Dreamcast Mark II Prototype On Show 67
The good news / bad news out of Sega picks up a few details today, as reader The vm writes: "The folks over at Daily Radar are sporting an article with pictures of the new Dreamcast set top box that Pace and Sega have recently announced. So far it sounds a bit shaky since they haven't partnered with any content providers yet. Only time will tell if this 'Tivo meets Sega Channel' product will wither on the vine or grow into something with mass appeal."
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:2)
Nevermind.
Re:NetBSD (Score:2)
--
Re:It will work (Score:1)
SOME existing games could be served this way (some games are quite small in terms of total megabytes of data, Virtua Tennis springs to mind as a quality game but (relatively) small in size), but I'd bet they are largely going to focus on smaller games or perhaps cut down episodic versions of full games.
Re:am I the only one who's confused? (Score:1)
Re:What kind of psuedointellectual claptrap is thi (Score:1)
Well, to each his own I suppose.
ata standards for content copy protection. (Score:1)
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:2)
I think you're on, er, on to something. If all of these realities have equal validity, then it's in fact no worse/better to kill someone in one of these than in what we construe as "real life". We aren't simply playing at killing someone, we're killing someone in a different reality.
This is all well and good in Quake, where the person respawns. But what about Rainbow 6, where there is no respawning? Is this murder? Could I prosecute someone for that? Case law, the DMCA, and the EULA say yes.
With the Dreamcast set top unit, this will only become worse. So many realities downloadable in an instant, all wired up for multiplayer-- people are going to murder reality even faster than the original poster. Now that's a scary thought.
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:1)
"Does this mean that I can sue Dan Fogelberg for turning me into a pu**y in the 70's?
"'Your honor, between the defendant and James Taylor, I didn't get a bl*wj*b until I was 27.'"
Maybe this is a little off-base, but I think it speaks to the issue raised: does media alone incite action?
In case you can't tell from my post, I think it doesn't.
-1 Troll (Score:1)
People keep saying this nonsense, but this story just said it was on display. People are interested.
Please do not feed the trolls.
--
Thoughts and Ponderances (Score:1)
First of all: The article says that this thing supports online gaming. That indicates to me that this box is built on the same platform as the Pace DOCSIS set-top box, which is based on the Cisco reference design (and QA on it was done by Cisco.) So not only will it support online gaming; Between you and people in your neighborhood, you'll have blinding fast connections. To anyone else it'll depend on what your ISP's upstream is like.
Two: This thing will flail. Why? Because it doesn't have a damn GD-ROM drive in it. HELLO, PACE. If you're going to put a DC in the box, you have to make it people for people to buy a DC game off the shelf and load it. By "off the shelf", of course, I refer to all the usual methods for getting a CD, which includes ebay, and the discount rack at the store. If people can't do that, they won't be especially interested.
Three: Pace has been working on a DOCSIS STB (again, that's set-top-box) for some time now. Their previous model seems to work. I don't know if they're scrapping that in favor of this, or what. I do recall in the first conversation on /. about SegaOA licensing the DC chipset/software out to other companies that some people were talking about what it would actually be good for; This is an excellent application, especially since they already have a TCP stack, Web Browser, and some sort of 3D-based GUI library, which appears to be in ROM; Note the screens on which you control memory cards and so on.
Finally, if Pace only makes it possible for you to get games via their subscriber service, then anyone who buys this thing is a blithering idiot, unless they plan to run some flavor of BSD on it. Then there's an excuse. Of course, if it doesn't have Ethernet, and only has DOCSIS (over your CableCo coax), you're better off waiting a couple years for the STBs which have Ethernet and POTS (Plain Old Telephone Service) coming out of them to hit the market. Those will probably have a DC built into them too. Or at this rate, a PS2. Let's hope those at least have a DVD-ROM built into them.
--
Re:I've said it before and I'll say it again. (Score:1)
Looks like we're finally getting what we want.. (Score:2)
Everyone knows that Sega has some of the best franchises ever, and that they're developed in house. Having sega as a developer on your platform means you're guaranteed at least a few good games - none of this playstation2 launch bullshit.
I love my dreamcast (first console i've owned since an 8bit nes) and while on one hand its disappointing to see the DC going away, its good that sega will have more focus on making their titles. Who cares what color the machine is as long as Sonic the hedgehog is still blue ? Plus, with the VF series on playstation hardware, maybe all those button mashing idiots (read: tekken fans
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:1)
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:2)
Isn't the classic example... a horrible tyrant (eg. Hitler) who's able to go home to his family and love them? Or a clergyman who can be saintly in front of his church and still commit sins when away from the public eye?
IMHO, there are significant examples where a person is able to entertain two conflicting sets of morals in different circumstances, and still be able to cope relatively well. I don't see why different realities would be any different.
--
Control (Score:1)
Destroying consumer ownership definitely throws the ball into the BIG CORPORATIONs' court.
I am not being paranoid with this stuff either. Nintendo is one of many game companies that tried to make the renting of games, and buy/selling of used games illegal. Of course, the courts said "get out of here", but with a change of technology, anything is possible: even the loss of great amounts of freedom.
Hard Drive (Score:1)
Which could also pose problems for the set-top hackers: having to decrypt the information on the drive to install *BSD, *nix, whatever, and then write that encryption scheme into the kernel...
Of course, if you just used it for the purpose it was marketed, it could be nifty.
Re:Is it just me... (Score:1)
"Everything that can be invented has been invented."
Re:I've said it before and I'll say it again. (Score:2)
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:1)
Is this why SEGA stopped making Dreamcasts?!? (Score:1)
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:1)
They're sure as hell not taking away my UT.
Perfect timing (Score:4)
Contrast this with Sony support on the Playstation. Just before they launch PS2, they refit the PS1 and start shipping this. Which is a clear sign to gamemakers that the PS1 is not dead even though PS2 is out.
Sega has shown their intentions and has made sure that I for one will go for another platform if I decide to buy a console.
Aw man... (Score:1)
What I need is a video game weapon in real life. Like a Rocket Launcher that self reloads and a backpack that can store a few hundred rockets in it.
The controller cable issue (Score:3)
As anyone who has tried to put a console system on top of a TV knows, there is a serious problem. The cables for the controller hang in front of the TV. I can only assume that the placement of the ports is an attempt to avoid this problem, though the guy on the opposite side is still probably screwed.
The solution, if you really need a set TOP box, is to have a single, short cable that runs to a secondary controller port box, which goes UNDER the TV. I don't think any other configuration will work.
Just my random musings. Continue debating the future of Sega now.
--
gnfnrf
Content providers? Please.... (Score:2)
Sega goofed in making an underpowered and too-easy-to-manufacture dual purpose machine (the same Dreamcast technology is identical to their Arcade machine) and releasing it too early. I don't have much faith in this new device, period. Sega only wins when they support a powerful software library. They haven't had a big hit in the USA since Sonic 3.
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:1)
Unless I win, that is; then I'm a war hero.
--
Re:The controller plugs into the TOP? (Score:1)
"Improved" doesn't sell. (Score:1)
Once people get a certain association in their brain between a label and a product, it's very hard to change it - especially for kids. That can be an advantage (name recognition) and a disadvantage (old embarassments).
When you hear "Playstation 2", even if you know nothing about it, you're bound to think that it must be incrementally related to the Playstation 1. Your views of the Playstation 1 will taint your appraisal of the Playstation 2.
On the other hand, when you hear "X Box", even if you've heard something about it, you still have a lot of unanswered questions. It's mysterious. It's unknown. Imagination fills in the gaps between news and rumor to make the unknown exactly what you hope for, and far far better than what you've got. That's what makes "new" so difficult for "improved" to compete with.
As for why companies get into these vaporware hype contests, it's all about mindshare. If you're not being talked about, you're losing market share hand over fist - perhaps not at the sales counter but definitely in the media and consumer imagination. Hype does produce financially successful products. Just ask Microsoft!
Re:It will work (Score:1)
The file transfer bandwidth on the CDRom drives in console boxes is probably not much beyond 300kbyte/sec. That's "only" 3mbit/sec - well within cable broadband capability. Even at a third that rate, you could still run today's console games over the network with full media content.
Looks like a hastily made move for Sega... (Score:2)
Back then, there was no concern for compatibility (or even quality it sometimes seemed). The big players at CES (Commodore, Atari, Tandy, TI--interestingly Apple and IBM often avoided these shows) always had busy booths and the odd new machine, but were notorious for making vapourous product announcements (I think they all said at one point that they would have built-in voice-synthysis and modems in at least one of their models. Of course, none of that ever surfaced). Smaller players (Coleco, Mattel, SpectraVideo, etc) were even worse. They would show non-functioning display prototypes (the first Coleco ADAM display was a hollow plastic case locked behind smoked glass--the working demo was powered by bare boards hidden elseware). Sometimes they would change their product announcements (pricing or specifications) to take the steam out of a competitors product launch (when Atari and Coleco announced the prices and specs of their new products, SpectraVideo actually SOLDERED MORE RAM CHIPS into their prototype machines--right on the trade show floor!).
With such unsophisticated marketing strategies it is no wonder they all bit the dust. Now I see Sega and Pace doing the same thing--besides touting an early prototype, they allowed one of their marketroids to make a "cryptic, possibly un-informed" product announcement. They also left many very important questions unanswered or ambiguous (Who the hell is going to serve up the games? How do I pay for them? Is there a menu system for managing games the hard drive will store or what? Time-limit on storage of games? Use of encryption technology?). Given the current state of tech-stocks and the fact many tech writers remember the roller coaster ride of the 80's home computer industry and the more recent dot-com fiasco, Sega runs the risk of looking desperate and indecisive (are they a hardware or software company or both, and who is going to design and produce their platform in the future?).
Histore really is doomed to repeat itself...
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:2)
I think this is a funny way to look at it, so I most definitely would agree...
This is all well and good in Quake, where the person respawns. But what about Rainbow 6, where there is no respawning? Is this murder? Could I prosecute someone for that?
Well, sure, it is murder. So if there exist a court system in Rainbow 6 someone could probably prosecute you. But don't forget that that is in a different reality than this, so you can't be punished here for what you do in that other reality ;-)
So I guess the Dreamcast will increase the total number of murders in all realities, but just don't forget that most of those murders will not be in this reality ;-)
Is it just me... (Score:1)
The controller plugs into the TOP? (Score:1)
If I lean back, the console better be crash-resistant.
aint gonna happen (Score:1)
I've said it before and I'll say it again. (Score:4)
A parent can feel safe letting their child play videogames without supervision because, unlike the internet, a parent can currently control all the access to specific videogames that a child might have. It costs a lot to buy the game, one need's parental permission to get it at the rental place.
A parent cannot feel safe when a kid can go home and download the latest new thing, without having to check with parents. Yes there are passwords and safety features, but this is a far lower level of safety than the level afforded when a clerk at the video store requires adult presence to rent certain games.
NetBSD (Score:2)
Wither on the Vine! Wither on the Vine! (Score:3)
-jpowers
Re:Is it just me... (Score:2)
welcome to america
Too complex (Score:2)
My first thought when I saw the picture in the article was, "Ick, it's a PC." While it may not exactly be a PC, it does, IMO, suffer from featuritis--a problem I see much too often these days. I can live with my game console, my VHS deck, and my DVD player [no, I don't actually have one] separate just fine, thankyouverymuch. I won't even go into the issue of more complexity = more bugs; I'm just getting tired of these so-called "all-in-one" solutions that never actually do all of what you want.
--
BACKNEXTFINISHCANCEL
Just an off-the-shelf Dreamcast. (Score:2)
This is a Dreamcast set-top box that I could put together in a couple of hours. If this is the best that Sega's partner company can come up with, then the Dreamcast set-top box will probably never happen
Cryptnotic
Re:NetBSD is dead (Score:3)
Or how about this? There is an infinite amount more traffic on the official freebsd user mailing list as opposed to the linux official user mailing list, hence linux has zero users.
Moral? These numbers don't prove a thing. I've seen this troll with every BSD post, and it's about time you give it up. If you believe that BSD is dead, suit yourself- there's no need to reassert it.
Of course, I shouldn't feed the troll- it just gives you the attention that your parents never did.
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:2)
Humans can adapt.
--
Re:Nope, that's not going to do it. (Score:2)
[OT] The link at the bottom of the page is... (Score:2)
Check it out:
Re:I've said it before and I'll say it again. (Score:1)
This is what happens to you if you play too many computer games!
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:1)
I think it was David Kronenbourg on the subject of movie violence mandating film censorship who said (approximately) -
"Where I live, people who can't differentiate fantasy from reality are called 'insane'"
Si
Re:Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:2)
Re:Content providers? Please.... (Score:1)
Have you *seen* the games on Dreamcast? They are easily the best line up of games in the first two years of a console on any system since the SNES. Unfortunately, they will be the only two years. What killed sega is that they had no money for marketing after the saturn failed and coin ops in general bombed. And Sony has a LOT of money for marketing.
Just as the Cubs are mathematically eliminated (Score:1)
Mark II screenshots [ridiculopathy.com]
I hope you don't let your children on a PC... (Score:1)
This is not a bad thing (Score:2)
I doubt piracy will be as big a deal as is suspected. Dreamcast games aren't terribly difficult to rip as it is, it just takes a good bit of technical knowledge and time to dump a game over the serial port, not to mention burn the game. I expect it will take the same amount of technical knowledge to rip games off this set top.
This box seems more aimed towards casual gamers who might just want a quick game of Chu Chu Rocket or Sega Smash Pack rather than Skies of Arcadia or Phantasy Star Online. Just my $.02
Realistic violence leads to real violence (Score:4)
Is it not then dangerous to play a console game in which agents are motivated by entirely different principles? There is no reason in evolutionary psychology to suppose that we are capable of differentiating in the long term between different representations of reality, which are all in the end subjective.I think it is dangerous that in this modern world there are so many differnt virtual universes for us to exist in. It could be that we are unnable to cope with this - our brains are made for the evolutionary plains of Africa, not the modern world of TV, books, consoles, the Internet, Radio, etc etc. We are suffering from an overload of representative realities. It has been speculated that this is the cause behind Alzhimers desease and Attention Deficit Disorder - the inability to be satisfied with just one reality.
Consoles of this hyperrealistic nature could well greatly exarcerbate the minimal problems we have in this area at the moment.
I just wish we knew more about these sorts of issues before we wantonly introduced new consoles.
This post may have seemed a littled bit off base, I suppose, and I am sorry if it appeared so. I just had to get it off my chest. It is interesting though, if slightly worrying.
You know exactly what to do-
Your kiss, your fingers on my thigh-
casual speculation (Score:2)
But this box looks like a prototype for the Pace pitchsters, and they are merely playing the cut-throat salesman game with these press stunts. There is no telling what Sega is going to do next, based on these scanty pieces of speculatory journalism and dog-and-pony press events.
I hope Sega figures out something quick though. As for this hardware, it sounds sweet enough, and I'm sure it will play my current dreamcast disks (the article seemed to imply you could play dreamcasts games by downloading them, neglecting to mention backwards-compatability with the dreamcast media), but it stands the chance of falling into the same trap as the PSX2. The consoles are a loss leader, and adding a Tivo is only going to make the problem worse. I've read that PSX2 is killing Sony in Japan because folks are buying the set-top box and ignoring the games, instead just using the hardware as a DVD player. This sounds dreadful until you remember that Sony is selling a major percentage of the DVD's as well... Oh-boy, there's just too many variables at play here. I can't figure it out. But at least one thing is certain- Indrema won't factor into things at all. And that's the real pity.
:)Fudboy
Stillborn (Score:2)
I really hope that Slashdot shows more restraint. An example from the print world are the magazines Popular Science and Popular Mechanics. If you were to believe these publications, by 2001 we should all have been commuting to work in solar powered gyrocopters from our $10K home made of low cost carbon composites, situated on 1 acre which includes a hyrdoponic garden for year 'round fresh vegetables.
Slashdot, there is a lesson there if you are wise enough to see it.
First impression... Controller cables on top... (Score:1)
--
"No se rinde el gallo rojo, sólo cuando ya está muerto."
Nope, that's not going to do it. (Score:1)
I was under the impression the original Dreamcast had pretty much the necessary capabilities to be a set-top box. With the current shift away from desktop PCs, the "new" set top arrangement with the integrated Dreamcast will still face competition from Sony, TiVo, Microsoft, etc in both the game console and set-top markets. So it basically hasn't changed it's position.
I want a set top box that emulates (older) game consoles , SNES or MAME [mame.net] stuff would be great !!
--
Re:Just an off-the-shelf Dreamcast. (Score:2)
Obviously it's a prototype, as advertised. Functionality comes first, then good looks.
Do you have any better ideas for getting power to the thing? (:
Actually it's a heatsink [dailyradar.com] covering the CPU and PowerVR (pic [min.net]). The leads for where the GDROM drive would be [min.net], are going to the hard-drive looking apparatus at the front-left of the case. Coupled with the fact that it has what looks like an EPROM for the BIOS and two coax leads [dailyradar.com] coming out of the back-left of the box, maybe this thing is exactly what they claim it is, a prototype of a box that lets you download games onto a hard drive and play them.
It will work (Score:1)
I prefer having my Dreamcast seperate from my other home entertainment stuff. It's like the idea of a TV/VCR combo, if one of them breaks, the other is pretty much useless. Now, let's say you want a bigger TV but don't really need to buy a new VCR? Too bad. Same concept, let's say a much better model of this was released, do you want the Dreamcast still? Yes. Do you want to pay for that part again? No.
Cool (Score:2)
OTOH, the old unix paradigm of 'Do one thing, do it well' may apply
Re:I've said it before and I'll say it again. (Score:1)
Down that path lies madness. On the other hand, the road to hell is paved with melting snowballs.
Re:"Improved" doesn't sell. (Score:1)
> if you've heard something about it, you still
> have a lot of unanswered questions. It's
> mysterious. It's unknown. Imagination fills in
> the gaps..
With Microsoft at the helm, my imagination can fill in quite a few gaps on X-box.
Like it's just a cheap PC with Windows CE and Direct X in it, and a cheap 3D card (TV doesn't require much resolution.)
History (Score:1)
Right after launching the SNES Nintendo refitted the original NES and started shipping it, selling it for $50. A clear sign to gamemakers that the NES was not dead even though the SNES was out. A wrong sign, of course. The NES died anyway, so fast that the refitted NESs now sell for upwards of $100 on eBay.
I've said it before and I'll say it again. (Score:2)
A parent can feel safe letting their child play videogames without supervision because, unlike the internet, a parent can currently control all the access to specific videogames that a child might have. It costs a lot to buy the game, one need's parental permission to get it at the rental place.
A parent cannot feel safe when a kid can go home and download the latest new thing, without having to check with parents. Yes there are passwords and safety features, but this is a far lower level of safety than the level afforded when a clerk at the video store requires adult presence to rent certain games.
Re:Wither on the Vine! Wither on the Vine! (Score:1)
-jpowers
Sega, the next Atari?" (Score:2)
am I the only one who's confused? (Score:1)
Of course, this might just be a ploy to keep their investers on board.
On an unrelated note, is it just me or do there seem to be an awful lot of vaporware consoles lately? The X-Box (which might not actually be vapor), the nintendo thing, the PS 3, —whatever happened to traditional "wait until it's ready to be released until you promote it all over the place" marketing?
-------
another mistake by Sega (Score:1)