Grammy Awards Finally Giving Games Some Respect 70
donniebaseball23 writes "Video game composers have been fighting for equal recognition at the Grammy Awards, and they've just taken another step in the right direction, as The Recording Academy has added video games to the descriptors of four awards, giving them equal billing with film and television. 'I think this could be viewed as a first step in the direction of video games getting their own category,' said the Recording Academy's Bill Freimuth."
Re: (Score:2)
I wonder if there's a People's Choice Award equivalent for the Grammy Awards.
Re: (Score:2)
Exactly. This is the crowd that gave Jethro Tull "Best Metal Album" and made Christopher Cross (yeah, I know, who?) their darling for one year. Who gives a flying frak at a rolling donut if they recognize gaming or not? But, hey, don't worry, be happy.
It's like animation fans who complained the Oscars had "ghettoized" them by creating a separate category for animated films. I kept asking them why they even cared what that circle jerk of pampered, Moon-sized egos did.
Re: (Score:2)
It's like animation fans who complained the Oscars had "ghettoized" them by creating a separate category for animated films. I kept asking them why they even cared what that circle jerk of pampered, Moon-sized egos did.
Like it or not, winning an Oscar turns into huge money for a film. Having a separate category for animated films has guaranteed that they'll never win Best Picture. Which goes a long way towards the idiot argument of "animated films aren't Real Cinema - when's the last time one won an Oscar?"
As little as I care, I'm glad they are included in an existing award, rather than put down at the kiddy table. Not expected one to *win* anytime soon, but at least they're included.
Re: (Score:2)
OK, but these are just animation fans I know. They have no financial stake in the films. Well, one owns some Pixar stock, I think, but Pixar hardly seems to be suffering from the situation.
not even close.... (Score:3)
Re:not even close.... (Score:5, Insightful)
You are aware that the grammy awards are about music?
Stops playing one BGM and starts another (Score:2)
That *is* iMUSE (Score:2)
Smooth transitions won't be possible for several more years, at least until US Patent 5315057 [Assignee: LucasArts] expires at the end of 2014.
Bullshit. Just look up any old LucasArts iMUSE game
The patent I linked to is in fact the patent on iMUSE, owned by LucasArts. Please allow me to rephrase: Smooth transitions won't be possible for several more years in games not published by LucasArts until the end of 2014.
Re: (Score:1)
Then what about Escape From Butcher Bay?
Re: (Score:1)
"Smooth transitions won't be possible for several more years in games not published by LucasArts "
Bullshit. Borderlands, the original Unreal, both have quite smooth transitioning into music tracks.
Are you aware the Grammy's are a joke? (Score:4, Insightful)
The Grammy's are the most notoriously meaningless awards in any field. They're owned by the studios, who use them as little more than PR tools. Every year they're won by the same predictable chart-toppers (indies need not apply), they reward popularity over talent (two words: "Milli Vanilli"), and no one takes them seriously. In fact, the Best New Artist Grammy has been jokingly called the "Kiss of Death" award, considering how most "artists" who win it end up becoming one hit wonders. The only reason anyone even watches that joke of an awards show is for the performances. And even those are pretty forgettable.
The Simpsons said it best. In an episode where Homer wins a Grammy, he takes one look at it, sees it's a Grammy and throws it out the window. Then, out the window, we hear a voice yelling "Hey, don't throw your trash out here!"
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Arcade Fire
Warner Music Group has been distributing all Merge Records releases since 1993. Of course, you'll never learn that unless you dig into it, since they don't want to lose their indie cred by publicly being associated with a big studio. Read up on the Alternative Distribution Alliance [wikipedia.org] to see how Warner is secretly behind quite a few "indie" labels.
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:1)
Every year they're won by the same predictable chart-toppers (indies need not apply)
Yeah, the timing of this move is extra suspicious, last year many indie artists were represented and nominated, including the huge surprise of Esperanza Spalding beating Justin Beiber for Best New Artist! (even if you hate him, everybody's heard of him, how many people have heard of her? not many is my guess).
Even if the Grammy's are diluted, they can help launch careers, just by exposing people to artists they might not be exposed to otherwise, another case in point, Nora Jones, a few years ago.
Whet
Re: (Score:2)
The Simpsons said it best. In an episode where Homer wins a Grammy, he takes one look at it, sees it's a Grammy and throws it out the window. Then, out the window, we hear a voice yelling "Hey, don't throw your trash out here!"
Actually, he takes it back to his hotel room where he tries to pawn it off as a tip substitute to his hotel attendant. The guy replies "Oh boy, an award statue! Oh, it's only a Grammy." and tosses it down the balcony. The rest of the quote is accurate.
Re: (Score:3)
Wow, you are deluded. Considering most major games these days use techniques that are used in film for cinematic sequences, stories that have much more depth than the hollywood reeltrash, and actors that are also big names in hollywood, well, maybe they are more deserving than films these days.
Aside from this, it's not the Grammys that need to respect games... it would be gamers needing to respect the grammys - which I doubt will happen.
I'm not sure what games you play that make them "choppy by nature", but
Re: (Score:1)
Bah! There is more "art" in games than there is to be found in movies or tv from Hollywood. Hollywood is great at the craft, but there are too many comities involved in the production of a typical main stream US movie or tv show and they manage to strangle any art out of the equation. There are of course some exceptions, like probably a few big name directors that can film their vision without too much meddling.
Games have had the chance to be more original, but as gaming becomes more prevalent, more of art
Re: (Score:2)
Video Games, as an art, are relatively young. Film has over a hundred years behind it, while games have merely forty [..] One can hardly expect an adolescent to have the same capacities as a fully grown adult.
Funny that you should compare video games to an adolescent. I've long thought that the industry's current obsession with seeing its own "maturity" and development in terms of comparing itself to the film industry as a sign of its underlying *immaturity*.
Right now the focus seems to be on pretentious, self-congratulatory attempts at cinema-mimicking narrative and emotional depth through self-consciously (*relatively*) big budget, cheesily-written sequences played out via horrid, unconvincing and mannequin-li
Bwana Devil (Score:2)
Games haven been 3D and Digital since at least 20 years now... Cinema has only recently catched up to video games in that regard
Cinema has been 3D since day one and stereoscopic since Bwana Devil in 1952.
Re: (Score:3)
Wow, you are deluded. Considering most major games these days use techniques that are used in film for cinematic sequences, stories that have much more depth than the hollywood reeltrash, and actors that are also big names in hollywood, well, maybe they are more deserving than films these days. Aside from this, it's not the Grammys that need to respect games... it would be gamers needing to respect the grammys - which I doubt will happen. I'm not sure what games you play that make them "choppy by nature", but they aren't the games that I am playing.
Movies follow a linear progression of near constant dialogue. Game cinematics are broken up by uh....gameplay? I have seen a few games that move between cutscene and gameplay fluidly, but in many games this is a fault. One example being a boss battle. You kill your enemy with weapon A and the cutscene shows you doing so with weapon B OR you "kill" your enemy but in a cutscene they merely appear exhausted. This is choppy cinematics.
LOL and BLAH... Duuuude!... Games haven been 3D and Digital since at least 20 years now... Cinema has only recently catched up to video games in that regard... get your facts updated man... and Metal Gear Solid is from 1998... so much fail...
and finally, i know I shouldnt fee
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Heavy fuckin' Rain. Great movie that plays like a game.
I played the demo and it was just awful. The first problem was the horrible controls: no free-look, awkward swiping motions, and just terrible walking animations. I felt like I was awkwardly controlling a zombie. They really should have just licensed an engine that didn't suck, something like GTA IV.
The second, and even more fundamental problem, was having to separate your attention between control prompts on the screen and following the "movie". Trying to do both at the same time takes the enjoyment out of
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
or even play Mega Man Legends 1 or 2...it's like a playable cartoon.
Call of Duty games realistic? (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Cinematics, story and voice acting in your average videogame cannot come close to the equivalent in feature films. Games are event-driven, so they're choppy by nature. There are games like Metal Gear Solid that have great cut scenes, but many gamers have complained that it seems more like a movie than a game. That seems like it's always going to be an argument, because if people wanted to watch a movie they would do so. They wouldnt be playing games
On the other hand, check out this list:
1) No one makes any money but the distributors due to crooked accounting, and the distributors are being destroyed by "the internet".
2) Mass distributed content is formulaic and repetitive remakes of the same tired old ideas and frankly hasn't had anything new or fresh in many years.
3) 1% of the population is fanatic about it, the other 99% simply do not care.
4) Everyone in the biz thinks the world revolves around them, everyone outside the biz doesn't care at all abou
Games shouldn't be treated as movies. (Score:1)
And I don't mean because games cannot be artistic. That's idiotic.
I mean because games are made better than Hollywood movies are.
I didn't believe this until recently. I thought even the most garbage movies shamed PC games. Then I played Mass Effect 2. I loved the game. But the Hollywood movie influence is everywhere.
Notably, the 'epic' (but unreal) shots. A character spray-firing a machine gun with no aim because it "looks cool." A character leaping off a falling building and it crashing down around him, ju
For example: music in games! (Score:2)
Finally!! This is great news because, seriously, music production in the latest blockbuster games is truly spectacular. Hear the latest Shogun 2: Total War soundtrack [totalwar.com] and it's frankly Hollywood on Windows!
Re: (Score:2)
Why in just the latest blockbuster games? The best game music is from the 8-bit era, when composers were so limited that it really took a genius to make anything sound good.
Who gives a fuck about the Grammy awards? (Score:2)
Just a bunch of RIAA insiders stroking themselves, and insisting the rest of us must care about it (since it dominates the newscast that night).
The reason it took so long (Score:2)
...was that for the past 18 or so years, the grammy for game music (heck even awesome drowning sounds -- remember Quake Classic?) would have always gone to Trent Reznor hands down.
Civ 4 (Score:4, Interesting)
The title song from Civilization 4 won a Grammy this year, becoming the first song from a video game to do so. I wonder if that had anything to do with their decision? As is often the case, you need really top-notch, undeniable talent to break down the barrier. Once it's broken, things get easier.
Re: (Score:2)
If I'm not mistaken, though, it won not because it was video game music, but because it was released on an actual album and was actually good.
IMHO "actually good" is the understatement of the year. I looked up that music on youtube after the grammy award and it FLOORED me. And not just one version but:
- The official music/video version (of just the baba yatu song)
- The PBS special on the first live performance (including the "coronation" intro, TWO videos, and a duet). This is the version
Who cares? (Score:5, Insightful)
Re: (Score:2)
Where's my mod points when I need them. Gone are the days when the industry can say "look at me" and we all collectively do.
Re: (Score:1)
I don't have a problem with game awards shows that award all aspects of gaming and development. If it wouldn't appeal to a huge general audience, then broadcast it online to a niche audience (a well done one would still be huge) and treat it with respect and dignity. I'd pay a few bucks to watch that live online every year. Awards are part of acknowledging and rewarding bold new attempts, even if they're not commercially successful. They're important in every industry, frankly. Granted, some are more releva
About the Grammies? Naw, but the IGF? I for one. (Score:2)
As a gamer, I couldn't care less about *any* award show.
I dunno, I'm a pretty big fan of the independent game festival [igf.com], and seeing who won what. Usually nukes a week or two of productivity for me.
Re: (Score:2)
JRPGs - credit where it's due (Score:1)
For me the JRPGs would dominate any top 10 list of game soundtracks (spending a fortune licensing commercial music a la GTA doesn't count).
Presumably, Western composers get paid peanuts to write in-game music, and the results are laughable - music nobody would ever choose to listen to outside the context of the game.
There's no reason for the Grammys to recognise Japanese artists such as Koichi Sugiyama and Nobuo Uematsu who are truly brilliant modern-day composers - I think computer game composers command a
Re: (Score:2)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJfIbfOLvpI [youtube.com]
Re: (Score:2)
Chris Hülsbeck (Score:1)
Some of the music he has composed
- R-Type
- Giana Sisters
- Turrican 1, 2 and 3
- Apidya
- Tunnel B1
- Extreme Assault
Re: (Score:2)
Lifetime Achievement Award (Score:4)
Now if only they will go back and give Nobuo Uematsu a lifetime achievement award! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Final_Fantasy#Music [wikipedia.org]
Let me just say that... (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
I'm making a note here, huge success.
It's hard to overstate my satisfaction.
Re: (Score:2)
Fahrenheit (Indigo Prophecy) (Score:1)