Follow Slashdot blog updates by subscribing to our blog RSS feed

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Games Entertainment

Review: Jade Empire 303

Neverwinter Nights introduced a new generation of gamers to D&D style roleplaying. When Knights of the Old Republic was released it was arguably the best Star Wars tale told since the end of the original trilogy. Given the chance to create their own world, Bioware has produced an immersive action/RPG with a compelling plot, memorable characters, and entertaining gameplay. Jade Empire is a most worthy addition to Bioware's library of games. Read on for my take on one of the most original RPG's in recent memory.

  • Title: Jade Empire
  • Developer: Bioware
  • Publisher: Microsoft Game Studios
  • System: Xbox (only)
  • Reviewer: Zonk
  • Score: 9

Jade Empire begins with another day in the simple life of a martial arts student in the town of Two Rivers. You get to pick who that martial arts student is, and can choose from among several different characters with distinct styles and kung-fu names. Whether you pick Wu the Lotus Blossum or Furious Ming, you'll be introduced to Two Rivers and the Jade Empire combat system via sparring and talking with your fellow students. The idyllic scene is broken by the sneers of a bully and, more seriously, a pirate attack. The aftermath of the pirate attack thrusts you and a few followers onto a path to discover your destiny, rescue a friend, and unravel the truth behind the history of the Jade Empire.

The story-based gameplay, then, is very similar to the Xbox version of KOTOR. You move around the world through various maps people with NPCs, and talk (and talk, and talk) to them. What could have been a frustration is a joy in Jade Empire, as every character's lines are voice acted and the quality of the voice acting is almost universally high. Even minor NPCs get performers with heart assigned to them, and the result is very engaging. By default the entire game is subtitled, but I found that the subtitles were distracting me from the quality vocal performances and I switched them off. The Tho Fan language, made specifically for the game, is subtitled to allow you to follow along with the traditionalists who don't speak english. Without subtitles in most of the conversations Jade Empire is a cinematic experience with you as the protagonist.

The cinema of the game is brought to the fore by the impressive graphical presentation Bioware wrings from the Xbox. The graphics are not groundbreaking or extraordinarily realistic, but evoke the world with soft tones, slightly exaggerated character designs, smooth looking animation, and beautiful effects. Much like KOTOR the beauty of the game is occasionally marred by slowdowns, but I found these technical hitches to be relatively rare. Given the story, cinema, and quality voice acting, Jade Empire evokes a well made wire-fu film.

Where there is wire-fu there is combat, and Jade Empire balances the preponderance of storytelling with a thoroughly enjoyable real-time combat system. Unlike Neverwinter Nights or Knights of the Old Republic, you actively control your protagonist character and your reflexes determine the success or failure of the Jade Empire saga. The basics of the combat gameplay, despite this innovation, remain firmly rooted in the d20-like systems of past games. Defeating enemies results in experience gains, and at certain intervals you gain levels. At each level gain you are given points to slot into your attributes to permanently increase them, and points to slot into your martial arts forms to improve their damage, speed, etc.

Your character has three attributes: Body, Mind, and Spirit. In turn, these attributes help determine your consumable personal resources. Body determines Health, Mind determines Chi, and Spirit determines Focus. You also have three social skills: Charm, Intuition, and Intimidate. Bonuses to your attributes affect these skills as well, with a higher Body resulting in more affective Intimidation and a higher Mind resulting in better Intuition. Your attributes, your resource pools, and your social skills can all be modified by amulet jewels. The amulet the protagonist possesses is given to her near the beginning of her quest, a powerful legacy from her mysterious past. By slotting jewels into the amulet you can customize your character beyond the levels you gain. Every jewel modifies one or more attribute or social skill in a specific way. The stones themselves are found at regular intervals throughout the game, and with only a limited number of slots you'll constantly be shifting the stones in your inventory looking for a good combination for combat and social situations.

Every character starts with a pair of martial arts styles, and as you move through the game you acquire more through combat, purchasing them, and questing. Every form, in turn, has a specific purpose. Ghosts are unaffected by weapon forms, demons turn aside magic forms, and other forms have supporting roles, such as stunning or blinding opponents. Some forms are pure support, draining chi or focus from your opponents to refill your own bars. Combat itself uses the martial forms in several basic ways, and even small fights tend to be varied enough to keep you on your toes. The basic martial arts forms have three moves: hit, block, and power attack. In the classic rock/paper/scissors style basic hits disrupt power attacks, blocks deflect hits, and power attacks destroy blocks. Each form uses the same moves, with their own variations. Long Sword's power attacks is a sweeping slash, for example, while Spirit Thief (a support/draining form) uses a power attack that fills almost half of your chi bar in one blast. The most visually impressive forms are the shapechanger forms, which allow you to take on the appearance and attacks of a demon or monster. The combat drama unfolds, then, with you switching between four pre-chosen forms (on the D-pad) in such a way as to take advantage of the situation. The flexibility of the combat system makes it rewarding to use, and rarely a chore to work through a battle.

The other element that enters into combat, and ties the combat system into the fully realized story of the game, is your companion. As you move through the game (much like KOTOR) you pick up fellow travelers and miscreants who have something to add to your tale. These individuals range from a fellow student and friend from your days at the 2 rivers school to a little girl possessed by a demon to a mad inventor who maintains the airship you travel in. Each of them has a well fleshed out backstory and as events unfold you have the opportunity to delve into their pasts and fish out interesting information and personal insights. The characters are well written and in some cases downright funny. Kang the Mad, in particular, gets some choice lines.

Next time I hide something, I'm packing explosives around it. Explosives shaped like silver bananas! Stops thieves, monkeys and monkey thieves in one fell swoop. - Kang the Mad

Besides talking with them, you are allowed to choose one to travel with you as you explore, and when you enter combat your companion fights alongside you. The AI is usually effective in their tactical choices. The companion picks a target and stays with it until it's down, countering the baddies moves as best they can. While they do occasionally take out enemies, as is befitting of a game where you are the hero, for the most part they engage supporting characters while you move in on more important targets. If you don't want them mucking up your battlefield you can also choose to place them in support mode. In support mode your companion doesn't fight, but each individual aids you in some specific way over the course of a battle. One companion regenerates your focus as you fight, for example, while another does so with your chi. The added complexity a companion brings to a fight allows for even more options on the field of combat.

Each companion has their own outlook on life. Some tend more towards a gentle disposition, while others have a harder edge to them. These outlooks reflect the two opposing points of view that your character will choose between as you move through the game. The Way of the Open Palm and the Way of the Closed Fist correlate, roughly, to the light and dark sides of the force as explored in KOTOR. As in those titles, moral choices are presented to you in nearly every conversation and situation. The more you tend towards kindness and understanding, the more enlightened you become towards the way of the Open Palm. The more you tend towards cruelty and indifference, the more accepting you become towards the way of the Closed Fist. Your physical appearance begins to change as you reach a choice along either path, and different martial art forms open up to you as well. In the end, your choice along the two paths determines what your role in the Jade Empire becomes.

Jade Empire, then, is a complicated game. It's a long story (I'm well over 30 hours into it and no where near done), well written, with impressive graphics and memorable characters. The only two real complaints I can lay at the game's feet are occasional slowdowns during combat, and (as with all Xbox Bioware games) sometimes abominably long load times between map areas. Neither of these minor technical hurdles was annoying enough for me to become frustrated by my play experience. Jade Empire is a new high water line for console RPG titles, and in my opinion is Bioware's best work to date. If you enjoy an engaging story, have gotten into Bioware titles in the past, or have a love of well crafted martial arts tales don't let Jade Empire pass you by.

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Review: Jade Empire

Comments Filter:
  • by BubbleSparkxx ( 879715 ) on Thursday April 28, 2005 @12:36PM (#12373288)
    ...for the 20 hours it takes to complete. Whatever happened to RPGs that offered 80-100 hours of gameplay the first time thru? I'm not necessarily talking Xenosaga length, but certainly at least FFX long.

  • by dfn5 ( 524972 ) on Thursday April 28, 2005 @12:42PM (#12373373) Journal
    Or Ultima V long. Those were the days.

  • by blackicye ( 760472 ) on Thursday April 28, 2005 @12:57PM (#12373569)
    I estimate I'm slightly past halfway into the game at present time. Everything I've seen so far I'd consider about par, its not a great game, but it doesn't totally suck.

    It also appears that most of the time, regardless of the multiple dialogue options offered, the NPCs will reply with identical messages.

    *warning possible spoilers follow*

    The combat system seems a bit shallow, case in point, I've gotten up to the Imperial City and up to the second tier of battles in the Gold Division of the Arena, Without using the block move a single time (on Master [normal] Difficulty)

    I am using Legendary Strike as my primary Hand to Hand combat style, and it is close to fully mastered, its not only a bit boring to play, its boring to look at too.

    I think maybe 2 attack buttons, a punch and a kick, as opposed to the single attack button, as well as some form of button combo system in addition to the silly (IMO) "Harmonic Combo" system would have added a great deal of depth to the game.
  • by EggyToast ( 858951 ) on Thursday April 28, 2005 @12:57PM (#12373576) Homepage
    A great deal of the time in longer RPGs is in the combat, which is turn-based and takes much longer.

    Similarly, combat is based on random encounters, rather than specific spots. For example, backtracking through an area in Final Fantasy will take a good half hour as you fight every other minute or so. In Jade Empire, it takes about 3 minutes, with 1 minute spent loading the area.

    Add all those times up and it's easy to see that if Jade Empire had turn-based combat with random encounters, it would easily take at least twice as long.

    As it is, it's a well-fleshed RPG without a great deal of padding -- most of the options and accessories deal more with choices you make for your character, rather than simply collecting everything. In fact, collecting everything will result in a shortage of money and an inability to max out the power of your styles.

    It's an interesting approach to it and it works quite well for this game.

  • Re:She looks cold. (Score:2, Interesting)

    by Morinaga ( 857587 ) on Thursday April 28, 2005 @01:07PM (#12373698)
    Yet every male Avatar depicted in games can play the xylaphone on his abs.

    Perhaps players don't care to depict Rosanne Barr nor John Madden when they wish to depict themselves in a fantasy world.

    I could be wrong.

  • by Anonymous Coward on Thursday April 28, 2005 @01:10PM (#12373727)
    Actually, I think Americans were doing great RPGs back in the 70's and 80's. Bard's Tale and Ultima spring to mind. Japanese RPGs often seem to scripted compared to some of my favorites, and the combat is often more about flash than real substance. (This is all opinion, of course, you may have had a different experience).

    It's not that the Japanese-style games aren't good, but they seem like a slightly different genre. Being more scripted, they can do an elaborate story, but it becomes more linear. Anyway, I usually end up playing them all.
  • by Inebrius ( 715009 ) on Thursday April 28, 2005 @01:27PM (#12373927)
    I would pay for Ultima 1-5 redone with updated graphics, slightly better interaction, and the story left completely intact.

    I wish companies would bring back some of the great games of the past with updated graphics, sound, and interfaces - and designed to work on modern systems without running in turbo blur mode.
  • by BoomerSooner ( 308737 ) on Thursday April 28, 2005 @01:34PM (#12374020) Homepage Journal
    Ultima IV & V were by far my favorites. I still haven't finished Ultima V. If my company ever makes me loaded I'm starting over in 1983 and working my way up to [current date]. I still haven't finished the first Baldur's Gate and it's hard sometimes to get these old games to run on a more current system.
  • Too Bad (Score:3, Interesting)

    by RichiP ( 18379 ) on Thursday April 28, 2005 @01:45PM (#12374161) Homepage
    Too bad it's XBox only. I really enjoy playing Neverwinter Nights (one of the few games to run natively on Linux). Jade Empire looks like a great game that I'd play if it ran on my gaming console (Sony PS2) or even on a Linux-based machine (don't have to buy the OS to run it on).
  • CRPG != RPG (Score:2, Interesting)

    by C0deM0nkey ( 203681 ) on Thursday April 28, 2005 @02:10PM (#12374467)
    This may be off-topic; mod as you see fit.

    I continue to be annoyed by the persistent use of the category "RPG" to describe video games. It's marketing hype. What particularly annoys me is when people equate the two:

    Player 1: "yeah, I've been playing RPGs for, like, 5 years."
    Player 2: "Really? What systems? D20? GURPS? Hero? Vampire? Shadowrun?"
    Player 1: "What? No. Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance."
    A fantasy or science fiction adventure video game is not an RPG. You are not playing a role - you are moving an avatar around on a screen and mashing buttons.

    I play video games - as a member of the Nintendo generation, it would be hard to escape them; presently, my 4-year old son and I are playing "Champions of Norrath". The fact that a 4-year old can play one of these games with a moderate level of competence is a testimony to the level of complexity found in an RPG video game; if this video game were an RPG, and my son was expected to assume a role and make decisions for himself, I doubt he would be able to grasp the concept of "free-play but with rules" let alone have any fun at it. Before you get your undies in a bundle, I know that "Champions" is not a particularly complex game - I bring it up because it is, in style, very similar to Baldur's Gate (mentioned in numerous other comments) which is often bronzed and placed on a pedestal by CRPG enthusiasts (until it is no longer vogue). Also, lest anyone think I'm doing all the work in the game, the game play is truly a "team" effort - I chose to play a Wizard and made my son a Barbarian - we are at a point in the game where it would be VERY difficult for me to go it alone and continue to advance if he were not there to back me up. At higher levels it would be nigh on impossible for a wizard to fight and defeat the boss characters alone (it can be done; but not without a *lot* of frustration).

    What differentiates a role-playing game from a video game, in my opinion, is the interface and options available to the player and what is at stake when you mess up. The interface in a video game is severely limiting: there are only so many button and key combinations available and when you make a mistake you simply reload the last save point. The interface in a role-playing game is virtually unlimited: your imagination. When you make a mistake in an RPG, you are often stuck with the consequences: it is a disservice to everyone at the table to rewrite history just to make everything turn out favorably for you. Suck it up - make a *new* character and lets go.

    These are huge distinctions; the only thing even remotely analagous between the two types of games would be the "munchkin/monty-haul/min-max" style of role-playing in which the players define character development as improved stats through beating monsters/obstacles and gaining treasures(if they define character development at all). Munchkin'ning is still more "RPG" than "grinding" through levels in a video game; in an RPG there is an opportunity to develop a unique character - you are likely to face different obstacles, have to consider your own verbal responses, etc. In a video game, every player ends up with essentially the same character who confronts the same "boss" who says the same things which lead to a fight where the bad guy uses the same tactics which can be overcome with the same technique in order to win. same...same...same...same. ugh.

  • Re:She looks cold. (Score:2, Interesting)

    by Temposs ( 787432 ) <temposs@@@gmail...com> on Thursday April 28, 2005 @02:47PM (#12374995) Homepage
    I would point to Yuna in Final Fantasy X, but not X 2. I think she wore pretty decent clothes for a main female heroine.
  • Re:Thats funny (Score:3, Interesting)

    by unclethursday ( 664807 ) on Thursday April 28, 2005 @07:14PM (#12377894)
    You seem to be under the impression that any reviews you read in magazines, or online are written by people who finish the game.

    It depends on the magazine and sites, really.

    I work for a review site, and I finish each and every game before I review it. My currently being out on long term disability helps; as does the fact that since we are a website, with no debug kits for any games, we have no "press time" to get the reviews out by. We have had one review that went up before the game was released, but only because we're friends with the game's developers.

    The few times they actually do are with A list titles, which are going to get steller reviews anyhow.

    Not always, Fable was an A List title, and I gave it a low score because it was, IMHO, a Piece of Shit(TM) that was over-hyped and too oft delayed. I beat it, 100% for my alignment, in 16 hours, and 4 hours of that was spent doing nothing but leveling up. That's all the side quests for my alignment, all the Demon Doors, all the secret weapons, etc. 12 hours to find and do all that? Pathetic. It's always going to depend on the sites and mags, really. Most sites and magazines hyped Fable up to be the Second Coming of Christ, and even the glowing reviews listed most of the faults I mentioned in my review... it's just that since they had hyped the game up beyond belief, they'd look like a bunch of cock smoking cum dumpsters if they gave it a low score after telling people it was the Best Game Evar(TM) long before it hit store shelves.

To program is to be.

Working...