Highway Shooters Claim To Emulate GTA 313
Thanks to Yahoo! for their story regarding teenage stepbrothers who randomly fired at cars on a Tennessee freeway, killing one person and wounding another, and told police they were inspired by Grand Theft Auto's sniper mode. According to the piece: "From a wooded area near their home at the Smoky Mountain Country Club, the boys fired a .22-caliber rifle up to 25 times through a break in the trees at cars driving along Interstate 40 about two miles east of Newport. They said they were bored and decided to shoot at tractor-trailer rigs, just like in the video game, 'Grand Theft Auto.'" According to this IOL/Reuters article, "Prosecutor Al Schmutzer told Judge Ben Strand that the boys told authorities they were mimicking the video game by trying to hit the sides of passing trucks."
Sounds familiar (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Sounds familiar (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Sounds familiar (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Sounds familiar (Score:2, Informative)
However, they did have a stock of dynamite-enhanced arrows...
ohhhh... (Score:5, Funny)
no wonder I suck playing GTA3.
Re:ohhhh... (Score:3, Funny)
Re:ohhhh... (Score:2)
Sound asinine? That's how the game works.
Re:ohhhh... (Score:2)
Honestly, I've gotten 100% on both GTA3 and GTA: Vice City, and I've never used the hooker trick in the course of the game. I used it once or twice in GTA3, just to see how it worked, and probably a half dozen times to show friends who wanted to know what all the hoopla was about. It's far from an intergal part of the game.
Funny (Score:5, Funny)
Sorry Mr. Prosecutor, got to come up with something better than that.
Re:Funny (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Funny (Score:2)
Hackwork defenses are the job of the defense attorney. The prosecutor would be the one dopesmacking the GTA argument.
So what are you saying? (Score:5, Insightful)
So what are you saying? (read more) (Score:5, Insightful)
They should receive the same punishment, because through their action/inaction they helped kill this driver.
Re:So what are you saying? (read more) (Score:5, Insightful)
Probably the parents were pathetic and irresponsible people as well. All this blame on games is pretty stupid, why don't you blame on the people that couldn't teach the kids that a game is a game, and shouldn't be tried in the real world?
You'd think these kids had some sort of teachings that taught them "shooting a truck with a gun is bad". It seems glaringly obvious the parents are at fault here, and people are once again looking for the scapegoat to blame.
Get some responsible parents, stop blaming games/tv/(insert someone else here).
Re:So what are you saying? (read more) (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:So what are you saying? (read more) (Score:2)
Actually, the parents and the community that family lives in are at fault. Cliques in school can reinforce bizarre and counter-intuitive ideas about morality, teachers often don't keep the kids stimulated while managing their "day care", and other adults in the community may simply be bad role models. For example, if a neighbor resorts to baiting a deer to his back yard and shooting it
Re:So what are you saying? (read more) (Score:2, Insightful)
How long can we keep passing the buck?
When people shoot cars, it's thir fault, full stop.
Re:So what are you saying? (read more) (Score:2)
I wasn't passing the buck at all. A community raises everyone within it. The parents ultimately have the most influence and bear the brunt of the responsibility, but every member of a community influences everyone else in it. This cannot be ignored.
Basically, it can be argued that humans are going through an adolescence of civilization right now. We still have prisons, personal freedom is still in question, there is still corruption in the government, etc. It wi
Even blaming the parents is stupid. (Score:3, Insightful)
You say "people are once again looking for the scapegoat to blame" yet yourself blame the parents. Sounds like scapegoating to me. The blame for this rests on the shoulders of the perpetrators.
Re:So what are you saying? (read more) (Score:2, Insightful)
It's all about teaching the child proper respect for the firearm, and supervising them until you know they have it.
If you wonder why so many people are growing up to be irresponsible people, you might look at how people like you seek to protect them for having any real responsibility for anythi
Re:So what are you saying? (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:So what are you saying? (Score:2)
Re:So what are you saying? (Score:2)
Those poor little Lemmings. Oh well.
Re:So what are you saying? (Score:2)
That aside, what's done is done, I want to see the White Wilderness episode with the lemming herding. I wonder if filming it was something like heding cats?
pk
Re:So what are you saying? (Score:2)
Well, the story line isn't perfect.. But I think it's close enough... Try using Stair Dismount [jet.ro] it should fit the bill well enough...
I was like this once (Score:5, Funny)
Re:I was like this once (Score:2)
Re:I was like this once (Score:5, Funny)
Sure there are. [tanpin.com]
Re:I was like this once (Score:2)
It's rated mature... (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:It's rated mature... (Score:3, Insightful)
Don't get me wrong, I am not about to launch an anti-gun tirade, but like any tool it should be used responsibly and until you can show good judgement in your actions you shouldn't be using them unsupervised
Re:It's rated mature... (Score:2)
- Happy Gilmore
Um, wrong. (Score:2)
"Guns don't kill people. I KILL PEOPLE"
- Dude on UHF (Movie starring Weird Al Yankovic)
Re:It's rated mature... (Score:2)
Or maybe they should sue games publishers and developers for actively fighting any attempts to make retailers obey the rating "recommendations". Industry representatives and trade associations claim the ratings system works but then they go to court to make sure the ratings aren't legally enforced. Hmm, why is that?
Re:It's rated mature... (Score:3, Insightful)
That's one view I guess...not the one I'd take though.
Re:It's rated mature... (Score:3, Insightful)
If parents can keep an eye on what television their children watch, as they should, why can't they keep an eye on what is on their computer screen? There is absolutely no difference at all. Downloading a game off P2P is akin to hiding a porno mag in the attic. Still got to open it to use it so watch your damned children!
(No, I don't expect anyone to watch every single thing your chil
idiot box (Score:5, Insightful)
Yeah, and he probably forget to mention to the judge that due to the lack of parental attention and involvement in these boys lives, they grew up to be anti-social and depressed kids who deep-down really just wanted somebody to pay attention to them while their parents sat on the couch, drank beer, and worshipped the idiot box.
Re:idiot box (Score:2)
Well, boo-fucking-hoo. Cry me a goddamn river. Life is a ZERO SUM GAME. You're NOT guaranteed to win. In fact, you're not even guaranteed to survive long enough to push your way out of your mother's wretched womb. Now that I think about it, you're not guaranteed anything, ever, from anybody. Stop your stupid whining and bitching, and wake up to the reality of LIFE. Every single man, woman, and child that is alive t
Hit the trailer? (Score:4, Interesting)
Re: game physics != real world physics (Score:2)
Yes. Because we all know that game physics and real life physics are identical.
... but to c
If there's anything that our office sessions of Quake II taught me, it's that the best way to move about in any situation is to constantly run while incessantly jumping like a rabbit 6 feet in the air.
I don't wan't to blame the motivation on the game either, I think it's just a cheap excuse
Yeah... (Score:3, Funny)
If I had only had the chance... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:3, Insightful)
And, you cannot have a child and hope that child will not be influenced
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:3, Informative)
Second, which should make point 1 moot: Did you watch Bowling For Columbine? If you haven't, I strongly suggest you do before you start deciding what actually influences children to do these things.
Kids are smart, way smarter than they are given credit for. Kids read every day how 'Violent Video Games Cause Children To Do Horrible Things'.
Gee, I wonder why when called on their actions they spout out: 'Hey, the
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:2)
You either didn't watch it, or you ARE the point being made.
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:2)
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:2)
However, can only documentaries make valid points?
The article you point to is interesting...mostly in that someone went to a LOT of work to try to discredit the entire piece of work. And why? If it was obviously total BS, nobody would care and there would be no point in discrediting it. In other words, the movie obviously hit too close to home for somebody.
Now, try to discredit the final scene, the interview with Charleston Heston. Is somebody going to tell me that that was
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:3, Insightful)
What is the point of the 'vicious pack of lies'?
Look, if I called you an asshole (I'm not, just an example...bear with...), who would care? Well, there are 2 answers:
1: If you aren't actually an asshole, nobody would care. You wouldn't give a damned because I'm absolutely nobody and you're sound in the fact that you aren't actually an asshole so you would just ignore it.
2: If you are actually an asshole, well then nobody except for you wo
Love your country like you love your dog (Score:3, Insightful)
Some people love their country as an adult loves a dog. The dog shouldn't pee on the carpet, chew up the shoes, or bite the neighbors, and the adult gets mad at the dog and does what they can to stop the inappropriate behavior -- but at the end of the
Re:Love your country like you love your dog (Score:3, Interesting)
I agree, for the most part. Except that all the "fixes" for the "flaws" of this counry that I've heard from certain people, including Tom Daschle, Bill & Hillary Clinton, etc., and eventually down to Michael Moore, generally include comparisons to other countries, specifically in Europe. That's one part I disagree with. With children in education, the Left (speaking generally here) thinks that each child is
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:2)
Children have minds, yes, and that is why these teenagers are responsible for this incident. That does not mean that the manner in which they were raised is meaningless. Influences matter.
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:2)
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:2)
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:2)
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:2)
Re:If I had only had the chance... (Score:5, Insightful)
Hm, no adult games, no mature television and movies, no mature music or books, including porn.
Ah, no more cars either, some kid might try to drive one. And no guns, or alcohol.
I've got it, lets let Fisher Price have sole controle over every single available consumable on this planet!
Oh, well, I guess we could take responsibility for our own children and actions if you think that might work too.
Slippery slope my friend, slippery slope.
even more important thing about this article... (Score:4, Funny)
yeah and i decided to emulate three musketeers.. (Score:4, Funny)
seriously, geez...
i don't remember shooting tractor rigs in gta though..
So? (Score:5, Interesting)
If someone doesn't know the difference between fantasy and reality then obviously playing computer games and watching TV could cause them to do something bad. But the problem is with them, not with the game or film.
Re:So? (Score:2)
You hit on the point that these people don't know the difference between fantasy and reality, which is close.
In my opinion though, the problem is that reality, especially the one that the media stuffs down our throat whether we like it or not, is quite often way more brutal and horrific than fantasy. So then how do you teach someone the difference between a TV show where someone is murdered, and a
Do we really believe in personal responsibility? (Score:2, Informative)
For smoking, this means the following. The fabric industry is the cause of a very small amount of publicly spent medical costs per year. The smoking industry is (indirectly) the cause of the majority of medical expenses per year. However, both the fab
Re:Do we really believe in personal responsibility (Score:2)
however.. guns do kill people.
or more correctly, irresponsible behauvior with a gun kills people(where the f did they get the gun??).
or more simple, shooting someone with a gun can/will result in death.
where did they get the gun, why weren't they educated enough to NOT SHOOT SOMEWHERE WHERE PEOPLE ARE? the gta excuse is just an excuse(there's no trailer-tractors in it) they de
romeo and juliet (Score:2)
Are you kidding? Or just a moron? Suicide is the third leading cause of death among 15 to 25 year olds. Each year, 500,000 from this same age group attempt suicide. Source: American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry [aacap.org].
For ages 15-19, homicide is the #2 cause of death, suicide is #3. #1 is "accidental death". Source: Child Trends Databank [childtrendsdatabank.org].
Romeo and Juliet are definitely "blamed" for some suicides. Some teens actually recreate
Re:romeo and juliet (Score:2)
apologies (Score:3, Insightful)
countdown (Score:2)
This is absurd... (Score:5, Insightful)
Point 2) Where did they get the gun? Notice how everyone is 100% ready to jump on the video game... my question... WHERE THE FUCK DID THEY GET THE GUN? I mean, of course the gun isn't dangerous. No way. Guns never kill people. That's why cops and 'sportsmen' carry around RAZOR SHARP DVDs.
It's fucking obscene. I can't wait to see what happens to such good titles (and yes, you have to admit, even if you hate the content with a passion, the games are done really well..)
Re:This is absurd... (Score:2)
can't wait till the judge hears this (Score:2)
Re:can't wait till the judge hears this (Score:2)
The closest thing to a tractor-trailer in GTA3 was one of the 18-wheeler cabs that drove around. IIRC there's nothing like that in Vice City.
For about a 3 month period I did nothing but play GTA:VC after work un
Get Bored - Shoot People ? (Score:5, Insightful)
You got to be shitting me. You take a
If you're shooting a rifle anywhere but at the shooting range, you're shooting to kill as far as I know.
Even in GTA, you only ever shot to either blow up the truck or kill the driver.
It's absurd that anyone believes their bullshit.
Re:Get Bored - Shoot People ? (Score:3, Insightful)
Everybody wants to blame something else for their poor behavior. Their parents, their video games, their DNA. Who the fuck cares why you did it? Does it even matter? You try to kill people, you go directly to jail, do not pass go. Learn from your (stupid-ass dumb-shit tard-fuck) mistake, and when you get out, try not to make the same mistake again.
Re:Get Bored - Shoot People ? (Score:2)
I sure do hope your backyard is big enough that there is no possible chance of a stray bullet hitting anything not on your property, in all directions.
I also really hope nothing ever ricochets and accidentaly hits a family member, maybe a child hiding just off to the side of your targets behind a bush out of curiosity or something.
If not, you're at LEAST as bad as these kids, except fo
What if.. (Score:2, Funny)
can I say I was inspired by SCO and blame it on insanity and get away with it?
A nudge in the right direction? (Score:5, Insightful)
Sure it's conceivable for a 13-year-old to have a concept of "the rest of my life", and for him to imagine the guilt he will feel over that length of time, but could that maturity and self-awareness really exist in the sort of kid who shoots at cars because he did it in a computer game?
Methinks an adult had a hand in writing that letter.
Re:A nudge in the right direction? (Score:2, Funny)
I guess I've watched Clerks too many times.
Salem (Score:2)
Hmm... been playing Soul Calibur 2 lately... (Score:2)
Seriously though, this is just sick. Not only that, but personally the whole "GTA made me do it!" just feels like a lame excuse. I've played through and beat GTA3, and I have absolutely no urge to run out with a sniper rifle. Nor do any of my friends who have played it.
Yeah I had the same excuse.. (Score:2, Funny)
A culture of no accountability? (Score:5, Insightful)
People need to be much more cynical than they are. They need to realize that both large government (whether Republican or Democrat flavored) and large corporations do not act in the interests of individual people. They are much too wealthy, powerful, and corrupt to care. They are their own means and their own ends. People need to stand up for themselves in the midst of this, vote their conscience with both their wallets and their ballots, and be prepared to sacrifice materialistic prestige and social popularity in favor of knowing they made the right decision and did the best they could. Corporations and government need to become more modest and come back to realizing that they exist because of and for the People, not the other way around. It seems that every day the opposite of this is actually happening, and, ultimately, people will exist miserably in a rusty machine of regulation and consumption and live in complete fear of their creditors and their own government.
The question is... (Score:3, Insightful)
From the article: William Buckner, 16, and Joshua Buckner, who turns 14 Sunday, pleaded guilty to reckless homicide, reckless endangerment and aggravated assault.
A 13-year-old and a 16-year-old. Now, I think the argument could be made that a 16-year-old MIGHT be mature enough to play GTA (obviously not Billy-boy, though), but WTF was a 13-year-old doing playing that game?!? To add on to that, why have I seen kids - young kids - in game stores getting M-rated games? My wife and I watched a 9- or 10-year-old kid and his mother buy Vice City earlier this year, and the mother asked him if he wanted the strategy guide! Obviously that's one smart little kid...
Now, don't get me wrong: I love the GTA series, but I'm 30. I wouldn't have let me at 13 play GTA, and I sure as hell know my mother wouldn't have, either. At 13, I couldn't handle that game, I know that.
Where the hell are these kids' parents? Is Tennessee going to prosecute those idiots (I hope!)?
Re:The question is... (Score:2, Interesting)
Last Christmas I worked at Best Buy, selling consoles and console games. 9/10 parents didnt know about the ESPR rating system. 5/10 were shockedthat there was one, and that the game their kid wanted was rated "M" because of sex, drugs, violence, murder, life-like gore. 8/10 partents would putthe game down and not let their kid buy it. But 2/10 parents were like really....I'll get it anyway.
Re:The question is... (Score:2)
You took the time to tell parents about this stuff and Best Buy let you keep your job? I'm impressed. Most of these
So then they should get.. (Score:4, Insightful)
24 charges of attempted murder.
1 charge of assault with a deadly weapon with intent to kill.
1 charge of murder one (since they clearly planned it).
The statement that they were inspired by GTA is irrelevant. In the 16th century, some Catholic nuns started to walk around with heavy pelvic thrusting all the time. They claimed it was because Satan had visited their convent and ravaged them in both holes with his evil, barbed, bifurcated penis. Did Satan really do that? No, not any more than GTA is responsible for this.
An action is not the same as an idea -- it takes a diseased mind to put an idea like, "it's fun to kill people" into practice.
Re:So then they should get.. (Score:2)
Reference? (Seriously.)
Movies, Games and Guns (Score:2, Insightful)
But seriously folks gun control is this issue here, not video games, or movies, or the sulky, moody, violent, careless, callous and fundamentally stupid nature of teenage boys.
America has a lot of such boys and a lot of guns. Together they'll cause deaths. They'll never be rid of the boys so they'll have to do something about the guns.
If they have to be prie
I hope... (Score:3, Insightful)
Ehh...
Doom made me do it...
GTA made me do it...
Satan speaking through my dog made me do it...
Further proof that there should only be one punishment for violent crime; an industrial meat grinder.
Idiots. (Score:2, Interesting)
Having the gun wasn't the reason (Score:3, Insightful)
GTA is a smoke screen, and probably came from leading questions from the prosecutor hoping to get a name for himself or to shift blame - there is no point in GTA where you randomly shoot at trucks. You shoot at people, so if they were emulating the game then they knew full well that people could die.
The sad part is that the 'juvy' distinction should be lifted for homicides. These murdering kids will be out at 19 each, and aren't going to be able to do anything besides turn to crime.
Yep (Score:2)
It's kind of funny but before we had our 22's we had pellet and BB guns. Now those we sort of abused, shot out lights, stop signs, whatever. But our 22's were "real" guns and we treated them with respect.
Same with my cousin's kids (Score:2)
He has full access to all of the guns (whether shotgun or rifle) on my aunt's farm, and goes hunting on his own often.
That said, he's extremely responsible with the guns. Nerf weapons... YIKES. But real firearms, he's *damned careful* with.
Yes, they live out in the country. Kids with guns are a normal thing in many parts of this country, and it's normally not considered a problem.
In other news: (Score:5, Funny)
"He started acting weird" mentioned his coworkers, Timothy Arcade 40 year old, went and bought a bunch of aspirins and throw them in the floor across all the cubicles, then he proceeded to eat them while making a "snacka" "snacka" sound effect, several coworkers and security officers tried to stop him, but he elluded them succesfully, in his way he also grabbed some cherries that were in the middle of the office for no apparent reason.
When the police finally arrived and arrested the man, he stated he was just trying to emulate pacman after hearing this the policeman let the poor man go and went to burn down namco's office on chicago.
Later that afternoon , the police had to arrest Timothy again, after eating a large Pill in one of the corner cubicles he actually attemped to eat the coworkers that were chasing him.
In other news some other 40 year old, was arrested yesterday for soliciting but he was let go when he confessed he was just emulating Leisure suit larry. The police is looking for sierra's offices to burn them down.
VideoGames: the best way get you off the hook... always!
hey, don't knock it till you try it (Score:3, Funny)
Long story short, I'm free because I was "insane" and needed "help". And blaming the game helped me stay out of prison for 3 counts of murder.
For anyone who is still pending litigation and wants to go full-on for the insanity plead, fire your lawyer and defend yourself... go for the chewbacca defense. It adds a special bit of believeability.
The Cost of Liberty (Score:2, Insightful)
Only in America... (Score:5, Interesting)
Where'd they get the gun? (Score:3, Funny)
They didn't emulate anything (Score:4, Funny)
Amateurs.(Vice City was in the past, doesn't count)
Gys dnt kill me plz i need a wpn wtf!!! (Score:2)
Re:Shooting at the sides of trucks huh? (Score:2)