player fun.

    Guitar Hero 3 [wikipedia.org] is great fun on the consoles, but it has high system requirements on the PC and I'm not sure if it supports split-screen play.

    Serious Sam [wikipedia.org] lets you play split-screen on one system, but I don't know how easy it'd be to use gamepads with a FPS designed for PCs (meaning, it probably lacks the auto-aim found in console FPSes).

    The Gametap [gametap.com] service lets you play a lot of old-school games for a flat monthly fee, and many of them are designed for 2-player console-like gaming (they're ported from the consoles or arcades, after all).

    Wikipedia also has a list of more single-system games [wikipedia.org] (sort the table by "screen view").

    That's all I can think of.
    • I went ahead and filtered that Wikipedia list for coop PC games that can be played on a single system (like the original list, this is neither complete nor perfect):

      Alien Breed
      Alien Breed: Tower Assault
      Batman Forever: The Arcade Game
      Blip and Blop
      C-Dogs
      Dynasty Warriors 4
      Guitar Hero III
      Jazz Jackrabbit 2
      Kane & Lynch: Dead Men
      Lego Star Wars II: The Original Trilogy
      Lego Star Wars: The Video Game
      Marvel: Ultimate Alliance
      Millennium Soldier: Expendable
      Pirates of the Caribbean: The Legend of Jack Sparrow
      Serious
  • by Anonymous Coward on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:09AM (#23181438)
    The best game to play is "HIDE the sausage"!
  • Gametap (Score:3, Informative)

    by Anonymous Coward on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:10AM (#23181454)
    Gametap.com. I like that. Go to walmart and buy a controller adapter for usb and you can both play games, old and new, arcade and console, from your laptop.
  • a head designer was the guy who coined the term mmorpg. it is in fact the first (graphical, sorry mudders) example of an mmorpg

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SubSpace_(computer_game) [wikipedia.org]

    its like the original asteroids, without the asteroids, and instead a maze of a bunch of other ships (random people from around the world)

    i think a lot of slashdotters messed with it 10 years ago, and forgot about it

    however, i recently rediscovered it (its free now) and was surprised to find a lot of zones still heavily populated. each zone has a different variation on the basic ship types and their abilities. you can waste 5 minutes or half an hour on it, to great effect

    nothing like meeting a guy in a tank from finland, dodging his mine, blowing him away, while a guy from china materializes out of cloak and shoots you in the back. its cheap and easy mmorpg fun without the massive time commitment something like WoW demands
  • In all seriousness, the total hardware cost of two gamepads, a TV out connector and a laptop graphics card needed to run the latest games will more than likely overrun the cost of just buying a PS2 or a Wii, Your spouse's tastes scream console gaming. No strategy games or RPGs? What does that leave? FPSes? Good luck finding a co-op FPS title.

    For Co-op play, console is King. There are a myriad of two player titles out there to cater for all tastes, and co-op is something that even gets included in some one [youtube.com] player [youtube.com] titles, owing to its popularity.

    PCs are not designed for what you're looking for. Consoles are, and they are cheaper, faster, easier and offer a better selection of titles. Just buy the damn Wii.
  • by jellomizer (103300) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:14AM (#23181510)
    The issue with most PC Games even Multi-Player is they expect one person for PC, so they are normally networked for multi-player.
    Get 2 USB Keypads, and a Copy of VMWare. Install 2 OS the VMWare and copy of each game on it. setup the virtual network correctly and Link one USB Keypad to each VM. Now Resize the VM Windows so you have Split Screen. And there 2 of you can play games at once (even 2 different ones if you feel like it) on your laptop all for the price of getting a console.
  • by Toreo asesino (951231) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:15AM (#23181526) Journal
    Jesus, if you've got to resort to games this early on in marriage, that's not a good sign.

    Sexual deviance, man! That's what you need to try; your "find the sausage" game sounds like a good start. You're married, it's ok to do that now!
  • Lego Star Wars (Score:3, Informative)

    by Rhys (96510) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:19AM (#23181588) Homepage
    Ep1-3 and 4-6 are both excellent and are PC-available.

    I think guitar hero has a PC port, if you're into rhythm games. (ba-dum-ching!)
  • by MadKeithV (102058) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:23AM (#23181652)
    For the console-like fun experience, you need a stick, a sharpening tool, and one of your eyes.

    Nintendo-Hard, look it up.

    (I kid, I kid).
  • by blindd0t (855876) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:52AM (#23181994)

    Since the post talks about what games the misses dislikes, I'll do my best with that even though no insight about what she does like was provided. Worms Armageddon is a seriously fun game anyone can play. It's an old game, and I want to say there is some hacked version that can run at higher resolutions than it was originally capable of handling, so I would suggest buying the game and looking into that. Also, I would recommend looking into emulators for NES, SNES, and so on. There is a ton of stuff out there for that which could provide a wide variety of games that are tons of fun to play (even if the graphics are far from top-notch).

    Even though you can't go spit-screen on this one, if either or both of you likes racing games, GTR2 is a seriously good racing simulator, but keep in mind that the average person might find its realistic physics to be frustrating. The Logitech Momo force-feedback steering wheel works exceptionally well for this and other racing games.

    If the misses also likes diablo-style games, Titan quest is a game my wife enjoyed. Again, you can't go split-screen here, but it could provide some good entertainment for both of you. Of course, if you have another PC in the house, you could play together over a LAN. ^_^

  • Cortex Command (Score:3, Interesting)

    by Peganthyrus (713645) on Thursday April 24 2008, @08:58AM (#23182058) Homepage
    My boyfriend and I have had a lot of fun with Cortex Command [datarealms.com]. It's a really entertainingly adolescent wargame that supports splitscreen play and joystick controllers.

    It's not actually finished but its active mod community makes it not matter - if one of you skims the forums now and then, you'll find all kinds of giggle-inducingly overpowered toys to play with. It's ultraviolent but it's on the border between 'obscene' and 'slapstick'...
  • There's always Rapid Onset, Vital Passage, or Sudden Thrust.
    • Re: (Score:3, Informative)

      Coming soon too we have LEGO Raiders of the Lost Ark and such. It's amazing how fun that game is, especially with a competent second player.

      However, play it with a five year old, my god, you'll go insane. It's like playing Contra all over again.
      • Re: (Score:3, Interesting)

        I play it with my 5 year old, he skips all the damn coins... drives me nuts. We're somewhere like 60% but the kids scratched it so there's 2 levels we can't play at all. Just got to the lego city, that was a disapointment... They've bought all the characters, most of the good power ups, only the 2x multiplier though... They keep spending the money on stuff they won't use. I think my favorite setup is the ewok with the explosive catapult and invincibility... Just walk up and kill everything. My son drive