Games That Keep You Coming Back? 601
The Guardian Gamesblog kicked off a great discussion on their site, talking about games that just keep pulling you back in. Games that, even if you've played through them once, you just have to pick them up again. eToyChest and Kotaku both have related threads. So, what about you? What are some videogames that, even years later, you just have to play through one more time?
For me, besides my ongoing fascination with World of Warcraft, Star Wars Galaxies, and Everquest II, there aren't that many that needed more than one playthrough. Both Half-Life titles, of course. I needed to play HL2 just to get everything I missed the first time. Jedi Academy and System Shock 2 required additional plays to try the game at a different angle. Similarly, I've played through the Diablo titles more than once each, as there's just so much clicking to be had. I somehow managed to avoid the gravity well of Civ4 for the most part, but Civilization 3 was almost the only game I played in college. Good times.
Some games off the top of my head. (Score:4, Insightful)
Wasteland
Nethack on alt.org [alt.org]
Star Control II
Re:Some games off the top of my head. (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Some games off the top of my head. (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Some games off the top of my head. (Score:3, Interesting)
Ah, flightsims! Personally, the one flightsim I keep reinstalling every windows upgrade/(re)install has been European Air War.
I know, Combat Flight Simulator and other very good and technically better, newer flightsims are out there, but EAW has a unique charm and many user add-ons, mods, tools, etc are still around.
Also i
Re:Some games off the top of my head. (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Some games off the top of my head. (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Some games off the top of my head. (Score:3, Interesting)
BZFlag (Score:2, Informative)
Re:BZFlag (Score:3, Interesting)
Obviously... (Score:4, Insightful)
The newest game to captivate me like this is Resident Evil 4, its a classic, getting to shoot anything with a shotgun, brill.
Re:Obviously... (Score:4, Informative)
Koules (Score:3, Informative)
Games that I can modify. (Score:5, Interesting)
Then again, card games are also always entertaining, and keep me coming back for more.
Re:Games that I can modify. (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:Games that I can modify. (Score:3, Informative)
Turn all the graphics down to minimum. For some reason, the arrows that tell you what direction to hit and when seem to be badly out of sync. Lowering the graphics settings seems to help somewhat.
Tetris (Score:2, Insightful)
Diablo! (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Diablo! (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Diablo! (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Diablo! (Score:3, Funny)
X-Com + Fallout (Score:4, Interesting)
Fallout 2 was amazing -- a huge world, violent weapons, and intensive role-play action. Anything post-apocalypic gets marks up from me
NESkimos -- Best. Nintendo. Metal. Ever. [neskimos.com]
Re:X-Com + Fallout (Score:2)
Nethack (Score:4, Informative)
adom (Score:3, Informative)
oh, and system shock 1, and fallout 2, and elite 2/frontier
I even bought system shock 2, but it wasn't that good.
Psst.. (Score:2)
I'm playing FF 7 right now :-) (Score:2, Interesting)
X-COM UFO DEFENSE (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:X-COM UFO DEFENSE (Score:2)
Re:X-COM UFO DEFENSE (Score:5, Interesting)
I'm an old fart (Score:3, Informative)
Crystal Castles (Rocks)
Omega Race
The original Star Wars, with the vector graphics
Xybots (this one isn't too old)
Re:I'm an old fart (Score:2)
Re:I'm an old fart (Score:2)
Devs should do this (Score:2)
Two words... (Score:2)
What is this blasphemy?! (Score:2, Funny)
Joust (Score:2)
Tetris (Score:2, Insightful)
System Shock 2! (Score:5, Insightful)
Don't get me wrong, I like (for instance) the Splinter Cell series, but if you don't sneak in the levels where you're supposed to sneak, you simply lose the game; when I've made it through such an obstacle course once I see no motivation to do the exact same thing again the next time through.
Re:System Shock 2! (Score:3, Insightful)
Oh so many... (Score:2)
Mr Do's Castle
Pacman
Mrs Pacman
Garou: Mark of the Wolves
Kung Fu
Mario Brothers (the two player original)
Joust
StarCraft
RC ProAM
Escape from Robot City
Gauntlet
Paperboy
Any Neo Geo or CSP1/2 arcade games.
Mame rules so much. Thank you world for Mame
Karl Buiter's Sentinel Worlds (Score:2)
Moo2 (Score:2)
MOO3 completely destroyed any fun in playing.
Re:Moo2 - AGREE! (Score:2)
Regarding someone else's reply, MOO I vs MOO II, I think I'm more MOO II. It just seems more refined, IMHO. And of course, MOO3? WTF were they thinking??!?
Monkey Island (Score:3, Interesting)
Monkey Island II is the game I play the most. I normally play through at least one Monkey Island game every year, I just love the humor (I like the first two parts the most but enjoy III and IV as well).
Maniac Mansion II: Day of the Tentacle is also one of those games I replay quite often. Like Monkey Island, the humor is just great.
Too bad Sam and Max II was cancelled and that the gaming industry doesn't produce good adventures (especially humorous adventures) any more... at least I haven't heard of any.
My list (Score:2)
Civ (the original)
Masters of Magic
Masters of Orion
XCOM (most of them)
Continumm (formerly Subspace)
Heroes of Might & Magic
WoW
Most of them are games from the ealry 90's and their sequels.
My list (Score:2)
Fallout 2 Nothing better than trying a role that I've never played yet.
Masters of Orion series I even fired up MOO on DOS Box the other day just as sweet as it always was.
Frontier: First Encounters Holy crap do I wish I could get x2 working or that they would release Elite 4. That series has always led with graphics, unstructuredness, and fun.
X-Com--Fighting my way to mind control and then making the etherials do m
Counter-Strike (Score:3, Interesting)
Think of it this way, why do you go back and play the same sport you like over and over. Because you like to compete in basketball, or football or whatever. Same thing with CS, it's all about competition, and it'll keep you coming back.
P.S. If you're worried about cheaters, there's many communities that are organized with the specific goal of stopping this threat with sophisticated anti cheat software and admin support.
Check out ESEA [esportsea.com] CEVO [cevolved.com] NEL [nationalesports.com] CAL [caleague.com] GGL [ggl.com]
Addictive games (Score:2, Insightful)
Gunstar Heroes (Genesis, Treasure) - It just has great gameplay, your characters seem like an extention of you. The stages are each unique and are fun obstacle courses to run through.
Megaman (NES, Capcom) - It's just a really unique and weird game, one of the first of its kind, the enemies and characters had a lot mo
Super Metroid (Score:2, Interesting)
My choices (Score:5, Interesting)
Super Smash Brothers Melee: My and my friends spend hours battling it out. One of the few games of this last (meaning pre-X360) generation that really had incredible gameplay. For the majority of people I know that own a GameCube, this game is the reason why they bought it.
Diablo 2: Patch 1.10 added a whole lot of material and pulled back a lot of people who left during the 1.09d era because of hackers, dupes, and overall lack of depth.
Pokemon: Fun to replay it with different creatures...what can I say. I didn't believe that my friends were actually going to spend several hours playing this all over but I have to say, I kinda wanna play it right now haha.
Baldur's Gate II: So much depth in this game. Tons of classes and races, tons of items, over 200 hours of play time because of a myriad of subquests - and this doesn't include the expansion.
Fallout 2: One of the best RPG's ever. And so unique in comparison to the stale overused 'fantasy' setting RPG's. Fun to go run around towns doing side quests and talking to all those people I never talked to before.
Unreal Tournament: Still a great Lan Party game, because it runs well on everyone's computers and just has outstanding FPS gameplay overall. A few years from now, I'll add 2004 to this list because it's gameplay modes are also amazingly addictive.
Note: I know there are a lot of CLASSIC games that aren't on this list (esp. on consoles), but I leave them out because I think the important factor here is replay value and so the grading is a little different. Games that tend to be strictly linear especially hurt from this.
C & C (Score:4, Interesting)
I bought the game the hour it was released locally (Mechanicsburg, PA, where I was at the time) and was eventually recruited for every clan on the net
Yeah, I play as iggy_mon there, too. If you pick up the multipack for around $20(us) join me!
Thief (Score:2)
Super Mario 64 (Score:2)
For me, there are just two (Score:2)
2) Quake. Again, the original, not II, III, IV, or any of the derivatives. Occasionally I like to kill all the lights and at about one in the afternoon, fire up Quake and just start playing. I can usually get through the entire game by midnight or 1 AM. I find it - refreshing
Deus Ex (Score:5, Insightful)
The sad thing is I have it for the Mac and it only runs in classic mode now. When the intel move becomes ubiquitous they aren't going to do classic and I'm going to lose Deus Ex (as well as all my nostalgic classic apps). Very sad.
-David
old school mac games (Score:2)
marathon
escape velocity
maelstrom
Total Annihilation, Neverwinter Nights. (Score:3)
Re:Total Annihilation, Neverwinter Nights. (Score:3)
Re:Total Annihilation, Neverwinter Nights. (Score:2)
I will never forget multiplayer games of TA that I had, the total fear the first time a Big Bertha had my base under fire. Or the innocent days when you all suck and some brawlers could chew through the enemy. Great times using the corporate ISDN network for 2vs2 play. Ahh man, good times.
In case you haven't heard:
http://www.gamespot.com/pc/strategy/supremecommand er/news.html? [gamespot.com]
Re: (Score:2)
Civilization. (Score:3, Informative)
Not many games pull me back in years later.... (Score:2)
Civilization 1, 2, and 3 were all excellent games with lots of "staying power" though. Every time I run across the installation discs for one of those titles and decide to load it back on a computer for the heck of it, I end up playing another round or two of them.
I've never completely grown tired of Warcraft III (with the Frozen Throne expans
Well... (Score:3, Informative)
Nethack - Of course. Though I'm not that good at it
Transport Tycoon Deluxe (And OpenTTD) - This one never gets old, and with OpenTTD it gets new features all the time.
Thief 1 & 2 - Simply great, too bad Thief 3 (imo) wasn't nearly as good as these two
Fallout 2 - I hope Bethesda can make Fallout 3 as good as this one...
Operation Flashpoint - Not that old yet, but a superb game, especially in multiplayer co-op
Doom 1 & 2 - Somehow I still can enjoy playing the same old original maps through one more time
And of course many C64 and Amiga games, though most of them feel too hard today. I guess the new games have spoiled me.
Oldies - Empire ... (Score:2)
Tetris (natch) (Score:2)
Re:Tetris (natch) (Score:4, Informative)
Star Control II (Score:4, Interesting)
Occasionally when a discussion of game storylines crops up, I'll pitch in a few kind paragraphs for Star Control 2. The conversation archives on The Pages of Now and Forever still relate the same compelling story, and I still remember my horror when I initially learned of the Kohr-Ah's plight. The most convincing villain is one you feel sympathy for, and they had that going, for sure.
A few weeks ago, I downloaded the most recent build of The Ur-Quan Masters. The first build I tried a year or so ago wouldn't start up, but this version ran flawlessly. The music was perfect, the graphics were just as I remembered them, and the interface took a little getting used to but then felt very comfortable.
So why did the game bore me? I played for probably half an hour, and couldn't seem to get interested. It's not that I knew the ending -- I played the game through 3 or 4 times back when it was new, and it didn't seem any less fun the second time around. I haven't been much for games in the last few years, and I'm still struggling to figure out why.
so many PC games in the responses... (Score:2)
Emulators, on the other hand, do a dandy job of making the pile of still-functional cartridges I have for my long-dead consoles very enjoyable:
Bionic Commando (NES, I'd kill for a Metal Gear Solid styled "update")
Final Fantasy 6 (SNES please, the Playstation version introduced load time)
River City Ransom (NES- single player'
The first FPS/RPG ever (Score:2)
My list (Score:2)
Dreamweb
Master Of Orion
Deus Ex
System Shock 1 & 2
Ascendancy
X-Com 1 through 3 (#4 is a little disappointing)
Fallout 1 & 2
and many others.
Sid's Alpha Centauri (Score:2, Informative)
Nethack (Score:4, Insightful)
my picks (Score:2)
I'm going to have to say... (Score:2)
Tetris - The old gameboy version, very addictive.
Armagetron AD [ http://www.armagetronad.net/ [armagetronad.net] ] - A very nicely done Tron light cycle clone.
many (Score:2)
dune 2
vtrek
elite
wing commander
unreal tournament
railroad tycoon
Dune (Score:2)
LucasArts (Score:2)
Civ 3? Civ 4? (Score:2)
Hell, I still play Civ 1 all the way through at least once or twice a year!.
COUNTER-STRIKE (Score:5, Interesting)
The irony, in the 6 years that I've played the game, I have yet to learn how to aim.. instead, I've learned how to improve my spray-and-pray. <shrugs> I must be the most leet noob I know.
FF3, Tetris, and Quake 3 (Score:2)
Final Fantasy 3 (Or 6, depending on who you ask)
It's like a favourite book - even though you know what happens, and where the story's going, you enjoy the telling of the story so much you keep picking it up.
Tetris
Must. Fill. Holes. With. Falling. Blocks.
Quake 3
OK. So it's hopelessly outdated compared to other FPS's, but it's got just the right level of complexity (that is, almost none) for me to kee
Mostly oldies: (Score:2)
Samurai Showdown 2 (Score:2)
The main reaso
It's all about the Commodore 64 (now emulated) (Score:2)
Deus Ex (1) (Score:2)
Excellent storyline, deep characters, and the thrill of finding stuff I missed.
Every choice I make, whether to kill or let live, has an impact. I've yet to find a game with a level of depth and choice like this. And it's been at least 5 years since I first had it...
I'd like to nominate (Score:2)
Close runners-up would have to be "Smash the Taco: Signal 11's Revenge", and the sequel, "Attack of the GNAA".
Quake2 (Score:3, Interesting)
I'm bored (or procratinating) so here's my list. (Score:2)
Puzzle Bobble - Well, make that 2.
Galaga - All right, 3.
Alpha Centauri - Best writing in a video game.
Katamari - The gameplay keeps me occupied. The music keeps me coming back.
Diablo II - Therapy
Mario Kart (original and DS) - Weapons are fun, but the racing is second to none.
Wipeout (1 and 3) - Best futuristic racer. Best music in a racer. Psygnosis made them with love.
Pilotwings 64 - Relaxing, beautiful, frustrating.
Goldeneye - How cou
--- ELITE --- (Score:3, Interesting)
http://oolite-linux.berlios.de/ [berlios.de] - for the Linux binary installer (autopackage or tarball, your choice - has *no* dependencies for most distros) and source code.
http://oolite.aegidian.org/ [aegidian.org] - for the Mac OS X version.
A windows port is also under way (currently in alpha, you can get it from ftp.alioth.net/oolite)
Simulators, Skills and Sandboxes (Score:5, Insightful)
In fact I'm a bit of a flight sim nut so long as the sim is sufficiently complex. There is always something new you haven't tried. Learnt Acrobatics? Try navigation. Learnt to navigate, learn to fly a 747 properly. Learnt that too how about crosswind landings, night flying etc. With the remote control sims there's always a new trick to try and master and your accuracy to improve. What's more you don't have to spend $200 and 3 weekends fixing things after every crash.
Then there's software that teaches you a classic game like Chessmaster. You can always get better at chess, and there are lots of tutorials in Chessmaster 10 so you can go through them again after a year or so and you're reminded of something you'd learnt but almost forgotten. The I can play in a virtual tournament against a number of virtual opponents.
These are the sorts of games I keep coming back to. They manage to keep your mind and/or your reflexes going without being completely artificial...and sure it's a cartoon world with virtual this and that, but hell I'll never get to land a real 747 or play chess against a grandmaster for real, so I appreciate these experiences.
Freespace 2 (Score:3, Informative)
The game gets complicated with all the different tasks it requires you to do (switch the targetted subsystem to destroy critical points of capital ships, commanding squadmates to attack specific targets, targetting bombs, etc.) but flows into it smoothly with a very forgiving learning curve.
This is an all-around fantastic game. It's showing its age, but still looks excellent graphically.
Re:Freespace 2 (Score:3, Informative)
I agree completely, as far as space-sims go, Freespace II is the single best overall, even compared to newer ones such as the X series and Freelancer which was a bit more arcadey.
However, theres good news regarding the game's aging graphics. If you are unaware, Volition released the source code for FS2 a whiles back and since then the players have unified their efforts into the FS2 Source Code Project in w
M.U.L.E. (Score:3, Informative)
Super Mario Bros (Score:5, Interesting)
The Carmageddon series (Score:3, Interesting)
Such a shame that Carmageddon 4 got canned. I still have hopes for its appearance though. Fingers crossed.
Tetris and Quake (1) (Score:3, Interesting)
As for Quake 1...I first played it in 1997 on my Windows 95, Pentium 1 computer. I've since played it at some point on every computer I've owned since then. I don't know what it is, but I have yet to find a finer FPS, especially one to replay so much. Perhaps it's the complete lack of scripted events mixed with the oldest-considered realistic graphics and atmosphere...but whatever it is, I can't get enough.
I also have a soft spot for Novastorm, a somewhat mediocre Playstation (1995) sci-fi blaster game. Despite its flaws, I have to play it every now and then, for the primitive charm.
Re:they don't make 'em like this anymore (Score:2)
Re:I'm shocked! (Score:2)
Re:for me and what little it's worth (Score:2)
Re:Paradroid (Score:3, Informative)