2004 Board Games Gift Guide 489
The Morning News has come out with a nice guide to good gift boardgames, while Funagain Games has the list of the 2004 Board and Card Games of the Year (and the runners-up). Like a bowling ball with your name engraved upon it, these make great gifts for your significant other. Any other suggestions for good adult boardgames?
Do not pass "Go" (Score:5, Insightful)
Me: still a Go newbie but loving every minute of it.
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:5, Insightful)
It's amazing how simple the game is, yet the best computer programs in the world only play at an intermediate level at best.
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:3, Informative)
It has been a while since my AI class. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong here.
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:5, Informative)
Before I go on, I have to point out that I only have a deep interest in AI, I haven't actually started my post-grad coursework in it yet (hopefully next year). So my information might not be 100% correct (I look forward to someone correcting/supplementing my post). I should also add that I play Go on occasion, but I suck at it...
Go does have a very large branch factor, so brute-force techniques to playing well are nearly impossible (or take WAY too long to compute). Chess doesn't have a large amount of branching (relative to Go), so brute-force is actually somewhat effective. But the real problem comes when trying to actually write an AI that makes decisions instead of exhausting all possibilities.
In Go, there is a very large amount of information to process. The relative strengths of each player in each position of the board, the aggressiveness of the other player, common move patterns, and of course the number of possible outcomes of an action. Simply put, Go is simply too complex to represent and analyze in a simple manner.
It's my understanding that successful Go programs work by simply looking up common scenarios in a large database of pre-programmed moves, supplementing that with some basic neural network pattern recognition, and then narrowing down decisions with a brute force attack on a reduced set.
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:3, Informative)
It's my understanding that successful Go programs work by simply looking up common scenarios in a large database of pre-programmed moves, supplementing that with some basic neural network pattern recognition, and then narrowing down decisions with a brute force attack on a reduced set.
Um.. no.
Computer Go is very much in its infancy, and pretty much all computer go programs operate by using hand-coded heuristics to suggest moves, and then doing lots of old-fashioned local search. While there are some p
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:3, Insightful)
Most people measure the success of an AI by its comparability to humans, especially in games. It's important to note that not every AI researcher agrees; some feel that the state of the art is what matters more than material success. That aside, there is a game that
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:2)
Shortly after studying it, most of the people I played Go with ended up leaving town for various reasons, so I haven't played much since and I bet I'm a pretty awful player at this point. Hopefully your mileage will vary.
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:2)
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:3, Informative)
Lots of nice feature-rich linux clients support it.
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:3, Insightful)
On the flip side, it's actually easier to teach than chess (fewer rules, no difference in the pieces), so it fits a guideline in the article ("can be taught within five minutes") much better than most, if not all of the games in the article.
Incidentally, if you do get a board, you
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:3, Informative)
As someone who has casually played Chess for years and has spent the last month or so learning Go, I'm less certain about this.
In terms of learning the rules, Go is certainly simplier, but it's jarring to many people. While Chess requires memorizing a bunch of arbitrary moves, the core ideas are obvious to people: pieces move from space to space, you kill (capture) other pieces, you're trying to get
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:4, Interesting)
Incidentally, "claim the middle, threaten as much space as possible" are valid Go strategies, too.
Re:Do not pass "Go" (Score:3)
The possible number of moves in a 40-move chess game also outnumber the number of atoms in the universe [howstuffworks.com].
Yes, Go has much more branching, complexity, etc. But the Go players' hype is a bit misleading. It's like comparing the damage done to someone who jumps off a 30 story building with that to someone jumping off a 110 story building. The latter will hit a lot h
Slashdot account (Score:2, Interesting)
But seriously, how about a set of Mahjong [wikipedia.org], it's something different and provides endless hours of fun. They now come in travel size that you can bring along in trips.
And are there any ethnic-based board games that you can learn about other cultures (not Indians being shot at).
You sunk my Scrabble Ship! (Score:3, Funny)
Trivial Pursuit (Score:2)
You must have at least three different flavors in your collection to be classified a geek.
Re:Trivial Pursuit (Score:2)
Re:Trivial Pursuit (Score:2)
Re:Trivial Pursuit (Score:4, Interesting)
Ironically, Trivial Pursuit is a Canadian invention. Chris Haney worked as a photo editor at the Montreal Gazette, and Scott Abbott was a sports journalist for The Canadian Press. A good history of the game can be found here [about.com]
Re:Trivial Pursuit (Score:3, Funny)
Most Americans would say the same thing.
Re:Trivial Pursuit (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Trivial Pursuit (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Trivial Pursuit (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Trivial Pursuit (Score:2)
Trivial Pursuit has been ruined. I played the Genus 6 edition a few months back and the game has been dumbed down considerably. If the question was on a president, the answer was Clinton. Every time. Geography has been replaced with People & Places and the entertainment questions often involved the likes of Marilyn Manson.
I won the game pretty easily by just thinking of then-current (late 90s) pop crap most appropriate. And I am NOT talking about the 90s editi
Apples to Apples (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Apples to Apples (Score:2)
Re:Apples to Apples (Score:4, Informative)
Works best after a case or two when the phrase "Pressing wood into sheep" takes on whole new meanings.
Adult Boardgames? (Score:4, Funny)
Twister.
But for the love of God, put away the engraved bowling ball before you start. (Trust me on this.)
Re:Adult Boardgames? (Score:2)
Or did you mean the kind you play with your clothes on?
Re:Adult Boardgames? (Score:4, Interesting)
That would be the "goatse game". I think I'll pass.
For our wedding, my wife and I registered for, and received, Rock'em Sock'em Robots, Operation, Connect Four, Mastermind, and a few other classic games. They are still fun. We are planning on having a party where you have different game stations, and everyone visits various stations. If you win, you stay at that station (and do a shot). If you lose, you have to go to a different station. (and probably do a shot) Games are much more fun when there is drinking involved.
What! No Risk? (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:What! No Risk? (Score:3, Insightful)
Ob. Simpsons Quote (Score:5, Funny)
Homer: You sunk my Scrabble-ship!
Lisa: This game makes no sense.
Homer: Tell that to the good men that just lost their lives.
Re:Ob. Simpsons Quote (Score:2)
Bowler: Your fingers are so slender, so feminine. They're far too tapered for the ball you are using. You need something lighter, more delicate. Here, use my ball.
Marge: No, no thank you Mister... [looking at his bowling ball] Brunswick.
(For those who don't bowl, "Brunswick" is the manufacturer of the bowling ball.)
Heroscape (Score:4, Informative)
Heroscape! (Score:3, Informative)
suggestion (Score:2)
Twister? (with some modifications, of course)
Settlers of Catan! (Score:5, Informative)
http://www.boardgamegeek.com/viewitem.php3?gameid
Re:Settlers of Catan! (Score:2)
Check out my current latest JE for a good online site for playing board games.
Settlers is a great game! (Score:2, Interesting)
And the Cities And Knights expansion for the true hardcore player is a great gift. Of course, the true hardcore player probably already has this. And the Seafarers. Plus the 5-6 player expansions for all 3...
Re:Settlers of Catan! (Score:3, Interesting)
There's a java version with AI bots at http://settlers.cs.northwestern.edu/ [northwestern.edu]. Although sometimes the servers get clogged and you cannot get on, there's also a mirror linked at that site.
Trivial Pursuit (Score:2)
Re:Trivial Pursuit (Score:2)
Betrayal at House on the Hill (Score:3, Interesting)
Lord of the Rings (Score:5, Informative)
Graphically, the game is gorgeous. The boards, cards, etc. are all extremely well done.
Re:Lord of the Rings (Score:3, Informative)
Other Kniza games I'd reccomend:
* Through the Desert (think multiplayer Go, but this may be quite hard to find, as I don't believe it's been reprinted yet)
* Samurai
* Schotten Totten/Battle Line (two player card games, and quite portab
Mensa Recommended games . . . (Score:3, Informative)
Past winners of the Mensa Select seal can be browsed by year here [mensa.org]. Have some fun while exercising your brain.
Previous winners include Taboo and Magic-The Gathering.
Re:Mensa Recommended games . . . (Score:2, Insightful)
I agree 100%. (Score:2)
Re:I agree 100%. (Score:2)
--
Vote Libertarian! [lp.org]
I guess not.
Balderdash (Score:3, Informative)
Without Balderdash, I never would have known that vagitis means "what my wife is going to do to me when I get home" and that a shittah is "a ghetto toilet".
Re:Balderdash (Score:2)
I've gotta agree with this one. I've found that it needs at least 6 people to be fun, but some of my happiest family moments have been around the balderdash board. (We usually play it with extended family visiting, thus giving us a goodly number of players.)
"Diplomacy" from Avalon-Hill is a must-have (Score:4, Interesting)
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&safe=off&q= diplomacy+board+game&btnG=Search [google.com]
"Attack!" (Score:2)
Re:"Attack!" (Score:2)
Re:"Diplomacy" from Avalon-Hill is a must-have (Score:4, Funny)
And the Evil Turkish Empire is about to learn what happens when he crosses both Russia and Austria every turn for two game years... we finally got him flanked!
Re:"Diplomacy" from Avalon-Hill is a must-have (Score:2)
Diplomacy is my ... (Score:2)
My other big complaint with the game is that it takes too long to play.
Go (Score:2)
Then go to Wal-Mart or some other bargain store and get in 200 of each color glass drops. They make great stones until you can afford a real set. Plastic stones are available online for $20 or so. Real shell Go stones will reach into the $200 range.
Google, of course, has more
not for the average table (Score:2)
Settlers of Catan (Score:3, Interesting)
May not be intellectual but fun regardless (Score:3, Funny)
Extensive list (Score:5, Informative)
Pretty much lists everything you won't find at a local wal-mart.
My card game of the year... (Score:2)
cheapass games (Score:5, Informative)
a) The games sound like fun. Sure, who's going to advertise their games as totally boring and stupid? No one. But, Kill Doctor Lucky [cheapass.com] and Deadwood [cheapass.com] to name two I remember, have funny concepts and sound interesting to play.
b) They are CHEAP. And, seeing as to how most board games I've owned have been played about 3 times, max, the money spent seems much closer to the value derived than the $50 it costs for a lavishly wood-crafted board game.
Again, I don't know much about the product so don't come crying to me if they suck, but I'm probably going to risk a few bucks on them this year.
Re:cheapass games (Score:2)
at like, $4 a pop, you can afford to get some duds too, not that I've found any.
Re:cheapass games (Score:3, Informative)
I love One False Step for Man... It's a 3-4 hour long board game that takes a lot of strategy, so I'd pl
Poker Chips! (Score:2)
Fluxx (Score:5, Informative)
In the latter category was in which the player who won, wasn't even there! I played a card which basically caused everyone to play all the cards in their hand. One of the guys got up to answer the phone right before it became his turn. We played for him (since he had to play everything anyway;-) and the *&$*#&*&#*($&%**#&$^%*@&$ won.
Mindtrap (Score:5, Interesting)
A black dog stands in the middle of an intersection in a town painted black. None of the street lights are working due to a power failure caused by a local storm. A car with two broken headlights drives towards the dog but turns in time to avoid hitting him. How could the driver have seen the dog in time?
Re:Mindtrap (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Mindtrap (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Mindtrap (Score:4, Funny)
The gerbil is on fire?
Re:Mindtrap (Score:2)
Re:Mindtrap (Score:5, Funny)
The ping-pong ball is on fire.
Some other good games (Score:2)
Check out www.gamesinabox.com as that is where I buy most of mine -- usually each game is about $1 more, but they usually ship same-day and shipping costs are very reasonable.
Classic Battletech (What Else?) (Score:3, Informative)
Okay, so technically, it's not so much a boardgame as it is a religion and a Way of Life, but is there any geekier reason to throw dice and push things about a tabletop?
Scrabble cards (Score:2)
Find out more about them here
http://www.google.com/search?q=scrabble+cards
Be a Cheapass... (Score:5, Informative)
All their games are imaginative, fun and, best of all, cost next to f-all. It's refreshing to see someone trying to be fresh about game styles.
Personal favorites:
Unexploded Cow - a poker-style game involving incinerating BSE infected cattle in French minefields...
The Great Brain Robbery - Get your Zombie out of the runaway train by stealing brains with special abilities.
Bitin Off Hedz - even works for kids - a standard-ish board game where dinosaurs race to extinction.
They're so cheap you can afford to take a risk anyway.
Settlers of Catan (Score:3, Informative)
Squad Leader (Score:2)
Aspiring grognards may be interested in the Advanced Squad Leader Starter Kit [multimanpublishing.com] from Multiman Publishing. MMP has run out of it's first production run, though, but will be doing another run soon.
Yes, Squad Leader is still alive and kicking, and this is a very good way to learn it w/o reading the entire Big Damned Binder O' ASL Rules or taking a semester course in ASL.
No Nuke War? No Illuminati? BLASPHEMERS! (Score:2)
No Illuminati [sjgames.com]?
No Hackers [sjgames.com]?
I pronounce you all BLASPHEMERS and revoke your geek status, ALL OF YOU!
And after all, who can forget doing combinations?
"OK, I'll see your Bavarian Gnomes, and I'll sic Skippy on your servers at No Such Agency!"
cool games (Score:2)
These games are generally fast, fun and require more strategy than is readily apparent from the shipping package. I highly recommend Kill Dr. Lucky. It's fun. You are a guy who hates Dr. Lucky (a rich philanthropist), and you want to kill him while at his mansion for a dinner party. Only thing is, everyone else wants to kill him too, but you don't realize that. So you have to get h
Only one game for me... (Score:3, Funny)
http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/ASIN/075284
1000 Blank White Cards!!! (Score:2, Informative)
The game is totally self-adjusting to the playing environment, creative, fun and good for all kinds of times.
Plus it's the best game ever invented for getting women naked and doing nasty things!
-posted anonymously to protect the identities of women ive gotten naked-
Well, it is a card game, but I would suggest this. (Score:3, Informative)
It's a great game and you never get the same play out of a round twice.
My favorites (Score:3, Interesting)
Here's a list of games that I play a lot (in order that I think of them):
komi
Cashflow 101 (Score:2, Informative)
We got ours through eBay, not the link I provided, and it was cheaper. It was this game that got us started in real investing, not just 401(k) stuff.
Bad list !!! Use the offficial gamers database !!! (Score:2, Interesting)
http://scv.bu.edu/~aarondf/Top100/
voted on by thousands of board gamers!
bookmark it.
All your favorite baord games are in it (sometimes under german original release spelings)
Most of my favorites still in publication made it to the top 100 in THAT LIST.
I'd compare it fully to the other list in the news link but it was slashdotted instantly. Please avoid sl
Cheapass Games (Score:2)
PUERTO RICO PUERTO RICO (Score:4, Informative)
Then, I discovered why. Every person that I've introduced Puerto Rico to gets hooked. Here's a list of reasons why I'm a fanboy about it...
--) No waiting: When other people take their turns, all players must make decisions.
--) Creepily well-balanced. There is no (to my knowledge) "power move" or "race for a certain card" that lames out the game.
--) Incredible replayability: each time you play is different
--) Minimized randomness: Randomness exists in only a SINGLE aspect of the game. Everything is else is based on seating and "what are my opponents likely to do".
--) Fast games: You can play it three times in an evening. Crucial.
Zillions of Games (Score:3, Interesting)
Munchkin! (Score:5, Informative)
Very fun, quick game.
Days of Wonder (Score:4, Informative)
Mystery of the Abbey is like a thinking man's/geek's version of Clue. Instead of that boring ole rag of a board game, you get an intricate and well designed whodunit that has strategy and tactics involved as to who finds out what and how to play the game to win. This is a favorite in our household and whenever we have a gettogether it's the first board game pulled out.
Ticket to Ride is another Days of Wonder production, designed by a frenchman I believe, who ironically created a game about US train lines around the early 1900's. You have a set # of trains and must build them in tandem across the country. You must connect certain cities according to your "tickets" you recieve at the beginning of the game, always giving you a goal and with multiple paths to each city there is strategy involved as far as how you connect them and by what color (each route is defined by color). It gets more in-depth and is very fun/interesting and fast paced to boot. The younger kids in the family really like this one as its color-based, easily followed, and easy to learn.
As far as other games, we love card games. Bang! [twilightcards.com] is hands down the best multi-player card game I've ever played. Take that as you may, but I've played my share and it is awesome stuff. When a friend/family memeber asks us what we want to play, it's always Bang! Great mechanics, interesting roles to play, fun and funny to boot. There are some expansions to it (about a dozen cards each) to throw some variety to the game, but we've not needed those just yet. This is an absolute must-buy.
Queen's Necklace is another Days of Wonder production and is very cool. I know, a guy saying that playing a card game based on jewelry is cool, but it's a blast and is still fun with just 2 players (me and my wife play it occassionally). Easy to learn, hard to master, plenty of strategy and lots of enjoyment to be had.
Lastly I'll mention that Cheap Ass Games [cheapass.com] is a treasure trove of goodness, particularly Kill Dr. Lucky. This is a game that happens -before- Clue. Instead of figuring out who died and how, you actually get to kill that person! Of course, he's the luckiest guy ever, so it takes awhile and each person chases the good Doc around the mansion in an attempt to finally kill him in a variety of ways.
I think my favorite "Foiled!" card that showed up as I tried to Kill Dr. Lucky said something like "And suddenly...you felt not so fresh."
Hilarious, fun, and cheap!
Hope this helps
Carcassonne (Score:3, Interesting)
The Dot (Box) Game (Score:3, Interesting)
Take a large piece of paper and make a grid of dots that leaves enough room for a single legible letter inside the confines of each square (3/8" x 3/8"?). Make sure the paper is at least 20" x 30" to get enough of a grid. There is only a minor peanalty for trying to use equivalent metric units.
Everyone knows how to play this one, right? Connect two vertically or horizontally adjacent dots and write in your initial if you happen to complete a 1 x 1 square. Repeat until you cannot complete a square with just one line. The winner is the one with the most initialed squares when the grid is 100% filled in with squares.
The game works best when you see your opponent almost every day for just a few minutes at a time. Perfect for killing time in between (or during) school classes.
Reid Strand, if you are out there, I demand a rematch from our game in Ms. Moran's french class!
Scruples, Psychologizer, Articulate (Score:3, Interesting)
"Psychologzier" is another game in a similar vein, and is great fun too, but is out of print. You can still pick it up on Ebay every couple of weeks or so, though. Well worth it! Oh, and "ImagineIff" is great too. (Even if my mathematician friends call it "Imagine if and only if"...)
Articulate [peedeetoys.com.au] is another fabulous game, a sort of verbal Pictionary somewhat akin to Taboo and is absolutely hilarious. Great fun!
Finally, you should try Killer Bunnies [killerbunnies.com]. Hilarious when you've got a group of friends, and the designers have put a lot of work into making this quirky game fun. Lots of expansion packs, too!
Re:wtf (Score:2)
oh, I stand corrected, they have a Carcasonne game.
Alternately, while very few of them are suitable as a gift, CheapAss games still seems to eclipse the entire creative output of the rest of the boardgame/cardgame industry in North America at a fraction of the price.
Still, too bad all my faves are discontinued, like WotC's Robo Rally or CheapAss's Starbase Jeff.
Re:wtf (Score:2)
Carcassonne *castle*? If I'm not mistaken isn't that an expansion? Imagine the look on poor Bobby's face when he realises that he can't play the board game he's just been given...
Carcassonne: Hunters and Gatherers is far superior to the original game, on the other hand. Extremely balanced and a lot less confusing than Carcassonne (balance sucks) + castle + rivers + traders + king &c &c.
Re:wtf (Score:2)