Fired for Solitare At Work 680
schlick writes "The Associated Press is carrying a story about a NYC employee fired after Mayor Michael Bloomberg noticed a game of solitare on the employee's desktop at work." From the article: "Greenwood, who earned $27,000 a year and had worked in the office for six years, said in a telephone interview that he limited his play time to his one-hour lunch or during quick breaks when he needed a moment of distraction. 'It wasn't like I spent hours and hours a day playing, because I had plenty to do,' Greenwood said. 'If I had been working at something exhaustively for two hours, I might get a cup of coffee and play for a minute but then go right back to my work.'"
If they enforced this (Score:5, Funny)
Re:If they enforced this (Score:5, Insightful)
I would personally like to see a study on how many people are compliant with their agreements. From a survey of my cube-buddies; I know we would all fail. At the same time, I don't usually stop for lunch, so I don't see the harm in taking a thought-break - without which, I am sure my productivity would drop.
Re:If they enforced this (Score:4, Funny)
soduko
Re:If they enforced this (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:If they enforced this (Score:3, Insightful)
I've been immersed in this culture my whole life, and it takes a short shock of outside air to look at it anew. We've a country that hates "socialism" so much that they organize to keep inions OUT of their workplace. The salaries shrink, pensions disppear, healthcare is repeatedly slashed for current employees and denied to new, "temporary" employees w
Re:LOL (Score:4, Funny)
Regards,
Spelling nazi
Re:evolved culture, identity politics, immigration (Score:3, Insightful)
These elite shape our culture over decades to make it suit them. They are capital. We are labor. Our interests are for the most part, directly opposed.
This is only in a socie
Re:If they enforced this (Score:3, Funny)
Re:If they enforced this (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:If they enforced this (Score:4, Insightful)
-nB
Re:If they enforced this (Score:5, Funny)
Nobody gets fired for that!
Re:If they enforced this (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:If they enforced this (Score:4, Insightful)
Terms of use (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Terms of use (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Terms of use (Score:5, Insightful)
The frickin' MAYOR is coming to your office. Not of Paducah, KY, but of New York City. He probably hasn't been there for three years. Don't you think you'd better make yourself a little more presentable?
Re:Terms of use (Score:5, Insightful)
If a big-time politician came wandering through my cube, (and a couple have) you have two obligations: clean up your desk, and greet the distinguished visitor with a smile. If your boss asked you to work during the tour, let's not be an idiot about it - find some work, or at least repeat some work you've already done. The VIP doesn't know the difference. "Sir, I'm working on an analysis of the workload levels of the T&M contractors the city hires to see if we're getting a good return on our contracts." Never mind it was something you did 3 months ago.
Oh, and don't act like you aren't the BOFH that opens up old network statistics charts or network snoops, pouring over them when the big boss comes in. "Sir, I'm tracking through some anomalous network activity our SOA layer got during last night's advertising during the Olympics opening ceremony."
Anybody caught doing something stupid when a VIP is in the room deserves what they get. It's like seeing a cop in the median a mile ahead and then getting the bright idea to shift four lanes of traffic and pass on the right. You're begging for it. "My cell phone rang and I was just trying to honor good road safety rules, officer." Yeesh.
Re:Terms of use (Score:3, Funny)
'Hicks, how come you're not working.'
I'd go, 'There's nothing to do.'
'Well, you pretend like you're working.'
'Well, why don't you pretend I'm working? Yeah, you get paid more than me, you fantasise. Pretend I'm mopping. Knock yourself out. I'll pretend they're buying stuff; we can close up. I'm the boss now, you're fired. How's that? I'm on a fucking roll. We're all millionaires and you're dick. I'm pretending shit, I'm wacky, I can't be stopped.'
I don't know if I have the right attitud
Re:Terms of use (Score:3, Insightful)
According to who?... Oh yeah the person who got fired; Of course he'd tell the truth if he was playing at the time, right? Really, how many people leave Windows applications up that you aren't using? If you're not using it, it should be minimized. Windows doens't have enough screen real estate otherwise, and it blocks your access to the desktop.
So in short, I think the guy is whitewashing his story. Getting canned for playing
Re:Terms of use (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Terms of use (Score:5, Insightful)
I'm fine with laws that protect people from each other. I'm against laws that attempt to protect people from themselves. Seems simple enough to me.
at least smoking tends to kill quickly.
Emphysema and heart disease are slow enough.
Re:Terms of use (Score:5, Interesting)
I do I.T. work at an amusement park but I also drive trams when its busy because its what I did before I got promoted. Anyway the CEO here has fire d people for sitting down at work and for even using a cell phone in a private break area away from guests. No cells allowed nor is looking like your not working in front of guests allowed. Cells outside of the public are allowed but its different when he is around. Even though I work in IT, I was asked by him why I was not picking cigarette butts where I was volunteering to work (clearing trams). I would have been termed onsite and to me its silly but that is just business as usual.
Re:Terms of use (Score:3, Insightful)
Whereas it probably also was made clear beforehand that playing games during businesshours was prohibited in the case of the NYC employee, there could at least have been a 'final warning' or serious discussion: What this guy did is purely covering his own ass: -HE- wanted to be a publicity whore, he'd better
Re:Terms of use (Score:5, Insightful)
Sounds to me like it's time to get a new job.
If you are good at what you do, then why are you putting up with these kind of working conditions?
My recomendation is to quit NOW
Re:Terms of use (Score:3, Informative)
I mean, you KNOW this will probably get you fired, you KNOW that people can see you doing it
Re:Terms of use (Score:5, Insightful)
It really is unreasonable to have such policies without some kind of technical help to enforce them. It doesn't need to be bullet proof - it just makes things easier for the employees honestly trying to follow the policy.
A related issue is the monthly limit on total bytes transferred with my cable company TOS. I wouldn't mind it, if only they provided a meter on their website somewhere where I could see how much I had left for the month. Without that, I am just guessing and hoping they don't get strict on me all of a sudden. I know I could build a system to track it myself using iptables - but haven't got around to it yet.
strangely quiet (Score:5, Funny)
Not something to worry about (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Not something to worry about (Score:5, Interesting)
There is a person at a company I work for, that gets the mandatory levels of productivity needed to keep the job. They are also very outspoken about company issues, which disagree with the current practices (union and so on). So every time he gets audited (monthly process) they purposefully find his worst interactions in the hopes that he'll be below standard and they can fire him. Some people didn't believe this so he purposefully made a small mistake in one interaction and wrote down the ID of that interaction. The next month, that was the one audited. This has been shown more than once, and they're just waiting for an "approved" reason to terminate employment.
This kind of discrimination does exist, they just hide it behind protocol and procedure.
Re:Not something to worry about (Score:5, Insightful)
The grandparent poster was talking about someone who was doing the job he was hired to do.
Employees and employers both have extensive rights and responsibilities that are enshrined in job descriptions, employments contracts, and state and federal laws. Working isn't a right or a privilege--it's a mutually beneficial arrangement extensively regulated by contract and labour law.
An employee who complains because the employer isn't holding up their end of the contractual or legal obligations shouldn't face sanctions (unfair evaluation practices as described by the grandparent poster, for instance).
Re:Not something to worry about (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Not something to worry about (Score:5, Insightful)
No, it is neither. It is merely the matter of a contract between two parties.
Re:Not something to worry about (Score:3, Insightful)
If you work in a public office, you've got people coming in and out all day, many of which are ordinary citizens. All it takes is one person to notice and say, "Oh, I am paying for that guy to play Solitaire." Something like that may come out against you in an news article or in your re-election campaign.
So yes, he looks like an asshole, but then again, he also looks like he's stongly protecting the
Re:Not something to worry about (Score:5, Insightful)
No, Ayn Rand, it's not in your job description, but it's precisely in almost every state's labor laws.
So? (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:So? (Score:2, Interesting)
However, one could make the argument that, since the game was installed, it was 'approved' for use....
Re:So? (Score:5, Insightful)
I've worked for employers that didn't understand this. Burnout and turnover rates were astonishingly high. Meanwhile, I've worked for employers that recognized the value of this kind of freedom/flexibility. They also realized the non-value of an employee that needs to get away.
Solitaire/minesweeper/Sudoku or the occasional "why don't you go home early" often translates to a refreshed and more productive employee tomorrow.
Re:Paid for 8 hours work or to be present for 8? (Score:5, Informative)
Now as a salaried employee, I constantly have slashdot, fark, etc open. On the other hand, I will read it, then do a bit of this, then read. In all honesty my productivity improves because to answer tough questions many times you have to distract yourself from them for a bit. (I am one of the most productive people in my group.) If the person wasn't playing solitare he'd be over in the other cube talking to a friend, getting some water, just roaming around, etc. That kind of thing has happened for AGES. To fire someone for playing a game for 5min is rediculious though it would be justifiable if the guy was always playing.
like a teenager and a car... (Score:5, Interesting)
Yep. It's like my parents and I when I was in high school:
Mom: "Okay, what car are you taking?"
Me: "My car."
Dad: *COUGHAHEM*
Me: "The car which I am permitted to use."
Dad: "Have fun!"
I see it all the time- employees get very posessive about their computers. The word "my" is thrown around very casually, they get attached to them, etc. Hell, I worked at places where people (almost exclusively sales staff) would take laptops with them when let go, and they'd act REALLY pissed when we called them and asked for them back. Some we had to literally harass the CRAP out of, to get machines returned- and when they were, they'd invariably be damaged, usually the keyboard and mouse/trackpad buttons; it was clear they whacked the shit out of it with a shoe or something just to piss us off.*
It's equipment. Capital. I don't see a machine shop operator getting pissed when he's fired and he can't take the mill home with him...
*I've also had to lock sales people out of databases WHILE they were getting "The Talk", because in the past, every single one of their predecessors had immediately logged in to the customer database from home and dumped it... un frigging believeable. Never had more trouble with terminated/let go employees than with sales dweebs/bimbos. ZERO morals, which I'd like to think was part of the reason they were fired.
Literally... (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:like a teenager and a car... (Score:3, Insightful)
Or possibly the reason they were hired in the first place. Honesty doesn't make higher sales.
Re:So? (Score:3, Interesting)
The bottom line is that if a company does not want an employee to use a resource, then they com
Re:So? (Score:3, Interesting)
It is so trivially easy to remove or disable access to this sort of software, that it boggles the mind anyone would even consider trying to make an issue out of it.
Re:Just because you can, doesn't mean you should (Score:3, Funny)
Many entry-level retail employees in NYC make $27,000/yr.
Bloomberg thus joins the ranks (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Bloomberg thus joins the ranks (Score:2)
Re:Bloomberg thus joins the ranks (Score:5, Informative)
Also, if the employee were so indispensible, I assume his manager would have defended him and done whatever possible to give him another chance. Honestly, if the man got fired by a chance remark, even coming out of Bloomberg's mouth, he probably was on the line already for other reasons.
Re:Bloomberg thus joins the ranks (Score:5, Insightful)
And to the GP, you will find if you pay attention, that most rich people who's names you know have worked very hard.
Re:Bloomberg thus joins the ranks (Score:5, Insightful)
It fucking well will be in real life. If you can't spell or put together a proper sentence, you will go nowhere fast.
Any job application / report to a customer / business proposal instantly loses its authority in the eyes of the recipient if said recipient detects a spelling or grammatical error. Think about that before applying the sarcasm on with a trowel next time.
Heh. (Score:2)
I'd cut him a little more slack, if I didn't know a few bosses just like him that managed things so poorly there was plenty of downtime. Of course, I suppose uber-capitalists like himself would say that whenever that occurs you're supposed to clock out so you can save the company your wages...
Rules (Score:5, Interesting)
That was a scumbag move of the mayor, firing him without even talking to him.
Two paragraphs from TFA ... (Score:5, Insightful)
-- and --
"I expect all city workers, including myself, to work hard," the mayor said. "There's nothing wrong with taking a break, but during the business day, at your desk, that's not appropriate behavior."
Yep, workin' hard there, Mr. Mayor. Workin' hard.
Re:Two paragraphs from TFA ... (Score:3, Insightful)
-Chris
Not nearly as bad as... (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Not nearly as bad as... (Score:2)
Re:Not nearly as bad as... (Score:3, Funny)
Yeah, you might both end up in the same hospital ward coughing your lungs up. That's a fantastic bonding experience.
A little extreme, but... (Score:2, Insightful)
When you know the boss is going to be around, with reporters, why would you be playing a game on your computer? I'm sorry the guy lost his job, and yes, I think a reprimand would have been more appropriate, but still, he wasn't very bright.
Re:A little extreme, but... (Score:2)
The guy was an office assistant working for the City.
Do you actually expect someone at that job to be even marginally intelligent?
If so, you never dealt with government (epsecially NYC) employees.
not first but still - a question (Score:3, Funny)
It wasn't in Manhattan (Score:5, Informative)
Bloomberg... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Bloomberg... (Score:5, Funny)
should have tried nethack (Score:3, Informative)
Solitaire is always going to get you in trouble because it's so recognizable.
Only a few minutes? (Score:5, Insightful)
Every good manager knows that employees need a bit of time to themselves. Just look at Google's policy for working on personal projects and what a great benefit that policy is to both Google and its employees.
At my last job we had short Unreal Tournamet sessions one day a week and nakednews.com viewings in the morning, and everybody was really happy with their job. Everybody got a lot of great work done.
Re:Only a few minutes? (Score:3, Funny)
You mean "assume", right? Perhaps it's `creative dismissal`. If I'd been fired for playing a game at lunchtime you can bet I'd be hiring a solicitor right now. Well, as soon as I finish this level...
Back in the day of Windows 3.1... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Back in the day of Windows 3.1... (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Back in the day of Windows 3.1... (Score:3, Interesting)
Your boss was absolutely correct in questioning why a programmer was in the data center.
Another reason to smoke (Score:5, Insightful)
-Rick
Re:Another reason to smoke (Score:3, Interesting)
I do believe I had one boss try to claim that was different because "smoking is an addiction". My response was on the order of "well... reading is my addiction."
Re:Another reason to smoke (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Another reason to smoke (Score:3, Interesting)
Now I work at a better paying job where there is no time clock and my boss smokes more than me. When I take a smoke break, it's usually with my boss and
Awesome (Score:3, Insightful)
I mean
Solitare used to be my wallpaper. (Score:4, Funny)
As an act of civil disobedience I made solitare my wall paper, and removed all my icons.
Evil breeds evil... (Score:3, Interesting)
On a related note, back in Law School, most folks used laptops to take notes. The Dean used to walk through the back of class from time to time. If he was in a particularly bad mood, he'd signal the professor teaching to call on whoever was playing solitare. Getting "called on" in law school is often just as unpleasant in real life as it appears in movies like "Legally Blonde." More so when you're playing solitare and not paying attention. It was evil, really.
Nobody ever got kicked out of school for it though.
And the next story... (Score:5, Funny)
Not NYC - Albany (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Not NYC - Albany (Score:4, Informative)
No, what it said was, "The mayor's office said its records show that in 2004 Greenwood reviewed the policy that prohibits "inappropriate" use of city computers." That means that they gave everyone a written copy of the AUP and had everyone sign something saying they received a copy of it and read it, something that practically everyone that works in an office of any size does in this day and age. It doesn't in any way imply that he'd broken the rules at any time.
Unrealistic expectations (Score:3, Insightful)
The human mind is not designed to stay on one task for hour after hour without a few minutes of mental downtime, and failing to recognize this and not to simply expect productivity, but blind mechanical function in a sentient being is not only wrong but fails to deliver the intended results.
It's a sad state of affairs when you realize that many people in their position tend to have a more anthropomorphic view of their pets than their employees.
Smokers...? (Score:5, Insightful)
A similar story... (Score:5, Interesting)
"But Mr. Ford! You can't fire me!"
"Why the hell not?"
"I don't work for you! I work for the phone company!"
Re:A similar story... (Score:4, Funny)
A new manager is hired to bring an underproducing office up to speed. He decides that he must fire somebody on the first day to show that he means business. While walking through the office, he spots a man leaning against the wall, not doing anything. He is in a room full of workers and so decides that this is the perfect way to start.
"You! How much do you make a week?", he bellowed at the slacker.
"About $300," came the reply.
The manager pulls out his wallet, peels off three hundred dollar bills, and throws them at the man.
"Here's your money. Now get out and don't come back!"
Feeling pretty good about the firing, he glared around room. "What was this man's job?", he asked.
From the back of the room came the reply: "Pizza delivery man"
Re:A similar story... (Score:3, Interesting)
Ford was definatly a genius, but with genius comes serious eccentricities. He held very firm beliefs about the "working class" and how they should be treated (and in return how they should act.) An extension of that feeling was his belief that the "international jew" was conspiring against the working man.
He was also quite shrewd. Read the fine print about the "five dollar day." You didn't just get a job, work a day, and walk out the door wi
Re:A similar story... (Score:4, Interesting)
It's everywhere (Score:3, Funny)
Yup, they had left their Windows Solitaire game up on the screen.
Solitaire Schmolitaire (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Solitaire Schmolitaire (Score:4, Informative)
Uninstall?? (Score:5, Insightful)
2 cents,
Queen B
The term of the day is "At Will" (Score:3, Insightful)
And good luck trying to prove wrongful termination in court without blatent supporting evidence.
I got reamed for Freecell (Score:3, Interesting)
The company got bought out. He kept his job; I ended up homeless.
I play Klondike... (Score:3, Funny)
Of course, if I get my work done for the day, then it's Warcraft time...
No, not on the Treo.
Violate guidelines; would you do one quake frag? (Score:3, Informative)
Plain and simple, what you do at work must be within the guidelines of your employer and its computer usage policy.
You wouldn't bring up quake, even for just a single frag, so why do people think it's suddenly okay to pull up solitaire, hearts, or the latest java/flash game from third party Web sites? The employer couldn't care less that you wanted only a single frag, playing games is probably against their computer policy, and this person is a clear violator of it. You wouldn't pull out a deck of cards either and start playing a game on your desk, though that'd be more of a company policy than a computer and company policy.
So this is simply that someone didn't follow the rules and is now whining. Some employers are a bit more lax during lunch hours, and that's okay, but you should never just assume that the employer will be okay with you checking personal mail, surfing the net, or playing games during lunch.
I'm sure what happened in more detail is a boss walked by a few times in a week at varying times (11, 2p, 3p, etc) and saw half the time that this person was playing games instead of working. The employer has every right to kick them out. They're on someone elses dollar, so they damn-well be worth it
Solitaire (Score:3, Funny)
One fine day, after installing Microsoft SMS 2.0, I wanted to try out the 'server licensing' feature; install software on each computer, tell SMS how many licenses you actually have, and it lets only that many copies run at a time, queues people up, and so on.
I decide to test it on Solitare; so I tell the thing that only one copy of sol.exe is allowed to run, fire a copy up on my desktop, try firing it up on my laptop, and sure enough, the laptop gets a message.
A few minutes later, over comes one of the Vice Presidents, asking me to kindly turn Solitare back on.
NYC will loose this one (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:honestly... (Score:2)
Re:The real question is..... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:The real question is..... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:I dunno about you guys (Score:3, Interesting)
Alternately, you'd be surprised what you can live on. Here in CT minimum wage is 7.55/hr. That works out to 15,704 dollars per year. Absolute crap money pretty much anywhere.
Rents can be found as low as 500/mo if you really look hard, realistically 600-700 is the lower range for a studio or smallish one bedroom(working on moving out ATM, so my info is fairly current for the New Haven area). Get fond of ramen and Goodwill
Re:Delete the games (Score:3, Funny)
For someone with 6 years of Solitare experience?
Re:Good! (Score:4, Insightful)
Me.
I guess I'm unusual.
Terry Pratchett once observed that cows are herded by men that, if the cows every thought about it, the cows could convert into a damp smear on the ground in two seconds.
But the cows never think about it. They are cows. Rebellion never crosses their minds, so they let the pink monkeys herd them into slaughterhouses.
(plaitive tone) why are we all cows? people died for over a hundred years to create unions so that employers couldn't treat people like peons on a feudal estate. Why do you hate yourselves so much?