Id Auctioning Off SGI That Created Q2 And Q3A 111
shiwala writes: "id software is auctioning the SGI Origin 2000 used to process all of the map data for Quake II and Quake III Arena." Hemos and I have been debating auctioning off the case that was the 2nd Slashdot (for a six months). I've been trying to find the alpha that was Slashdot for the first 9 months of its life (it served the first million pages: if I only knew that we would serve that many pages every day). Probably donate the $ to the FSF or Project Gutenberg or something. Anyway this id box amuses me: opening bid is $7500.
Re:IANAQ (Score:1)
In an unrelated story... (Score:3)
Lots of processing power... (Score:1)
What in God's name could they have done to it to make half the processors die? That's an expensive mistake!
Re:But... (Score:1)
I'm surprised... (Score:1)
Re:its auctioned because linux blows it away (Score:1)
Lastly, compare Infinite Reality 3 graphics with *any* PC graphics card. The PC crap won't even come *close* to catching it.
Auction: id software selling used fridge (Score:1)
Starting bid, $7,500.
Note: 4/8 lightbulbs dead.
from Scancode
High bidder! (Score:1)
Just wondering though, why does it say seller pays shipping in the header, then in the description ID is saying I have to pay the shipping???
This did not compute
Re:retail? (Score:2)
I wonder what they're replacing it with. If I had one of those things, I'd really hate to see it go - they have panache.
D
----
Re:Imagine... (Score:1)
Good Idea (Score:1)
Maybe Corel can auction off Wine machines (that Corel office first emulated on) to make payroll around October time.
Or maybe Confusious will auction off his new Athlon with 256 MB ram that has been rumored to run Star Office 5.2 and Mozilla at the same time (with almost enough memory and MIPS left for Confusious to play Mahjongg)...mmmm...sweeet
Re:It's a supercomputer that's why! (Score:4)
With Apple claiming the G4 as supercomputer, you will actually need to subtract processors from your Origin to make it meet todays standard of supercomputing.
--Shoeboy
Re:ID once tried to sell their NeXT machines ... (Score:1)
Re:Things to consider when buying (Score:1)
Do you really get that much computing out of it? I've got a P133 with 6 SCSI drives that I don't run because its just too damned expensive.
Re:Au contraire (Score:1)
Re:Yeah, but does it run vi? (Score:1)
What you noticed about the machine plodding through code (but a lot of it at once) is because the point of Origin is for parallel programs. The fastest way to run a program with n threads is on an n processor machine (neglecting other activity). So, if you aren't writing parallel code, you get basically no benefit from a parallel system. The way to speed up single thread code in the supercomputing world is to run on a vector based system.
Re:IANAQ (Score:1)
Re:Imagine... (Score:1)
Re:Anyone care to answer a question? (Score:1)
Think about the number of levels in Quake 2 or Quake 3, and the number of times they need to be compiled before they're complete, and that's quite a bit of computing time. Especially when the game has deadlines, and levels often have to be rebuild due to changing requirements/features of the game engine. Level designers who are designing levels for an in-progress game will tell you that it's much harder (and levels require many more builds) than when you're working with a finished, stable game engine.
There are, what, 50 maps in Quake 2? If each one takes a couple of hours to build, that's a little over 4 days to build them all a single time. It's possible that the tools they used on that Origin 2000 were more accurate and slower (comparitively) than the Intel/win32 equivalents, so that could require more computing power also. You can see how it would all add up to a lot of computing time... and obviously you don't want to be building levels on the same machine the designer is still trying to work on...
Re:Imagine... (Score:1)
Drink more tea
organicgreenteas.com [organicgreenteas.com]
If you're going to donate it... (Score:1)
Yeah, that's the ticket.
Re:So? (Score:1)
I'm sorry, I had thought that you were trolling.
-----
Re:SGI that created Quake (Score:1)
Re:Obligatory Poll Mastah Poll (Score:1)
.plan entries (Score:3)
here [idsoftware.com] are a few pictures of the actual machine.
retail? (Score:1)
I'm sure somebody will get a good deal on it.
how much was one of them things when it was spankin new?
________
auctions / economic changes / etc (Score:2)
Now, there *are* professional bidders already, of course, but they're not something the ordinary Joe gets to use. There are specialized professional bidders in all kinds of esoteric things, but of course that's not what you're talking about. The interesting thing about near-simultaneous, wide-ranging electronic communications is that the level at which it's practical to have things like this creeps lower -- you don't have to be as rich to use such services if you're paying incrementally in combination with other people (services like ubid.com), and the actual bidding services can be done cheaper and for products for which it wouldn't have made sense a few years ago. (priceline.com, for instance -- groceries etc).
Even pricewatch.com can be seen as a sort of reverse auction, where you can say "Gee, I'm looking for a D-Link PCMCIA modem / ethernet card. Wonder who can give me the best deal on one?" -- BAM a few search terms later, you find one ($128, as of yesterday). Much nicer than trying to sort through dozens of sites for a few bucks' difference.
And the new-economy thing I want to see most is the chance to "roll for more" as featured in R. Heinlein's "The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress." It's been a few years, but I believe the basic concept is, when buying anything from a meal to a motel room, it's traditional to pay slightly more in exchange for the chance to win it for free instead. It's gambling, so the house wins (in aggregate) but the player sometimes wins, and to the player wins large. (I'd like that at Motel 6, for instance
Of course, given current ridiculous attitudes about gambling this isn't likely to happen, but
simon
Do you think.... (Score:1)
Enditallnow
Re:SGI that created Quake (Score:1)
Re:Well, why not? (Score:2)
Errrr
It looks to me like you're predicting that once we disintermediate everything we're going to find it's TOO DAMN MUCH HASSLE to live without the dissed intermediaries and we're going to reintermediate right back.
I think I'm with you on that, actually. Now, how can we make an IPO out of this?
I could use that! (Score:1)
-
Re:IANAQ (Score:1)
And no, I haven't rendered a 3D game myself (though I have written a few simple Open GL programs). However, I *do* work with Origin hardware and software *every* day since my group is responsible for kernel support on it.
I will ask some people Monday, though, about the 2010 and I'll post more then (if anyone's actually heard of it...)
Re:It's a supercomputer that's why! (Score:1)
To compare (Score:1)
Here [spec.org] is a dell PIII 733.
You'll find the PIII system has better intger proformance and the Origin better floating point proformance. But, the tests are run only using _one_ cpu... and from I read in previous posts the origin is focusing on really fast IO.
Free advertising? (Score:1)
Re:i'm in this too (Score:2)
Aw... come on, why not?
Because IBMs, like coffee, porn, and enjoying life, are against the Mormon religion. He doesn't want to face the wrath of one of the richest cults in the world.
--
Re:IANAQ (Score:1)
Re:Yeah, but does it run vi? (Score:1)
ID once tried to sell their NeXT machines ... (Score:1)
I still have my color NeXT machine, and it served many years of use. When I replaced it with a 200MHz Pentium Pro system (running RH4.1), the PPro machine was roughly 20x faster than the old NeXT machine.
Re:SGI that created Quake (Score:1)
SGI's web site and picture for the Origin 2400. (Score:1)
Give the geeks money and look what they do (Score:1)
I'm waiting for the Jon Katz article about how the distribution of wealth among geeks suffering from a post-Columbine syndrome has led to the artificial valuation of tools of technology.
Re:So? (Score:1)
Re:It's a supercomputer that's why! (Score:1)
Re:To compare (Score:3)
It's not just the raw-cpu power of these things but the internal-bandwidth the ccNuMA architecture can support.
I guess as it goes today, they are a bit out-dated on the processor level, but would still make a fantastic file server. (That spec of Origin can maintain about 2 gigabyte of sustained internal bandwidth per second. A top end 1Ghz Athlon can only sustain about 800mb per second on the bus.
Re: (Score:1)
Re:ID once tried to sell their NeXT machines ... (Score:2)
Re: (Score:1)
Is this cool? (Score:1)
Re:its auctioned because linux blows it away (Score:1)
In case anyone thinks this is nonsense, remember that the low-end single user workstation that SGI recently released had a custom made souped up 64Mb nVidia Quadro card on it that makes your average DDR GeForce look slow. That thing is fast...
Things to consider when buying (Score:1)
Re:Imagine... (Score:1)
But the real question is... (Score:4)
Or do we finally get their sgi compile tools?
I know quite a few mappers with 64 processor sgi machines that want to know
Re:It's publicity - read the dpecs first. (Score:1)
SGI that created Quake (Score:2)
Obligatory Poll Mastah Poll (Score:3)
Poll: how many people are interested in this SGI box?
Caffeine underflow
Brain dumped
Re:Q3A (Score:1)
-Chris
i'm in this too (Score:3)
a beautiful IBM Craptiva with an enormous 64 meg of RAM, a beautifully stylish mobo with onboard crystal sound and an ATI Rage video card (you guessed it: the 2meg) This beautiful desktop unit is fully functional, it can be used as BOTH a paperweight for those outside offices, or a projectile. Either way, you'll be a winner with this baby!
Bidding will start next week...reserve is a bargain at a low low $32k. (Make checks payable to the FluXraD retirement fund. Seller makes no guarantee of implied warranty or viability of said IBM Craptiva. Purchaser takes product as is with no refunds unless expressly stated. Upon return a %100 stocking fee may be charged the buyer. Offer not valid in UT, VT, TX and The People's Republic of China)
FluX
After 16 years, MTV has finally completed its deevolution into the shiny things network
Re:Au contraire (Score:1)
Then I'll work on forcing gr_osview to work and turning on the distributed.net client so we can REALLY see how good it's doing.
-Chris
Well, why not? (Score:5)
Back on topic....
Could the Auction will become the defacto engine behind the new economy?
In a way, we'd come full circle. In the beginning, purchases were bartered for. Two people would negotiate back and forth until the price was agreed on. Eventually, fixed prices started to replace this. Money became the accepted tender, and everyone was happy.
Now, however, it's becoming easy to do the bartering without the social interaction, bluffing, etc. Stores could set an opening bid on the things they wanted to sell. When demand went up, the prices would go up, but not because they raised prices, instead because customers would bid against each other.
Eventually, people might bid against each other from whatever evolves from web-enabled cell phones or bluetooth devices. The winner would get the goods right then, and the loser would need to wander around the store waiting for the next bidding cycle to start on that item. On the plus side, the customer might be able to snake great bargains if they come in at off peak hours, reducing the mob scene you find in stores between 5-7PM. People who needed to shop at peak hours would pay for the convenience, bidding against other people of like-mind.
Whole new services might even appear where people pay fixed fees to 'professional bidders' who would take care of the whole bidding process for them. This would appeal to people who just want to buy stuff, and would create a whole new career.
Maybe it's our destiny to go back to our roots, economically...
Another reason (Score:1)
Re:Questions (Score:2)
--
Email address is real.
It's a supercomputer that's why! (Score:5)
According to the 1998 review [unixreview.com] of a Sun Enterprise 10000 at UnixReview (previously Performance Computing)
It's publicity what else. (Score:1)
I belive, "id" would server it's community better if they gave it away for to an art school -- does "id" realy needs the money?!
-- George
Re:So? (Score:1)
What are you talking about, mister 203477?
It sure doesn't look like you've been here all that long, does it?
-----
Re:Things to consider when buying (Score:5)
With half the processors dead, chances are that you could pull the dead boards and coax it to run on a 15A circuit (as long as you didn't have much/anything else on the circuit) Kitchen counter plugs are a good bet, since most building codes require each plug to be on a separate circuit.
The heat issue is real, though. I worked with an SGI crimson once, in a small room with not enough air conditioning to handle the output of the thing. At night we had to close the door to the room, and the temperature would consistently hit ~35C (~95F) (this was in Vancouver, not Phoenix). One night it got so hot that a termal protection fuse blew. It stumped the SGI service guy for a while (he didn't know about the thermal fuse).
Due to bureaucratic heel-dragging, it took almsost 6 months to upgrade the air conditioning in the room.
I don't know why it's power requirements would stop you from using it in a residential neighbourhoood, but chancces are that it's only FCC 15B (industrial) rated. -- I mean, who's going to put an Onyx in their basement?? (OK, put your hand down, I take that back!)
Re:where is the money going to end up (Score:1)
-----
Re:Auction mania! (Score:2)
Re:Imagine... (Score:1)
Re:It's a supercomputer that's why! (Score:1)
Re:So? (Score:1)
Re:So? (Score:1)
The user number in my old account (which I changed because I decided to post to /. with my real name) is under 10k. I've been around here far longer than you. I know what I'm talking about.
Slashdot2 Case (Score:1)
"SUPER XXX HARDCORE PORN, previousily Slashdot.org."
Then again, how many people would notice the difference? ;)
Re:It's a supercomputer that's why! (Score:1)
BS. Violent 3D computer games are an industry plain and simple, not a "revolution", which is just a word which sadly is mostly used for meaningless glorification of accomplishments that, in the great scheme of things, are totally trivial. Just like other bullshit PR terms like "paradigm shift".
You have ALL been trolled!!! (OFFTOPIC) (Score:1)
>Back in the good times, whenever the editors
>were thinking of making any changes to the
>system,
To which emmons rightfully points out that it's userID is GREATER THAN 200K.
It has also, in the past, claimed to remember people being "out to get" shengan in the days before his (apparantly temporary(unfortunately)) banishment from the editorial pool.
Now, my userID is in the 62K range, and I joined
Clearly, no one with a 200K+ userID would have been around then. UNLESS it is a troll. "estanliao martinez" is a such a troll. It is a made up character, a fraud. You should all have realised THAT much from its posting history.
A while back, an anonymous coward was circulating a link to "martinez"'s postings in the illicit "inchfan" forum, announcing the creation of the character. I, unfortunately, lost that link. AC, if you're there, a repost would be really cool.
Not only all that, it SLIPS OUT OF CHARACTER when you get it pissed off! Examine this quote from it in the following story (It is archived, so you'll have to scroll down, or search for its username):
http://slashdot.org/articles/00/06/28/1832229.s
>I repeat, I have *taught* logic. I have studied
>First Order Logic, Dynamic Logic, Modal Logic,
>Hybrid Logic, Type Theory, Model Theoretic
>Semantics, Substructural Logics, Feature Logics,
>and some more. At grad level. I'd advise you to
>not take my knowledge here for granted.
Note, in particular, the last sentance. Now, where have we heard THAT before? Which phony personality did it fall back to?
Everybody remember st-st-st-steven w-w-w-woston, of "jjjjulius games", who just HAPPENS to be close, personal friends with just about EVERY major player in the industry and community, from John Carmack to Scott Draker to Linus? Gets previews of EVERY bit of new hardware? And has his contributed code to EVERYthing fron Doom to Quake3 to the Linux kernel itself? And who'se character is EVERY bit as condescending as "estanislao martinez"?
It is baiting all of you. Quit biteing.
Oh, if only Slashdot had killfiles....
john
Resistance is NOT futile!!!
Haiku:
I am not a drone.
Remove the collective if
Q3A (Score:3)
-Chris
Future auctions (Score:1)
The prinout containing the first free software Bill Gates ever used. [ Known at the time as PD Basic ]
The 386 Linus used to compile the first version of Linux.
But getting sereous... Who cares what it was used for... It's still quite a powerful box...
Some upgrades and pollish and it'd kick butt.
I'd put in a bid if I thought I had a chance
I'd offer the first computer I used but... that was shipped back to Commodore back in 1979.
I don't want Slashdots first servers...
I want the last retired Slash server....
harddisk blanked of course....
Re:I'm surprised... (Score:1)
Re:Anyone care to answer a question? (Score:1)
Someone sat down and worked on all those details to make every player look human. Thats a lot of work. All your PC dose is overlay a skin on a frame. Someone had to make that skin and frame.
Also when develuping the game your working a few years ahead.
Say your working on a game today. Your target computer is a Pentium 5. Obveously such a machine dosn't exist. So you need something equally powerful.
The first versions of the game will not work well. A lot of hacks. A lot of unknowns. Later you go back over the code clean it up and make it work reliably. But when the code is running slow you need to run "at speed".
There are quite a few reasons to use a computer that is far byond the target machine.
In IDs case it was probably an upgrade consern. They didn't want to have to upgrade that machine to often. It was after all used for two versions of Quake and while it can be upgraded they probably need something a tad more powerful than a computer than a top end PC two years from now. This won't cut it.
Questions (Score:1)
1. What's the going rate for one of these things (are they charging a premium for the sentimental value?)
2. What's do they use as a replacement? (Probably "a cluster of ..."?)
3. Anybody have benchmarks for this sucker?
4. Does that come with a color monitor? (grin, Dilbert reference)
Re:ID once tried to sell their NeXT machines ... (Score:1)
I suspect the FSF might not want something so bulky becouse it would be so hard to get rid of once it's obsolete.
However to a geek, a colector, a tech or a company this sucker is totally worth punking down hard cold cash...
If ID wanted to donate that... it'd help out a lot....
Basicly the FSF won't get the workload out of it to make it worth the space it would end up taking up.
Re:Things to consider when buying (Score:1)
Re:just amazing (Score:1)
First no ID won't make a proffit. The cost of the replacment system will eat up any proffits ID makes.
So really there is no money to be made. It's a cost reduction yeah but it isn't enough.
ID would probably make more on goodwill in a donation of this bad boy that they would in capital from a sale.
But... It wouldn't benifit the FSF much at all and it takes up a lot of space.
It may not even be welcomed at the FSF.
What they need is new hardware not fast hardware. ID can write Pentium 5 code using a fast super compuyer FSF must have a real P5 and specs or it won't make much of a diffrence.
At issue. the FSF needs to do stuff like optomise the GCC compiler to run under new processors. The code isn't slow itself and still compiles and runs reasonably under a 386.
ID however is working on next generation graphics technology and needs computers as powerful as the ones we'll be using 2 to 3 years from now.
FSF needs to be able to compile and test P5 optomise code on a real P5.
ID just needs something as fast as so they can test the engen.
Once ID is readly to ship they'll rely on a compuler that has allready been optomised for the latest PCs. ID dosn't need to worry about that layer of technology.
In short the FSF would probably frown on a donation of such a box as it's unlikely anyone using such a box would need free software. But they'd be more than happy to accept a NeXT box as such a box would welcome new free software.
This auction gives ID a bit more publicity than a gift to the FSF would...
That is unless we have a folow up story about how the FSF office has this big old obsolete box waisting space and they can't afford to get rid of it.
And that is why ID should never donate such a system to the FSF... To much potental ill will
Re:Sell it to Los Alamos! (Score:1)
We don't need it.
We already have 192 of these, with 16 *working* processors each.
Sandia National Laboratory might be interested, though...
Re:Things to consider when buying (Score:1)
That reminds me, I'd better go pay my power bill today.
Mathematica Vax (Score:1)
I was told CalTech and Wolfram had a disagreement over who owned the machine, and Caltech moved it to the most inaccessable place they owned to try to keep it. (I take no responsibility for the accuracy of this statement.)
Another cute feature was the reel to reel tape drive - an old but still used technology at the time. They had a particularly old drive, because all the new ones would auto-feed the tape for you using suction, and they wouldn't work at ~4200m altitude.
A collector's item (Score:3)
"Comes autographed by the id development team and an official certificate of authenticity!"
Auction mania! (Score:1)
Make me an offer today, and you too might be
able to own one of these phenomenal Multias.
D
Re:It's a supercomputer that's why! (Score:1)
So if it's the fact that it's a supercomputer, and not that it's Id that's auctioning it, that is news, how come what was reported is the fact that ID auctioned, and what they used it for, instead of its capabilities? This is completely irrelevant.
I repeat: anybody who gives a damn that Id is auctioning a computer they used to create a couple of games is a spoiled yuppie brat. Collectors item my ass. And Taco should not use his story posting priviledge to sell crap.
Re:Things to consider when buying (Score:1)
Re:Yeah, but does it run vi? (Score:3)
I got this all from a small booklet (Product Guide) that I got while on a field trip to SGI in highschool 2 years ago... As for comparing against a dual PIII 800, I'm not sure what the R10K's can do... they're not mega-powerful 64-bit processors but the machine concentrates on the I/O bandwidth more than anything...
Re:Yeah, but does it run vi? (Score:1)
Au contraire (Score:3)
-Chris
Re:Things to consider when buying (Score:1)
Weight (minimum) 300 lbs
Weight (maximum) 750 lbs
Floor loading (minimum) 38 lb/ft^2
Floor loading (maximum) 95 lb/ft^2
Voltage 187-264 volts, 1-phase
Watts (maximum) 9750
Frequency 43-67 Hz
Cooling Requirements (max) 33,150 Btu/hr
------
Documentation says the wall plug is a "NEMA 6-30P". It looks the same as used for your washer/dryer (a big round three-prong plug that you insert and then twist into place). IIRC, they use these for boats to connect to harbor power.
So, to address your concerns:
1. Your floor should probably hold it up, even fully loaded. Unless you do the install in your kid's (or your own) treehouse.
2. Heat, on the other hand, is probably going to be an issue, unless you've got some decent central air. The biggest window unit I've seen is 20,000 btu/hr, which *might* hack it for a single module system (as this one is).
3 and 4. The power requirements aren't too bad, but you'll probably need an electrician to run a new outlet from your main to your new air conditioned server room to power this beast as well as the a/c for it.
----
That doesn't change the fact I still want one. $10K is a good deal for a O2000 with 8xR10K's. Maybe when I win the Big Game this week...
-Chris
Re:Things to consider when buying (Score:2)
It's a really wide voltage range (probably meant to use 208V if you have it, 230/240 if you don't). Only one problem - most residential power distribution centers/power meters only handle 100A or so, so you have to convince spouse to not cook and do laundry at the same time.
Uptime hosed because of dinner and laundry. Hmm.
Re:Questions (Score:2)
Too bad this isn't a mauve Origin2K; I think they have the most RAM...
Anyone care to answer a question? (Score:1)
Re:Q3A (Score:1)
my 2500w heater (Score:1)
Citizen Gates (Score:2)