Doom 3 for Linux Released 411
edawg writes Linuxgames reports that "the Linux edition of Doom 3 has been released by ID Software. Although it didn't ship with a Linux version on the install CD, its still nice to see they release Linux binaries around the same time as their first game patch. Here is Information directly from ID Software."
questions (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:questions (Score:5, Informative)
Why not use SDL? (Score:5, Insightful)
I've heard this said before and wondered why they don't use a combination of SDL/Alsa/OpenGL to keep it cross platform. I've been doing that and have a single code base that compiles to Linux, Windows, and Mac with no nasty piles of #ifdef'ed code.
Re:Why not use SDL? (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Why not use SDL? (Score:3, Informative)
Aside from that, I agree with you wholeheartily
Re:Why not use SDL? (Score:5, Interesting)
I've tried out SDL a few times, and although I've found it pretty workable, when you bring multithreading in it has troubles, especially if you don't want to render in your main thread.
Re:Why not use SDL? (Score:3, Interesting)
I assumed it was something along those lines, as ID actually has a longer histo
Re:Why not use SDL? (Score:3, Interesting)
Perhaps -- and I know this may be shocking to some -- iD doesn't find SDL to be as advanced as DirectX when it comes to sound and input.
Besides which, since SDL sits on top of DirectX (note that this does not necessarily mean that SDL can do everything that DirectX does), that means they've got to deal with one extra level of abstraction, which hinders speed, if even slightly.
Re:questions (Score:3, Informative)
But on Windows, it might perfectly well use other parts of DirectX that aren't Direct3D.
Re:questions (Score:2, Funny)
Re:questions (Score:3, Informative)
OpenGL and DirectX aren't equivalent anyway, you must be thinking of Direct3D, which is the graphics library.
Re:questions (Score:3, Informative)
Direct3D has been renamed "DirectX graphics". Weren't you paying attention to that announcement?
On DirectX and OGL (Score:2)
M$ own like 99.9999999999999999999999% of OGL now anyway, so they don't really care.
Re:questions (Score:3, Informative)
Re:questions (Score:2)
Re:questions (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:questions (Score:2)
Re:questions (Score:3, Insightful)
OpenGL is just a graphics library.
I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:5, Interesting)
I wonder if Doom 3 can be successfully played on lesser hardware if played in linux...
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:2)
Just keep the detail level at medium and it runs fine on an Athlon +1600 w/ a Geforce 4 ti 4800 and 382 of (older)DDR memory. But I really could use more memory as I see the game effectivly sucks it all away during play.
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:5, Interesting)
Not that I'm trashing linux, I use it daily. I have 2 boxes, with Synergy setup between them. One is linux, the other windows. I use the linux box for websurfing, AIM, and as a file server, and the windows box (since it has a bigger monitor) for doing any programming homework and playing games. I just find that linux isn't quite there yet for gaming. Hopefully soon though, its came a long way.
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:4, Insightful)
(Beowulf Boy, this isn't a criticism of you, but the mentality of moderators)
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:3, Insightful)
At least with Linux and Windows you know where you stand.
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:2, Funny)
You're not even safe there. I've been modded down multiple times for saying Windows98 was unstable.
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:4, Funny)
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:5, Interesting)
So basically, it isn't sad that the guy had to put a disclaimer in there, because what he said does in fact contradict popular belief, as well as somewhat recent published benchmarks.
(Disclaimer: I'm not one of these dillusional people who claim Linux can run Windows games faster than Windows itself under Wine. The only game I recognize as running equal or better in Linux is Quake3.)
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:2, Informative)
Using the same config (1280x1024, High settings, 8xAF, no AA, all effects on) on Athlon XP 1.4GHz
Win98se/Forceware 61.21: 30.1 fps
Linux 2.6.7/NVidia drivers 61.11: 28.9 fps
So perfomance is very close, which probably attributes to slow CPU. One difference is that Windows Doom3 version is 1.0 - I didn't bother to download 1.1 and hack it to work in Win98 (shame on id for yielding
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:2)
This is great timing too. ID release the Linux client only 2 days after my girlfriend gave me Doom 3 for my birthday!
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:4, Informative)
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:3, Informative)
It's mostly CPU and GPU burning. Quality of the GFX drivers are very important.
Re:I wonder if the hardware specs are the same... (Score:3, Informative)
open the console: [~]
type: timedemo demo1
my results: 2148 frames rendered in 68.2 seconds = 31.5 fps
system specs:
AMD XP2000+
512 MB DDR266
GeForce3 MSI StarForce 822 ViVo 64MB DDR
KT400 chipset
os: Gentoo 2.6.9-rc2/NPTL/Prelinking/gcc 3.4.2
driver: nvidia 1.0.6111-r2
obviously my old graphics card is the bottleneck. I don't have a windows box here, but maybe someone who has a dualboot can test this benchmark.
Not much in the way of a HAL in Linux yet (Score:2)
Linux will get a form of HAL layer eventually, but I would imagine this will be bypassable to keep the embedded developers happy.
As for if Linux performs better, I'd say there's not much in it. While Linux has some better code for various things, GCC doesn't produce the fastest code, so
Re:Not much in the way of a HAL in Linux yet (Score:2)
Linux programs get the same interface in about every architecture as long as you stay away from assembler and accessing io directly (which is the kernels job anyway).... And even if you do program part in assembler its good practice to do it in C first so even then porting won't be a problem.
Jeroen
Nothing for you to see here. Please move along. (Score:5, Funny)
Errm (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Errm (Score:2, Funny)
Decent info here. (Score:4, Funny)
ATI Drivers (Score:5, Informative)
Re:ATI Drivers (Score:3, Informative)
Have a look at
http://www.petitiononline.com/atipet/petition.htm
to meet other frustrated people . i even sent a couple of emails to ATI folks
Re:ATI Drivers (Score:3, Insightful)
X.org V6.8 has been out for how long now, and in pre-release for how long, and yet, ATI does not have a build of their drivers for it. All the major distros have gone to X.org over XFree86, and yet ATI is not supporting the current release of X.org - this would be like them not supporting DirectX 9 for Windows.
Their drivers do not support the tuner subsystem on their cards, nor is it possible to get the GATOS
Re:ATI Drivers (Score:3, Informative)
The only reason I haven't switched (Score:3, Interesting)
DUP! (Score:5, Informative)
http://games.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=04/10/
Re:DUP! (Score:2)
Doom 3 for Linux Released
Posted by CmdrTaco on Tuesday October 05, @09:01AM
Linux Doom 3 Client Released
Posted by Zonk on Monday October 04, @06:30PM
Re:DUP! (Score:3, Informative)
Re:DUP! (Score:2)
If it's a dupe, just don't read the second one! It's not hurting you, and nobody's forcing you to read it. I know a "DUPE!" post equals an instant +5 for some unfathomable reason, but please resist the urge!
Slashdot is free for many of us, and cheap for the rest, so really, the fiscal loss, and the emotional pain and agony should be minimum. If you see something is a dupe, save your (and our) time, and just ignore the second posting
Who cares??? (Score:5, Funny)
"the Linux edition of Doom 3 has been released by ID Software."
Who cares about Doom?! I've been playing Duke Nukem Forever here on GNU Hurd for months!
Re:Who cares??? (Score:2)
A few special notes (Score:5, Informative)
Re:A few special notes (Score:2)
I'm too lazy (read: should be working) to go check.
Linux for games? Hahaha-hey wait. (Score:4, Insightful)
I know :) (Score:2)
oh no, not again... (Score:4, Interesting)
time will tell, and maybe these things will come, but most of the time these things loose steam as the team loses motivation and counts $$$.
Isnt it easier to develop for Linux, and port to windows? This way everything works in Linux, and if it works in Linux it cant be that hard to tie into windows? Easier said than done, sure, but easier than porting from windows to Linux.
I hope they take time to polish the Linux release and do not half ass it.
Re:oh no, not again... (Score:5, Insightful)
you say that like it's a bad thing. ID is a business, not a charity. The economics are probably very simple. The Windows version will likely turn a profit several orders of magnitude larger than a linux version.
If I worked for ID I know which version I would concentrate on.....
Do I have to pay twice? (Score:4, Insightful)
Not that this question isn't entirely academic, because my Linux box isn't capable of running Doom 3 anyways, but I am just curious how they are handling this.
Re:Do I have to pay twice? (Score:5, Informative)
There's no serial number check - anyone can download the game binary. However it's useless without the game data files which you'll have to copy from a windows install or from the CDs.
Re:Do I have to pay twice? (Score:2)
Shouldn't the serial key be required for online play? (I've never played Doom3 online so I don't know)
Re:Do I have to pay twice? (Score:2)
unless it grabbed the serial from my Windows install when I copied over the base/ directory (I extraced the pak files so I don't know what was all in that base/ directory)
Re:Do I have to pay twice? (Score:3, Informative)
Dumb question (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:Dumb question (Score:2)
thinking about it, mass piracy (like it doesnt happen anyway...) on windows will have a much bigger sales impact than on linux... so obviously they're not as bothered....
Re:Dumb question (Score:3, Insightful)
If it wants to verify the disc is copy protected it can do it during the key validation. Thereafter it should really make no difference.
Besides copy protection is a joke. It takes literally a few hours at most for someone to crack a game - I'm sure Doom 3 is already available over P2P in cracked versions - and I know there are cra
Re:Dumb question (Score:2)
Re:Dumb question (Score:2)
Anyway I've grabbed my Doom 3 for Linux now and its blissfully copy protection free. It's just too bad my Linux w/ NVidia NX2 is too underpowered to play it. I tried running it there and it was getting about 12fps. Still, I might be able to use it as a
Whither OS X ?? (Score:5, Interesting)
blakespot
Re:Whither OS X ?? (Score:2)
Re:Whither OS X ?? (Score:5, Informative)
The day the G5 arrived at my home I installed 2GB of Crucial PC3200 RAM (four 512MB DIMMs), bringing the total system RAM up to 2.5GB. I also installed a 74GB WD Raptor 10,000 RPM SATA HD, delegating the existing 250GB Maxtor for use as a "data" drive while the Ratpor takes on the boot / application storage role. I plugged my trusty external, FireWire 250GB Maxtor in to use as a backup drive.
A few weeks later I added a 3.3v PCI FireWire board with 3 ports. I've got a couple iPods, an iSight web cam, an external FireWire HD, and my DV cam to mate with the G5 from time to time. The extra ports make things a little easier.
Right now the machine has a Radeon 9600XT in the AGP 8x slot, as I'd mentioned in the original post. In the next few weeks I should be getting a GeForce 6800 Ultra which I will swap in for the Radeon. There's another upgrade.
I am trying to think what else I might wish to upgrade but will be unable, due to the difficulty you cite in upgrading Macs. I've got a 1250MHz CPU bus, and so I probably won't be wishing I could upgrade my motherboard anytime soon - but that would be a hard thing to do, granted. The two 2.5GHz, liquid-cooled CPU's are on a large daughterboard that connectst with the motherboard through dual CPU jacks. This would seem to allow 3rd parties to offer CPU upgrades down the road. They've certainly done so for the G3's and G4's in the past. I guess we'll have to wait and see. And it would be difficult to add another internal optical drive, I'll grant you. Given that this is a DVD writer capable of burning CD's, I've not go a great need for an additional unit that I can see. I suppose copying a DVD or CD would require caching to disk with just one drive, but I can probably squeeze that data somewhere amongst the G5's 575GB of on-line storage.
So I've got bluetooth, integrated modem, GHz ethernet, 5 FireWire 400 ports, 1 FireWire 800 port, 2 USB 2.0 ports, analog audio in/out, digital (optical) audio in/out, an additional headphone jack, AirPort 802.11g as an option, dual screen support via digital outputs, and 2 empty PCI-X slots. How am I held back again?
blakespot
Re:Whither OS X ?? (Score:3, Funny)
You don't by any chance were a black beret, have a goatee and show up on Penny Arcade from time to time do you?
It worked fine (Score:5, Funny)
I think I must have been out of ammo or something, because it kept giving me stick about command not find.
I tried apt-get and still nothing.
No seriously, everything works fine, except all the PDAs on the base don't work right, because I guess linux on the PDA is a bit immature for the martian market
Linux vs Windows performance (Score:5, Informative)
But I did notice it started up faster, and was smoother/faster in the menus in Linux than in Windows. And the whole computer wasn't slow for 30 seconds after I exited out of the game in Linux.
By the way, this story is a dupe, it was posted in the Games section yesterday (by a different submitter) so if you want more info check that out too.
WinXP Pro / Slackware 10
800x600 Medium Quality
AthlonXP 2800+
512mb ddr400
Geforce FX 5700 Ultra
Hrmmph (Score:5, Funny)
Next on Slashdot (Score:5, Funny)
-Release of the Doom3 Linux version. by michael.
-Linux Doom3 finally released. by Cliff.
-A look at the socio-economics behind the Linux Doom3 release. by JKatz
-The Doom3 Linux server is included in the Linux Doom3 release. By CowboyNeal.
- Doom 3 for Linux Released. by CmdrTaco who doesnt even read his own stories.
Re:Next on Slashdot (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Next on Slashdot (Score:3, Funny)
has a few limitations (Score:2)
Linux Doomed again!! (Score:2)
BitTorrent (Score:2, Insightful)
Works great ... but ... (Score:5, Informative)
Got pretty much exactly the same timedemo benchmark as win32 (same box), although I could swear it felt smoother and sharper somehow.
I think I can coax a bit more out of it - I could with Linux Quake3.
Pity about the 5.1 sound - I really hope they get a patch for that soon as it's a big part of what makes the game fun.
For the record, it seems you have to be running X in 24bit mode - unsure if that was the case for quake3 too ?
Another thing, which would only apply to the small percentage interested - no editor support under linux.
No idea if this is planned for a future patch, but GTKRadiant now supports Doom 3 (without the render preview in the current build)
Still, kudos to id software for supporting Linux !
Linux gaming benchmarks on Anandtech.com (Score:5, Informative)
http://www.anandtech.com/linux/showdoc.aspx?i=222
It's more of an AGP GPU on Linux comparison, but the information on some of the setup was, for a Linux newbie like me, a little informative. I had considered doing a Linux installation on my A64 gaming machine (using a separate hard drive) and installing some of the Linux versions of games that are mentioned in the article.
I'm curious, though -- do most of the mainstream game Linux versions come on the CD-ROM or have to be downloaded from the developer? Doom3, for example, requires the Windows CD for adding some files to the Linux installation. Enemy Territory is standalone. What about Jedi Knights: Jedi Academy, as mentioned in the Anandtech article? On the CD-ROM? Or a free download without requiring anything from the original Windows CD-ROM?
Anyway -- a good article. I enjoyed seeing information about gaming on Linux. Now, I just gotta get an Nvidia card so I don't have to struggle as a Linux newbie with the ATI driver installation.
IronChefMorimoto
Hmm.. interesting, but with a number of gotchas.. (Score:5, Informative)
But look at the FAQ for a number of gotcha!s..
- No AMD64 build (this would have been sweet.. but, oh well.. not a showstopper)
- Won't run on ATI cards using the fglrx driver! I don't know.. is this the driver used by ALL ATI cards for Linux? If so, this is a major issue for anyone wanting to play the game on Linux..
- No 5.1 sound.. considering that the eerie sounds are a good part of what makes the game..
In all, I'll be sticking to using the Windows version of the game
Re:Hmm.. interesting, but with a number of gotchas (Score:4, Informative)
Yes, the ATI problem is a major issue, but at this point, we are used to getting the shaft from ATI.
ATI drivers and running under FC2 (Score:5, Informative)
There were some new drivers [ati.com] released the other day.
I installed these applied the fedora patch [fedorafaq.org] and it runs just fine on a Radeon 9600. Not that fast mind you, but it certainly works.
BTW, if you are attempting to download, try the Bitorrent network, I pulled down the installer in about 30 seconds.
Better Support with Cedega(WineX) (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Well.. (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Well.. (Score:4, Informative)
Certainly not - not all articles make it to the main page. Maybe what's missing is an "All sections" page.
Re:Well.. (Score:2)
Re:Jon Carmack, eh? (Score:2, Insightful)
Seems that you should have taken another example [google.com]...
Re:Jon Carmack, eh? (Score:2)
Re:Jon Carmack, eh? (Butterfly Effect) (Score:2, Insightful)
Now, let's suppose that Carmack worked for "the US military" instead. He could have developed a new incredible cluster bomb, that was first tested en masse in Iraq and killed 1000s of people.
Never forget the Butterfly effect. You can NEVER predict what your actions may trigger as a result. I'm sure Einstein didn't see it coming when his nuclear
Re:Jon Carmack, eh? (Score:4, Funny)
Report of someone elses comments (Score:2)
http://lists.erps.org/archives/erps-l ist/msg04358.shtml
Re:Is Doom 3 free ? (Score:2, Informative)
id Bittorrent tracker (Score:5, Informative)
http://zerowing.idsoftware.com:6969/
Re:Pretty half-assed attempt (Score:2)
ATi is the one to blame for their poor support of *nix.
As for sound issues, there were software patent issues with Creative over 3d sound, which might have something to do with it. I don't know about the ALSA vs. OSS thing though.
Re:Had it yesterday. (Score:2)
Esp in the more cpu intensive areas, rotating my view left or right has jolts, but moving forward and backwards doesn't.
Re:Simple thanks (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Simple thanks (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Simple thanks (Score:3, Insightful)
Not because I like paying Electronics Boutique prices, but because it makes them tell the publishers "we're getting requests for Linux software".
Works for me... (Score:3, Informative)