Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
Education Nintendo Portables Games

Nintendo Developing DS Apps For School Systems 40

Posted by timothy
from the not-quite-swords-into-ploughshares dept.
MojoKid writes "Shigeru Miyamoto, who has had a hand in some of Nintendo's most popular titles, recently offered that he is working hard to turn Nintendo's DS line of handheld gaming machines into tools for schools. The DS already has a nice line of educational software titles that help users learn, and he thinks that this could really be a huge benefit to schools looking for alternative ways to educate students of a new generation. The company has already managed to get them into Japanese elementary schools."
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Nintendo Developing DS Apps For School Systems

Comments Filter:
  • I'm not sure I see how this would help Nintendo. Doesn't every school-age kid already have a DS? It sure seems that way among all the kids I've seen lately...

    Maybe if the school versions were remotely monitored? The teacher could use a DSi XL to view 93% more students!

    • Re:Everyone... (Score:5, Informative)

      by carlzum (832868) on Sunday March 21, 2010 @03:13AM (#31555680)
      It helps Nintendo because every school-age kid has a DS. They're familiar with the system and interface, so basic typing and computer skills aren't a prerequisite for the software. The platform seems perfect for class use, and it's low cost and easy to support. Like you said, every kid has one. A model for schools would open a whole new market for the DS.
      • by Fluffeh (1273756)
        It also helps Nintendo as it's ANOTHER market for them to develop, grow, make money off. It's what the entertainment industry SHOULD be doing as a whole - "Hmmmm, how else could we look at making money..." rather than "Lets try to sue people because our business model is no longer making money..."

        RIAA (and all you similar minded corps) take note of this brash concept - update and improve your business models!

        Side note: Way to go Nintendo!
  • by Judinous (1093945) on Sunday March 21, 2010 @02:34AM (#31555576)
    The fact that this hasn't been pushed for before is rather surprising. The DS has been one of the most cost-effective digital kanji dictionaries for years. It costs about half as much as most comparable touch-screen devices and, obviously, it has other uses as well. It's right at the top of the list of tools for non-native speakers trying to learn Japanese, so it seems only natural that it would be at home in Japanese classrooms as well.
    • Re: (Score:1, Insightful)

      by Anonymous Coward

      This is true. Honestly, the only thing holding me back from supporting this is the same thing that has irritated me about the use of Windows and Macintosh computers in schools for ages now - schools are supposed to be places of learning. Having something in them which you're legally forbidden to learn about is... contradictory.

      • Re: (Score:2, Insightful)

        by sourcerror (1718066)

        I think the bigger problem was that digital tools weren't integrated in the curriculum, they were always kind of gimmick.

    • It's an ideal platform for language-learning software in general. The portability, quick suspend mode, touch screen, speakers, and microphone make it perfectly suited to the task.

      Unfortunately, the only software of the sort that I've seen is the (if I recall the title correctly) "My [language name here] Tutor" line, which is limited to (AFAIK) four languages and--at least for French--sucks. They're not nearly as good as Rosetta Stone (not even in the same ballpark), they (again, extrapolating from the Fre

      • Namely that it's marketed to get you good at a language but even if you go through all three levels, you may have attained 15% fluency. I used it only a few hours - does anybody have more experience?

        • It's better than anything else I've seen. You still need a lot of grammar and listening/speaking study outside of it, but it's good for vocabulary building and basic sentence structure.

    • They tried edutainment stuff in the early days of the Famicom and NES, but these failed to take off nearly as well as the games. IMO it's not surprising that they'd be cautious in going down the road that burned them before-- and Miyamoto would know, he was there back in those days.

      Another possibility is that they wanted to see what the market would do before moving in with their own ideas.

  • I just want another Mario Teaches Typing.
    • They will never teach typing in school because it's far too useful for the general population. If everybody knew how to type, then any ol' high school grad could make $14/hr. Ho! Watch college enrollment drop right off.

      They will never teach how to drive a car or money management. They will never teach resumes or job interview. They will never teach physical fitness or weight training. They will never teach oil change or tire rotation. These are all "electives."

      They will never teach speech or diction

  • They should call the Nintendo DS a "Macintosh" and say that it has all kinds of educational software. They will get loads of sales to schools.

    That strategy kept Apple afloat for two decades before they invented the iPod.

    Just make sure the 'DS comes with WYSIWG text editor, and a primitive paint program with a brick tileset and "spraypaint" brush. Bonus points if they revert to black and white.

    • by rworne (538610) on Sunday March 21, 2010 @03:20AM (#31555698) Homepage

      From what I remember of the "old days" dealing with my high school's foray into teaching basic computing... excuse me... BASIC computing.

      They planned on getting a full class of 30 or so students instead of the 6 or so that were supported by a TRS-80 model III and an apple II and an Apple II+.

      The school got a shipment of 20+ Atari 800's with floppy drives. They sat in a closet for an entire year because the district refused to let the school use them. Why? When they heard "Atari" they thought 2600 VCS and videogames and could not comprehend that Atari also made computers.

      This kind of closed-minded thinking will also kill off any idea of using the DS as an educational tool in the school districts.

    • by tepples (727027)

      Just make sure the 'DS comes with WYSIWG text editor, and a primitive paint program with a brick tileset and "spraypaint" brush. Bonus points if they revert to black and white.

      DSOrganize, which needs a homebrew card, is disturbingly close to what you describe. It's too bad Nintendo has been suing to stop the sale of DS homebrew cards.

  • by AuMatar (183847) on Sunday March 21, 2010 @02:59AM (#31555650)

    Normally, I laugh off reports like this. But if Miyamoto says he's doing it, I give it a high probability of working. The guy is a damn genius. And seeing he did the impossible and brought old people into gaming with titles like Wii Sports, I think he may even actually pull off an educational game that's worth a damn.

    • Re: (Score:3, Interesting)

      by Belial6 (794905)
      Honestly, the DS already has a ton of educational titles that are worth a damn. It is a full on genre on the DS.
  • by Statecraftsman (718862) * on Sunday March 21, 2010 @03:20AM (#31555702) Homepage
    Nintendo is a company dear to many of our hearts since many of us are nostalgic for their early games. They've continued to innovate in game play and still provide a lot of pleasure in leisure time. That being said, they are only rivaled by Apple in their record of locking down their proprietary systems. In gaming, it's not a big deal but in education, it's another story.

    In education, we need to avoid putting up artificial walls where they needn't exist. Children should be free to explore as long as they're not a danger to themselves or others. That's why free software is essential in education. It encourages cooperation, learning, and exploration. I fear that Nintendo is going to continue to lock down their systems when they're used in an educational setting and if that's the case, we should skip it. There's nothing worse than a teacher having to answer a question with, "That's just the way Nintendo made it I guess."
    • by santax (1541065)
      Help me out here. And what is the bad part about not having the source-code of a program that let's say, teaches math? I love open source as much as the next slashdotter but I don't see your point here. Nintendo is known for the 'it works' way of developing software. It just works and it works great. I can't come with a single from nintendo inhouse that really sucks and I see no reason to think their educational software will be any different.
    • That being said, they are only rivaled by Apple in their record of locking down their proprietary systems

      Not even Apple is a rival. Apple compares more to Microsoft; in fact, the iPhone developer program was a dead ringer for XNA Creators Club on the Xbox 360. Nintendo won't let you in unless you're an established company with a "secure business location" (specifically not a home office) and a published commercial title on another platform (citation [warioworld.com]).

    • And that said, I would still welcome Nintendo/Apple to come in and make ripples in the educational software market with wide open arms.

      Why?
      Because right now educational software, at least in primary schools, sure as hell could use someone to come in and figure out how to make it "just work", with good intuitive interfaces. While I'm sure there's good edu software out there somewhere, it sure wasn't in any of the primary schools I've seen in the last few years. Heck, Apple and a blown-up iPhone OS could be

  • Do they plan to release a programming language? That is part of what made TI calculators so popular. Nintendo could learn from that model. (Well, before TI DRM'd them)

  • It's a noble cause, but there are questions [csmonitor.com] as to whether or not Brain Age and its ilk work as advertised. Some [bbc.co.uk] have found success in improving math scores. Still, results are inconclusive [findingdulcinea.com]. Given how strapped our schools are for cash right now, it's hard see them snapping up a bunch of DS' and software for questionable benefits.
    • by skids (119237)

      It's not that it can't be done, it's that it can't be done unless you actually test the effectiveness of the software and apply the results of those tests towards making a better product.

      We need a certification board for this sort of stuff. Some sort of program that tests software that claims to teach on actual students (in those special schools where teachers get "hands on training"), and also has cognitive scientists and educational professionals evaluate the software by a set of well-thought-out metrics

  • From a business perspective, why hasn't Nintendo already chased the education market?

    But seriously, it is 2010, how about a device that has reasonable screen real estate and operating system?

    We can build much better devices, even at a reasonable cost. Let us start with a screen big enough to read something on, at least 5" if not bigger. Second we need a programmable OS to run on these, Android, Win 7 new mobile OS, New Palm, even an apple tablet.

    A couple years ago I would have thought great. Today

  • A DSi: Graphical device with touch screen, WiFi, Web Browser, 2 Cameras, SD card, Custom Cartridge. Does it have IR? Some kind of external port?

    There was a embroidery sewing machine that used a GameBoy Color + custom cartridge as its computer. Many sewers back then (1999?) didn't have computers and adding a $200 GameBoy to a $2000 sewing machine was cheaper then a $1000 PC.

    Palm PDAs with the infrared port have been used to simulate the spread of a disease through a population. Give all the students the

He keeps differentiating, flying off on a tangent.

Working...