Nintendo Promotes Music Piracy? 74
f-matic writes "A New York Times article discusses an amusing character in a popular virtual world: K.K. Slider, a travelling canine musician in Nintendo's Animal Crossing: Wild World, apparently promotes music piracy." From the article: "... it's a bit disorienting to find an 'information wants to be free' message embedded in a video game - particularly one aimed at young children and teenagers. After all, video game industry representatives, along with their brethren in the music, film and computer software industries, have long complained that this is precisely the kind of thinking that is eating away at their business models - and maybe civilization itself. "
Piracy? (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Article is absolutely stupid (Score:5, Interesting)
I disagree with that completely. You see, in Hungary exactly such is the situation: You cannot sign away the "rights" to your music. There is also an added measure, that you cannot not ask payment for your music, which conveniently a civilian agency called Artisjus enforces after deducting a certain percentage for their "efforts", want it or not, according to the current legislation.
That situation results in this nonsense: Let's suppose that you want to give music away for free on your homepage. Artisjus demands from you around 50 cents for each download. They then deduce around 10% of the total you payed to be able to put your own music for free on the website and make some trickery with charts etc, and in a lucky case you get around 10 cents back from Artisjus as your "profit". That is all in the name of protecting the artist using early 20th century legislation which was supposed to prevent artists being pressured into signing their rights away over music they made.
This stupid law killed my favorite amateur music compilation which was housed on some popular hungarian IT magazine's CD back in 1998.
Trust me, you don't want the government to protect you. In the end it will be perverted and used against you.
Re:No Nintendo Doesn't (Score:3, Interesting)
I don't want to know what the ??AA thinks about the idea that a person using their right of free speech to express their political/economic views, in a copyrighted, reproduced, and marketed way, is a valuable thing (in a monetary sense).
This is exactly how pundits make their living; they excersize their free speech, people pay to hear it, and the circle of life completes itself.
Pundits have a funny way of swaying public opinion... a popular pundit may be many things (including a liar), but stupid isn't one of them. Espescially when the subject is about expressing the same kind of views that earns a pundit a soft life.
K.K.'s Name (Score:4, Interesting)
Quick reality check (Score:3, Interesting)
*blinks*
I wonder if this guy wrote the article with a straight face. And I smell cat pee.
Conflicting theory: (Score:3, Interesting)
Also, even though K.K. is apparently supporting piracy, there's no in-game way for players to duplicate K.K. Slider's "airchecks" and share them with other players. Nor is there any indication that these "bootlegs" are pirated copies of published work. His songs are, for all intents and purposes, bound to their distribution media. Some people are reading way too much into this.