Phantom Game Console Presentation 237
superultra writes "Glaximus has posted an impressions piece on Penny-Arcade of one of Infinium Lab's first press conferences. Most notable is that which Gabe, of Penny-Arcade fame, also replicates on Penny-Arcade's front page: 'One of the last questions asked was rather direct and perhaps aimed a bit low. "So, I have all my consoles at home, and I have a very powerful PC that plays lots of games and can be upgraded simply by installing new hardware myself. Why would I want to buy a Phantom?" Rob's answer? "Well then you aren't really part of the Phantom's core user base." That got some chuckles from the crowd, sure. But it was Rob's next statement that had the real impact. "See, you people say you have enough consoles, and a powerful PC, but whenever a new console comes out, you people always buy it."' Other details are scarce, except that the release date is now April 2004, and that the Phantom will use highly advanced DMCA techniques such as Epoxy Encapsulation and Case Intrusion Detection. Doing so will, no doubt, provide the Missing Link in Digital Rights Managment."
isn't it obvious? (Score:5, Funny)
c'mon, why don't they just say it. we all know the launch title is Duke Nukem: Forever, why must they beat around the bush?
Mike
Re:isn't it obvious? (Score:2)
Jeebus this guy spouts poetry like our esteemed Secretary of Defense [msn.com]... now I'm really scared. Does he know someone named Darl?
I'm seeing some sh*t! (Score:5, Funny)
Re:PA review (Score:2)
Reading the article surrenders....
Comment removed (Score:5, Interesting)
isn't google wonderful? (Score:5, Interesting)
HardOCP (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:It does not exist! (Score:3, Insightful)
From reading the articles at HardOCP it doesn't look good. (Developing in you garage is fine, supplying a false adress is at best suspicious.
And the entire thing seems like a new version of the DivX DVD-player standard.
If you believe the phantom... (Score:2)
Seriously.
We have Max Payne 3.
*smirks*
"You People." (Score:3, Interesting)
The crowd became outright hostile as the speech wore on. I remember hearing one person incredulously shout, "US people???"
I can't imagine the crowd at the presentation reacted any better.
So Infinium believes Us People will buy basically whatever any console manufacturer makes, eh? I guess they're unaware of the Sega Saturn. Or the Atari Jaguar. Maybe they believe Nokia's press releases, and not their in-store sales figures on the N-Gage. I don't know. It seems to me that the video game industry has more failed consoles than successes.
But then, I'm not in the business; I just play games.
Re:"You People." (Score:4, Insightful)
By constantly saying "You people," the underlying message Perot gave was: "You and me are separate and we're going to stay that way." Compare this to Clinton's "I feel your pain" approach: It said, "I may not be black, but I understand disenfranchisement."
Back to topic, the message Infinium gave with this comment is: "We're not really by gamers for gamers as the company motto says, and we think you'll buy whatever we give you."
Re:"You People." (Score:2)
Of course, it was dumb. And in this case, it's dumber, because as you say, they're not really gamers. The games might be, but the people putting it together have no clue. They're making the device way too large, which is clearly not necessary. Advantech sells
Blink, Blink (Score:5, Insightful)
Can't beat free publicity.
Re:Blink, Blink (Score:2)
The Phantom is also dumb. But it doesn't exist, doesn't work and even if it did it doesn't innovate. It imprisons. It is mail order only.
This reeks of that Mel Brooks classic, The Producers.
Not quite... (Score:5, Insightful)
We didn't buy the 3D0, TurboGrafx-16, or Jaguar, did we?
uh yeah.... (Score:2)
Nope.
Re:Not quite... (Score:2)
Re:Not quite... (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Not quite... (Score:2)
Re:Not quite... (Score:5, Interesting)
Of course, these older consoles aren't the ones that require a broadband connection. That's a good way to slash your target market down to an order of magnitude less than what it could be...
Not us in particular (Score:2)
I think you misinterpreted my comment; I wasn't referring to our age group (whatever that may be) specifically. Video game consoles were well-established as a form of entertainment by the time the ones I mentioned were rolled out, and the public still didn't take to them. Why? They were fatally flawed in areas other than technology -- price, game availability, development model, etc. Essentially, they go to show
Re:Not quite... (Score:2)
Someone's in for a bitter dissapointment.
Re:Not quite... (Score:2)
Yeah, I was so disappointed by Phantasy Star on the unsuccessful (in the States, anyway) Sega Master System that I couldn't put the game down until I beat it. That game was just so horribly ahead of its time I don't know why I bothered spending money on it. I still catch myself humming the God-awful title track to that horrible game.
Maybe I can eventually move on to be disappointed crappy Sega Saturn imports like Castlevania: Nocturne in the Moonlight. I'm s
Re:Not quite... (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Man, I bought a Jaguar (Score:2)
Tempest 2000 & Alien -vs- Predator. (Wish sombody would port that version to a faster machine. Great FPS game. Scary too.)
Everything else was crap (sigh).
Oh well, it did say "Atari" on it, so it goes into the collection...
Since I am gonna ramble... Why buy this anyway? I want a console that can be hacked a bit. Maybe not as easy as the Dreamcast (only because that killed it), but easy enough that I can make creative use of it later after the company t
Re:Not quite... (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Not quite... (Score:2)
-B
Re:Not quite... (Score:2)
I'm a big SC2 fan as well. You might be happy to know that the ( relatively ) recently open source version of Star Control 2 [sourceforge.net] is based on the 3DO code branch.
YLFIVaporware (Score:1)
Doesn't sound right (Score:2)
256 mb of ram
80 gig ram
ATX architechture MotherBoard
NV 36 graphics
Controllers
cost $300.00
Definitely looks like an X-box like loss leader, problem is there is no OS included. What are developers going to develop to ? Whats more unless they have a couple billion to drop sales of consoles theres no way they are going to get the developer support on porting the games over.
Maybe their epoxy DMCA scheme could sound nice to developers, but is casual piracy of
Re:Doesn't sound right (Score:2)
Re:Doesn't sound right (Score:2, Informative)
You don't need an OS to develop a game. None at all. The only functionality that one would really need is how to talk to the hard disk to store items on it, and that could pretty much all be done through bios calls and a drive with some sort of documented filesystem interface on it. Everything else would be done through programming to the direct hardware, like most game consoles already do. In
Re:Doesn't sound right (Score:2)
Why aren't they using BitBoys? (Score:2)
Re:Doesn't sound right (Score:2)
One of these days I will learn to proofread.
80 Gig HD
Mandalorian Armor (Score:3, Interesting)
I want to feel bad for anyone who invests in this flop. I find it exceedingly difficult however because they're painfully stupid. Hopefully the people backing Infinium married well so there's a chance their offspring to end up with decent genes.
I am laughing (Score:2)
Sounds like a PC. Too bad the general purpose version is pretty damn cheap anyway.
I think all these opportuneurs don't get it:
The general purpose computer will eventually price crush the game box.
Re:I am laughing (Score:5, Interesting)
it may price crush them (it's close to that now) but it is nowhere closer to having three things:
1. appliance-style instant-on "plug and play" -- instead you have to load the OS then install the game, then load the game, and so many things can go wrong there.
2. unified controller architecture (man the buzzwords) so that game developers don't have to worry about which version of Microsoft Sidewinder you're going to use, or maybe you'll just use the keyboard and a trackball or what have you.
3. "franchise" games like Nintendo's Mario, oh so popular with the young 'uns.
Now, what the PC does have, is mods. I think that's the big weakness of Xbox live and all that, there's no ability for the community to "embrace and extend" as it were. Kinda ironic, but not surprising. The PC is an open architecture computer, the game consoles are closed-architecture appliances.
Re:I am laughing (Score:2)
directx offers this basically already.
and as to 3) there's plenty of 'franchise' games that have been pc only(or pc+consoles), like lots of ea's games
the phantom is meant to be an easy to use computer.. for computer literate audience. so it doesn't sound that smart(i wo
Re:I am laughing (Score:2)
the reason keyboard + mouse works so well for quake is because the developers coded the game with that interface in mind. if Carmack knew every PC owner had a PS2 controller, then he might have tweaked the game interface very differently to play well on a PS2 controller. button layouts, control sensitivity and accelleration all make a
Re:I am laughing (Score:2)
The solution to input is to provide support for complete key remapping so people can choose their own keys. Far too few games do this, so you get stuck using particular types of controllers. Oh and by the way, keyboard and mouse has long been shown to be a better interface for first person shooters than gamepads. The simple fact is that when you are trying to shoot people in the real world, you just point at them, and the mouse is the easiest way to point, requiring just a little wrist motion. The merits o
Re:I am laughing (Score:2)
But it's easier to make a game for PC. Shit, games for other consoles are WRITTEN on the PC. So the pressure is on to find a way to make PC gaming profitable.
Hence, X-box. And ain't no way MS is giving that up to this idiot and his glow-box.
Re:I am laughing (Score:2)
Re:I am laughing (Score:2)
Your username is quite appropriate.
i know where to get one (Score:2, Funny)
(Note to the well read, i dont mean Dante's hell.)
Full Sail! (Score:2)
I used to imagine Full Sail as the kind of place that would ask you essay questions like "The President has been kidnapped by ninjas! Are you a bad enough dude to rescue the President?" on its application forms. Then I went here [fullsailsucks.com]
heh (Score:3, Funny)
A P4, 80gig hard drive and some ram all for $300 eh? Not bad
Re:heh (Score:2)
Re:heh (Score:2)
Haven't you heard? The Phantom features "Epoxy Encapsulation" technology! That's right, it's all going to be covered in glue!
Chris Mattern
Re:heh (Score:2)
Shit, did I just break the DMCA?
Re:heh (Score:2)
That's a little over kill buddy!
I have a sneaking suspcion they aren't going to submerge this thing in epoxy. that would be a little expensive and probably an utter pain when slapping it together. They probably intend to glue the cards in or something silly.
Your just crazy enough to make it to my friends list, welcome aboard buddy!
Re:solvents all around. (Score:2)
ya know (Score:5, Insightful)
Know your Market.
A broadband fed video game console is not exactly new, ya know. (Sega's SegaNet for the Genesis, JagNet for the Atari Jaguar, etc) Neither is DRM technology. (Those of you that cracked Commodore games can now raise your hand, thank you all)
The video game market is really filled with thrill junkies. Looking for their latest fix. Weither that is Donkey Kong Country or Final Fantasy X-II, in the end, "It's the games, stupid."
If they can't name a single game, they're grasping at straws. A joke in an ATX case.
Site is already, slow, so here's the article text. (Score:2, Insightful)
Phantom Impressions
By Glaximus [mailto]
The Presentation
A crowd of about 300 had gathered in one of Full Sail's larger classrooms for the monthly meeting of the Orlando chapter of the International Game Developers Association. Our guest speakers for the night were Infinium Labs, the company behind the oft-maligned and highly mysterious Phantom console. They were cautious with information, and while they did spill some details about the system, it's hardware, and their business model, they left a lot of critic
Games are Not His Focus (Score:3, Interesting)
This guy is not building a gaming platform. He's building a cable decoder.
Cable companies would like nothing more than to rent you immersive, persistent entertainment. ("Sell? That's so last millennium.") Problem: Cable boxes today are pitifully stupid due to the drive to keep costs low; they have no local storage. Also, they've learned the hard way, both through their spastic "Interactive TV" initiatives and their broadband internet offerings, that there's no way they can serve interactive games without intolerable download waits from the head end.
What they want is a PC that the subscriber can't modify in any way. It looks like the Phantom guys propose to build this.
Or, they could just be a bunch of flakes out to put over an obvious hoax on the industry. (Please support our "phantom" console, ha ha...)
Schwab
Infineum business plan (Score:5, Funny)
2) Depend upon the utterance "You people buy every console there is."
3) Profit!
Yes folks! They have revealed the elusive and often obfuscated STEP 2!
Hallelujia! No longer do I have to steal underpants [geocities.com] to build a business!
April of 2004? (Score:5, Funny)
Enron Economics (Score:5, Funny)
If I remember correctly, April would be in Q2.
Actually (Score:2)
Re:Actually (Score:2)
Re:Enron Economics (Score:2)
Pssh... epoxy THIS. (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
This is Going to Tank (Score:3, Insightful)
Secondly, what if your area doesn't have broadband? Doesn't about 50% of the US still use modems?
And finally, no memory card, no disk drive. You want your friend to borrow your game? No problem. Give him the whole console. Want to trade save games. Same thing. There's a reason we have disk drives and memory cards, this is it.
So where does that leave our audience? I guess that means anyone who has broadband, doesn't have a good PC, and doesn't like to play console games with friends.
Any takers?
Re:This is Going to Tank (Score:2)
Just who is the target audience for this thing??? (Score:2)
They are going to see a box that is screaming for more memory, faster bus speed or a bigger CPU. But unless you can get around the tamper-resistent case (probably) you risk turning it into a useless pile of junk by doing so.
It certainly isn't parents shopping for a Christmas present. So you are telling me that I ca
I know how they are gonna make money on this. (Score:2)
This is smart. Really, really smart.
And they have already alluded to it several times.
And it is gonna work too.
They are not even humoring themselves on making money on the console. No sir.
They are gonna make money on the digital rights managment feature.
Or rather, they are baiting another company to put epoxy over there chips and to put a tamper switch on the case of there console.
Know what they do when that happens?
Nothing.
Wait a couple of
Re:I know how they are gonna make money on this. (Score:2)
What your saying makes sense, but would they really need to put on as big of a dog and pony show as they are to pull something like this? Wouldn't the whole thing be a lot easier if they just patented some of their crap, let the console be still-born and then wait?
Re:I know how they are gonna make money on this. (Score:2)
Smoke, Mirrors, and the Bomb (Score:2)
Rob's answer? "Well then you aren't really part of the Phantom's core user base."
Well, it's nice to know console and PC gamers aren't their target audience. I mean, God forbid you'd want to tap that user base.
That's great except for this article... (Score:3, Informative)
This should be required reading for anyone who still believes that this console will ever be more than a greedy attempt to milk VC's for some quick cash.
Re:That's great except for this article... (Score:2)
Re:That's great except for this article... (Score:2, Interesting)
Note: In Florida (where Infinium, and presumably Mr. Roberts is supposed to be) a residence, no matter the value, cannot taken from an owner who has filed for bankruptcy. A lot of those Enron, Tyco and Worldcom guys have huge multi-million dollar estates down there, pretty much precisely for this reason. Investing millions in a home in Florida is a great
Bandwidth? (Score:2)
10000 very hard-core users, at 650MB downloaded per user per
Pricing structure (Score:2)
Distribution of games is apparently going at 60% of sale price. Unlike a real publisher, that 60% doesn't buy you any advertising, hype, or free press copies. At the end of this, the Developer and original Publisher split $20, and Indrema walks away with $30.
Fuck them (Score:2)
Waste of VC money (Score:2)
Come April 2004 there will be a new press conference showing exactly the same thing and indicating a release in 6 months from then until some sucker of a company buys these guys out and nothing becomes of it because they realize what BS the whole thing is.
"See, you people say you have enough consoles, and a powerful PC, but whenever a new console comes out, you people alwa
look at Apple, people (Score:2)
For the same reason people sometimes pay $15-$20 for a physical CD instead of paying $9.99 to download it at the iTunes Music Store: sometimes you'd rather own the thing permanently with no restrictions on how or where you use it.
They should look at it another way: if I can pay $50 for a game that I own, unrestricted, can play on my friends' consoles, can resell at
Re:look at Apple, people (Score:2)
Hmmmm (Score:2)
Potential Partnership (Score:2)
Actually, the comment of "Well then you aren't really part of the Phantom's core user base," is what really chokes me up: The implication is that the Phantom's core user base is that group of people who already want a Phantom
Phantom can go FUCK themselves for spamming (Score:2)
Proof of phantom's spamming at http://groups.google.com/groups?q=phantom.net++gr o up:news.admin.net-abuse.sightings+group:news.admin
Re:Phantom can go FUCK themselves for spamming (Score:2)
go to http://groups.google.com
do a search for "some bastard phantom"
The first listing at the top is my spam report.
Re:Phantom can go FUCK themselves for spamming (Score:2)
Try this. [google.com]
Mixed Messages (Score:2)
So we have this company, they have this slogan of being "by gamers, for gamers". Then we have this press conference where Captain PR Guy says that gamers aren't the target consumer for this product.
Now, I'm just a simple caveman and your world frightens and confuses me, but isn't that just a little confused on their part. I have said a few times that this is just a fancified computer.
My problem is that these people seem schizophrenic, as if
buy it? (Score:2)
Well Rob, rest assured, if that's the only selling point you have....I WON'T be buying your console.
God....marketing 101 is PRODUCT PLACEMENT! And you have not done a damned thing to place your product. It has NOTHING that separates it from anything else. You offer us nothing new. Those other consoles that we all bought? Guess what? They all offered something new. Ninte
Tim Roberts' Resume (Score:2, Funny)
Is being able to click a
Re:Tim Roberts' Resume (Score:3, Funny)
This man is teh w1zzrd! He has run both Microsoft and McAfee's regclean programs! A man of the wurlde!
Hmm... (Score:2)
I guess I just like to stick it to the man. . .
This sounds to me like the biggest scam ever! (Score:3, Insightful)
Next we have a console that noone has ever seen.
Next we have a sales and distribution model that requires you to pay them before you get product... pay to an address that is a PO box.
Finally you have no developer interest of any kind from major players, let alone publishers. No sign of an office or hosting facility that can handle delivering applications. No sign of infrastructure to manufacture or support the box either. Sketchy always changing specifications and unreachable personnel.
It would not surprise me in the least if these guys take a bunch of orders and then just 'disappear'. I mean there is no sign that there is any plans for a business at this point.
Re:Security features (Score:2)
Re:Security features (Score:2)
Re:DMCA techniques? (Score:2)
Should read:
-Paying user burning money to brign to light the fact that he has no real foundation upon which to base his opinions.
Seriously, all you do is post a sentance or two on every story that say copyright is horrible. Ban it now! Arguments like these are ignored by anyone who has the power to change them. Why? Because people with power were, in most cases, smart enough to achieve their postions on their own meri
Read the post (Score:2)
That was a disclaimer because I know it is not in all cases. Now, try posting thought out arguments to back up your opinions.
Re:DMCA techniques? (Score:2)
P.S. I am checking this post extra carefully. I'm sure I'll screw something up, but here's hoping.
Re:None of it matters (Score:2)
Re:I can't see their market advantage (Score:2)
And last I check their slogan "For gamers, by gamers" was used/owned by Interplay.
Re:I am still reeling... (Score:2)
You come back when Shenmue II is released for PC, and then we'll talk. I have a P4, a G4 and an XBox on my desk ( the xbox feeds the TV in on the P4.. ). Each one has its place, each one has its use. I think the best bit about the Xbox is that its has a near zero setup time, is conducive to playing short sessions, and eliminates the need for a Windows PC in the above machine set.
I agree about your point wrt the fountain drying up, however.
YLFI