Nintendo DS Network 195
Kamalot writes "It looks like Nintendo is preparing a wireless peer-to-peer network of Nintendo DS ' to allow a new way of playing games online. Each Nintendo DS could includes a repeater hub to extend and share an 802.11 signal. A thread on GameCubicle unveils more, including a service called MarioNette and some disturbing marketing pieces with hidden images and messages." As with everything involving the new handhelds, take this one with a grain of salt.
DS wins (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:DS wins (Score:5, Interesting)
I guess it could work to automatically network to any other DS's within a set range, but over a wide area, what happens when some dipshit turns off his DS and breaks the very tenuous chain of DS's transmitting through the rural area between two urban areas (where there are more people and probably far more DS's floating around)? I admit I'm not as knowledgeable about wireless networks as wired ones, but I don't see this working on a large scale, and on a smaller scale, why even bother with building a hub into every DS?
With all its problems, the N-Gage probably was closer to the spot with a wider area gaming network. The cell phone network is already there, and although it's not 100% reliable (especially if you're moving around between cells), it's got far less random factors involved than a p2p DS network.
Just sounds too cool to be true. At least the hoax about the PSP price was believable. The PSP will be a lot closer to $350 than the DS will be to this p2p distributed network.
Re:DS wins (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:DS wins (Score:2, Informative)
The GameCube is network-capable. Five games have been designed to take advantage of this feature (Mario Kart: Double Dash!!, Kirby Air Ride, and 1080 can play LAN games, and Phantasy Star Online Episodes 1-3 can play via Internet).
Re:DS wins (Score:3, Insightful)
Even more so to the point, Nintendo had a successful radio gameplay network in Japan that IIRC dates back to the Super Nintendo.
And somebody else made a point about Nintendo not doing things half-assed. With the exception of the virtual boy it's true. Look at the wavebird controller as a great example of doing something right. They advertise a certain distance, the controller can double and triple that distance and still work easily.
Re:DS wins (Score:2)
Don't get me wrong its a lot of fun, and I am glad they included it. Even if it feels like no time was spent on the multi-cube link except to get it working. I have family and friends that have purchased Gamecubes and networ
Re:DS wins (Score:2)
I just gotta jab in
Cut Every Corner
Shery: If there's a task that must be done,
Don't turn your tail and run,
Don't pout, don't sob,
Just do a half-assed job!
If... you... cut every corner
It is really not so bad,
Everybody does it,
Even mom and dad.
If nobody sees it,
Then nobody gets mad,
Bart: It's the American way!
Shery: The policeman on the beat
Needs some time to rest his feet.
Chief Wiggum: Fighting crime is not my cup of tea!
Re:DS wins (Score:2)
Yep... and Nintendo is a Japanese company... ;-)
Re:DS wins (Score:2)
Of course, Nintendo didn't write the game. Nevertheless, it's a concern.
Re:DS wins (Score:2)
Gamecube is hardly worthless; it may not have as wide of a library of games as a PS2, but it does have some damn good ones.
Re:DS wins (Score:2)
And neither do the people who own Xbox. It's still set for 'TBA2005', which means it probably isn't very close to being done.
Re: (Score:2)
Re:DS wins (Score:2)
Re:DS wins (Score:2)
It may not be an issue of strapping on another piece of hardware. All of the DS's will have 802.11b, and the processing power is pretty reasonable. There's a good chance that they will be able to form ad-hoc networks without the need of any other hardware to be installed. What I'm describing, though wouldn't be nearly what the article is suggesting. I'm picturing something along the lines of a b
Re:DS wins (Score:2)
Unless you think that buying a peripheral somehow adds hardware to the host?
It's possible (Score:4, Funny)
However, the real question is:
Who shall save the poor boy out in the wilderness tied into the internet via the DSes the bears ate along with unsuspecting tourists who dared feed them! *
* - Providing this is true, of course.
Re:It's possible (Score:2)
There really *was* a famicom network - it had online banking and gambling services if I remember correctly.
Re:It's possible (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:It's possible (Score:3)
Very cool idea (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Very cool idea (Score:2)
If only the DS had a permanent memory storage device, like an internal flash chip...I bet someone would have Linux and Kismet/Airsnort/[choose your favorite] running on it within six months.
Well, really... (Score:2)
A lot of consoles are moving toward having some kind of permanent internal storage (PS2, XBox). It wouldn't surprise me if the DS did too. Hell, the media format sounds like it might be something like SD. Maybe they'll shock the hell out of us and make it SD for real (or something that's form-compatible with it, and let you browse digital camera SD cards with a simple file browser or something). Sky's the limit with this machine.
Re:Very cool idea (Score:3, Informative)
Why walk with him? (Score:2)
You'd just use the GPS to track that they are going to new places to randomly give them chips while gathering wireless network info in the background, when they sync with the internet to process their new chips it sends you the net infomation, you scour over it and next time they sync you have the game tell the kid to go back
The future SkyNet? (Score:5, Funny)
Alternatively, look for the first Nintendo DS virus to forcibly re-direct all WiFi-based HTTP requests that use your DS as an AP to the Goatse-man site.
Re:The future SkyNet? (Score:2)
Say hello to AIBO, destroyer of worlds! Piro-riro, bitch.
Re:The future SkyNet? (Score:2)
No. I'm sure I don't want a copy.
Re:The future SkyNet? (Score:2)
Killer App? (Score:5, Interesting)
The potential hinted at by these new revelations [gamecubicle.com] totally trancends your basic "sit around in a group and play wirelessly" functionality. If this (the repeater functionality) is in any way true, then it will make the touch-screen part of the DS look about as groundbreaking as MP3 support on a Sony player, and it makes the PSP's infra-red wireless gaming look like a silly kids' toy.
Seriously, wide-area gaming would be the killer app for handheld consoles. Imagine some sort of asynchronous MMPORG-style game whereby when a fellow player's DS is detected, some form of battle can take place. Some sort of modern take on the old style Campus 'Assassin' games [uwsp.edu].
Not to mention the facilitation of true munchkin-style [gadgetophile.com] ubiquitous networking.
Just to be clear... (Score:5, Interesting)
But i gotta say, alot of the messages are very cool, almost like Nintendo's ilovebees.com on a much smaller scale.
OT: what is ilovebees.com? (Score:1)
Re:OT: what is ilovebees.com? (Score:2)
Re:Just to be clear... (Score:2)
How long... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:How long... (Score:5, Funny)
Well, I think the name simply means they plan on using you as a puppet, so why not?
But if all kids playing extend the 802.11b network and allow me to connect with my laptop from anywhere, I totally agree and support Nintendo!
Re:How long... (Score:5, Funny)
We apologize for the error in the reply. Those responsible have been sacked.
Problems with this? (Score:5, Interesting)
1. Early adopters will get spottier connection capabilities than those that wait til tons of people have them? (much larger network based on the repeater concept).
2. What if I am connecting via John D.S. and suddenly he drops off of my range? Will I lose my connection and game? This would um...whats the word? Oh yeah...suck.
Decisions Decisions (Score:5, Insightful)
It's hard to decide right now, with all the speculation going on. However, Nintendo has backwards compatibility, low-battery using cartridges [gamespot.com] innovative dual screen [gamestracker.co.uk] and not to mention a ridicoulsly awesome track record for good first party games.
The price point [slashdot.org] is even on par with an 'upscale' portable system.
Let's be serious for a minute. What can the PSP offer me that is worth it's (expected) retail price? I really don't want to play my PS2 titles on the go, and the UMD media thing doesn't make me feel all warm and fuzzy either. Look at Wario Ware Inc. [nintendo.com] if you want to know why you will buy a DS. It's in the games man. The games. Oh, and the price too.Re:Decisions Decisions (Score:2)
However, from what I've heard, the PSP's screen is absolutely beautiful, and I can understand the appeal of being able to play a port of a PS2 game like Gran Turismo 4 on the go.
Is a PSP going to be worth $300 or $400 to me though? That's what I'm not so sure of. It sounds cool, but it also sounds like they are going for a different market than just handheld gaming.
I am pretty sure I would not buy movies released on UMD format thou
Re:Decisions Decisions (Score:2)
Heck yes. I've been anticipating the PSP, but if users can't write their own UMDs, I'll forget about it. I would have liked something like a multifunction MD player, but without being able to record UMDs, that's dashed. I'm guessing that third parties making UMD writers is probably out of the question.
I'm kind of doubtful of the publicly speculated pricing but Sony has been known t
Re:Decisions Decisions (Score:2)
If sony gives us the ability to copy and share content, they worry that their media sales drop. But if they protect their media they risk a drop in hardware sales.
Must
Re:Decisions Decisions (Score:2)
Re:Decisions Decisions (Score:2)
Someone told me that I could get a PS2 keyboard.
and of course, "PS2 won't do. My ps2 port's taken by the wireless keyboard."
So that was pretty silly.
A PS2 USB keyboard...
Can you use a PS2 keyboard with a ps2/usb adapter and hook it up to the usb port of a PS2, or the other way around?
Re:Decisions Decisions (Score:2)
An exceptional game you can't get on PS2?
Re:Decisions Decisions (Score:2)
Unless you think they've already got one in the wings, otherwise you have to wait 6 months or a year or however long for a killer app to be released. With the DS, there's innovation to play with immediately.
Maybe it's just me, but hoping that a great exclusive might come out in the future is not enough to warrant a purchase.
Re:Decisions Decisions (Score:2)
I'll be getting the DS, though-- probably at launch if I can manage to get my hands on one. I'm already convinced it'll be good and the price isn't THAT bad. The PSP I'm still planning to wait and see on. I could get two PS2 units for the hinted retail price they're talking about for the PSP.
I hope they're secure... (Score:4, Insightful)
I can just see someone writing a virus that forcibly installs a miniature Linux distro on your DS and propagates.
I'm not sure if that would be horrible or awesome, personally.
Re:I hope they're secure... (Score:4, Informative)
Based upon that, I would guess that if there were an exploit, it would be caused by a specific game, and could at most ruin that specific cart. In which case, it serves the developer right...
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:I hope they're secure... (Score:2)
Re:I hope they're secure... (Score:2)
Remove the battery (Score:1)
If there's so much as a single remote code exploit found in the DS, it won't be long before someone writes code to forcibly propagate itself and do something to your DS
Unless the DS boot blocks can be overwritten, I wouldn't worry. Remove the battery when in contagious zones and you won't propagate anything.
something like the PSO bug for GameCube would be lethal on the DS, if it were wirelessly exploitable.
Lethal? How? I can see how it might end up harmful to Nintendo's business model in that it e
Re:Remove the battery (Score:3, Informative)
You can remove the SP's battery it's got a small screw holding it in. So anyhow you failed slashdot go to your room!
Re:I hope they're secure... (Score:2)
I can just see someone writing a virus that forcibly installs a miniature Linux distro on your DS and propagates.
"
Umm, seeing as how the DS doesn't have any storage for this sort of thing, how does this really rate as an insightful comm
Re:I hope they're secure... (Score:2)
Which is why that was mostly an exercise in wishful thinking.
This is News? (Score:4, Insightful)
This is all they've developed this huge "OMG TEH W1RELESS GAMING!!!" story from? Ever think that a boy using a gameboy in the forest to navigate might be a 'pushing the frontiers' image? or an 'immersive environment' image? It's a very amiguous photograph, and I'd like to know how this rumour sprang from nowhere, based solely on one picture and a 'find me' slogan
Move along, nothing to see here.
Re:This is News? (Score:2)
Come on, man. Even if it's full of shit, it's fun to dream about pervasive wireless networking. But speaking as somebody who's USED the Pokemon GBA wireless adapter, it'll probably be slow, weak crap.
FCC test report of Nintendo DS (Score:5, Informative)
Coral P2P link to FCC report [nyud.net]
or
Direct FCC link to report [fcc.gov]
More info on Coral distribution network [nyu.edu]
Re:FCC test report of Nintendo DS (Score:5, Informative)
Re:FCC test report of Nintendo DS (Score:2)
Tagline (Score:1)
Battery Life (Score:5, Insightful)
I would assume they would have to have a toggle switch for airplanes if nothing else...
C'mon now (Score:5, Insightful)
Now, if for some insane reason the DS has a 1+ mile range then yeah, that's amazing. But I can guarantee that that is not the case. It's just a way to play online with people within sighting distance. Will come in handy in urban areas, colleges, etc. But Tommy in Montana might have a hard time finding 100 opponents.
Re:C'mon now (Score:2)
Re:C'mon now (Score:2)
Re:C'mon now (Score:2)
Re:C'mon now (Score:2)
Fair enough, but Tony Montana could easily find 100 opponents.
http://games.slashdot.org (Score:5, Funny)
"Unsubstantiated rumours and wild-ass guesses for nerds"
Speaking of Wild-ass guesses... (Score:2)
Re:http://games.slashdot.org (Score:2)
Bluff that matters.
Sweet! (Score:2, Funny)
What about battery life? (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:What about battery life? (Score:3, Informative)
Re:What about battery life? (Score:2)
What about gaming over the internet? (Score:2)
Pokemon Fire Red/Leaf Green (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Pokemon Fire Red/Leaf Green (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Pokemon Fire Red/Leaf Green (Score:2)
Side view? (Score:2)
LS
Re:Side view? (Score:2)
One slight problem (Score:2, Insightful)
Perhaps the DS simply includes a function that allows you to physically find other DS players. Like you know there is another DS player 100m to the north of you. This would be a great way to meet people, except that Hot Jenna is probably a
Re:One slight problem (Score:2)
Re:One slight problem (Score:2)
I've played big Advance Wars 4 way tournaments with my friends, and they were hella fun...EXCEPT they were too slow, and even the slightest jolt on any of the cables stopped everybody's game. Annoying.
A game like Advance Wars, Pokemon or Shining Soul would be a lot of fun when hanging out, IF they were wireless, fast, and could deal
Here's a clue stick (Score:5, Informative)
These are not "marketing pieces" and Nintendo is not planning a p2p Wireless Network.
The story: there's some guy named Chad who is the lead developer on Warp Pipe (a tunnelling system that lets Gamecube owners play LAN games against each other on the internet). There's this other guy Dean from n-sider.com who knows Chad.
A few days ago, it was posted that Warp Pipe got new offices in Chicago. Combined with this, it was also known the Warp Pipe attended E3. Apparently after E3 Warp Pipe became quiet about their future plans.
Fast forward to a couple of days ago, Chad posted the picture with the kid and the dog. After that, Dean posted a pick of the Marionette (which is photoshopped from an original Ragnarok Online piece of art http://www.prontera.net/cards/marionette_l.jpg. Dean claims he needed a Marionette.
The third picture (with the guy missing eyes) is another photoshop job by Dean. Chad said there would be a logo on the box of some games (DS? Gamecube?) that when you bought them, Warp Pipe would receive money. They both also said that this news will not be broken by Nintendo in their upcoming Oct 7 press conference.
I think you're having delusions of grandeur... (Score:2)
You _MAY_ be able to access the Mario Net from places like starbucks and airports, but it's likely it'll simply start from home and expand from there.
Wireless networking is good for game sales (Score:3, Insightful)
This is potentially one of the biggest cashcows nintendo has ever dreamed up.
Even without adhoc wireless repeaters and a range of just 150m, that's more than ample for any mall/school etc.
Imagine kids using the touchscreen to write secret notes in class - cheat on their exams etc. Man I wish i was back in school!
anybody remember the initial 'marionette' rumors? (Score:3, Insightful)
But, yes, Nintendo has been toying with online content for a long time in Japan. They've known better than to try online with add-on products in the states, though, so any online strategy with the DS will have to be integrated in the launch hardware.
Furthermore, Nintendo knows that this is their last shot at getting the older gaming population to buy into portable gaming. They don't want to get beat by Sony a second time to the older-gaming spenders, and the remarkably early launch of the DS before PSP, along with this rumored adult-ish marketing campaign, makes total sense. Kudos to NOA for getting their heads out of Japan's ass and getting aggressive.
Nintendo Gimmick #408407 (Score:2)
I'm figuring that this will either be an underutilized feature on incapable budget hardware or the DS is gonna fall way above the impulse buy range everybody is counting on. After all, if the hardware can do half of what they're claiming... Nah. This screams "Pay attention to meeeeeeee!"
Marionette has meaning and Wi-Fi's not alone. (Score:3, Informative)
A Nintendo network for the DS would be fairly easy to do. You only need to maintain a matchmaking service. Basically it's the same Xbox Live does (matchmaking and then letting one console be the host to others), but the footprint and requirements for DS games are quite smaller and there's no HDD to download patches to, therefore the service could be very cheap, paid by simple marketing schemes or even free.
By the way, Wi-Fi is not the only wireless protocol the DS has built-in. It also includes a proprietary wireless chipset, probably devoted to game requirements, like using lower frequencies and throughput than 802.11b to maximize range and battery power, and optimized to not include IP to avoid overhead/latency and simplify connectivity between users.
It's also desirable to avoid hotspot authentication when connecting locally since it can really be a nightmare because some hotspots are not configured to allow connectivity between machines on the same network, they only route to the outside and that could mean a lot of headaches for local users.
As much as I like Wi-Fi, it has limitations and can't really be considered "Plug and Play" (imagine typing your credit card number or WEP key on the DS screen in order to access a Boingo hotspot in an airport), so I definitely support the simplicity of another wireless protocol specifically made to run games locally and nothing else.
Bogus (Score:4, Funny)
That, and can you imagine playing games over a P2P network? Okay, I'm playing Metroid Prime: Hunters. I am facing off against my mortal enemy. We each have one bullet left, taking cover behind the tattered remains of the arena in which we fought. (Yes I know Samus doesn't use bullets but bear with me.) Suddenly, she takes a flying leap from behind a pillar! No! I shrink into a Morph Ball and dodge, then rise back up and pray that I can hit her first...
But, I neglected to mention that she is in Montana, and we are connected by a kid playing DS over his lunch break who is thirty feet away from somebody who is lollygagging on a park bench who is thirty feet away from somebody who is playing the DS on the can... and just as I emerge from my Morph Ball to stare my enemy in the face, the guy finishes washing his hands and walks out of the bathroom, DS in hand, and the connection is broken.
WHAAAAT?! Uuuuuaaarggghhh! I'll stick with hotspots, thank you very much.
So anyway, I'm sure whatever Warp Pipe has cooking is super ultra mega exciting; but there is nothing to suggest that Nintendo is in on it, nor that it is a P2P network, which are the two main points of the article. I hope Slashdot sees it fit to update the article with a retraction; they're busy people and I don't blame them for being duped by the hype, but, you know, they were still duped.
Re:Bogus (Score:2)
Wolf in the woods.... (Score:2)
Re:Reimnds me of that other thing.. (Score:1, Informative)
It's still around and has an active development community.
Re:Reimnds me of that other thing.. (Score:5, Informative)
I had one of those. It was crap. The keyboard was too small to do anything comfortably, the battery only worked until about a month after I got it, and the AC input port physically broke a month after that.
Several friends had them too, and they all had the same problems.
Re:Reimnds me of that other thing.. (Score:2)
* Peer-to-peer chat and gaming - the most obvious
* A free SDK with a reasonably well-designed API
* A WML browser that could use another Cybiko connected to a PC as an access point
I really think that if Cybiko had waited a few more years, outfitted the device with a faster processor, a backlit color screen and WiFi, they would've made a fortune. And pulled the rug right out from under Nintendo, I might add
Re:Reimnds me of that other thing.. (Score:5, Funny)
Papyrus? Parchment? Stone tablets? Man, if the battery life on PDAs sucks now, what was it like in 200? :)
Re:DS? shouldnt that be GB (Score:5, Informative)
Re:DS? shouldnt that be GB (Score:3, Insightful)
And, speaking as a game developer, it is.
Groundbreaking... (Score:4, Insightful)
"So, the DS can run in Ad-Hoc mode, and AP mode. This is groundbreaking because.......????"
Because no mainstream handheld gaming console has ever had this functionality...basically.
Re:Why? (Score:2)
In general, I agree that extra features are annoying and unneeded, especially if they're not done well. (see sidetalking) I know I certainly don't want a device that can do everything at once but nothing well.
On the other hand, it's already been confirmed that the DS is going to launch at 150 bucks... pretty damn good for what it seems to be offering. Even though this whole story