Games That Should Be Remade 116
Thanks to an anonymous reader for pointing to Gamespot's new article on videogames that should be remade. This third article in an ongoing series starts with the statement that "..we feel like there are plenty of titles from the annals of gaming history that deserve another shot at the spotlight, and that's exactly why we assembled this list." It goes on to pinpoint titles such as The Bard's Tale (rumored to have a remake in development already), Bullfrog's classic Syndicate, APB, and even the original X-Com as being worthy of an update.
M.U.L.E. (Score:5, Insightful)
But it would be the greatest game ever if it happened.
Re:M.U.L.E. (Score:1)
Every once in a while the regional EA rep would come buy and ask how their stuff is doing. I would always suggest that EA remake MULE. And every time she would reply "Thats the most requested game. But they won't do it."
I think MULE was great; but it was the game play that won me over. Its a tough one for any developer, I think. MULE was all about game play, not fancy gra
Re:M.U.L.E. (Score:1)
There was a period when MULE didn't stand a chance in the gaming market, but thanks to the popularity of games like The Sims, I think a net-workable version could do very well. Imagine it like this, though: You expand the personal development section considerably. Not only can you install/transfer MULES and hunt the Wampus, but you can do maintenance, tweaking,
Re:M.U.L.E. (Score:1)
I know someone had a very good version of MULE working. I think they were calling it MULE386 or somehting like it. It was good enough that EA phoned up and said drop it or we bring in the lawyers. It worked; the project dissappeared. I've never played Space HORSE or any others. But at least once, EA took an interest in the clones..
Re:M.U.L.E. (Score:2)
Even less well known is the MULE remake Traders [the-underdogs.org] by Merit Software 1991. It was clearly a remake of the original game, but unfortunately they added an unnecessary fighting aspect to the game if things wern't going your way.
Another MULE clone (this one I haven't played) is Subtrade: Return to Irata [the-underdogs.org] by Century Interactive 1993.
Nostalgia (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Nostalgia (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Nostalgia (Score:1)
Re:Nostalgia (Score:2)
Why do people always say that modern games are all flash and no substance?
Sure, the % of good to crap has probably gone down, but the sheer number of games produced means that there are still more good games than ever produced every year. Luckily we now have the Internet so we can get reviews by the bucketload.
As far as classic style games are concerned, there are many of them coming out still (for GBA, anyway) and even when they jump to 3d, the good
River City Ransom on GBA?!?! (Score:2)
Re:River City Ransom on GBA?!?! (Score:1)
Here is the news item, and a link at the bottom
River City Ransom is one of the most talked about cult-classics from the NES generation, and yet it only received a sequel for Super Nintendo in Japan. Fans outside of Japan haven't seen anything new since the original game was released in 1990. Now Atlus is bringing the game back with River City Ransom EX, a remake of the original NES game. River City Ransom is a unique game that blends actions, fighting, and role-playing elements into
Bionic Commando (Score:2)
M.U.L.E. (Score:5, Insightful)
There is an Atari 400/800 emu called Atari800WinPlus that uses a server called kaillera to tie multiple peopel together so you can play the original atari version, tho kaillera seems to also be popular for MAME games.
Re:M.U.L.E. (Score:1)
Anyway, uhhh... me too.
Re:M.U.L.E. (Score:3, Informative)
Holistic Robotic Slave Engineer = HoRSE is even worse than M.U.L.E. = Multi Use Labor Element
sorry, no OSS projects that I know, and I've been looking, I had a friend working on making a Java clone but he got bored and went on to other stuff (I'm no programmer)
Re:M.U.L.E. (Score:2)
Why does all the really fun software come from Poland, of all places? ;)
tainting the classics? (Score:4, Insightful)
Ultima V? Don't mess with the classics. please.
With a remake of this game, it would leave out what is missing with most games these days: imagination. 2D rpgs made me wonder how the lands really looked and made me think about the character personalities etc. (think about how Link from Zelda never speaks)
Out Of This World? Gamespot claims that it helped pioneer 3D but it in fact used 2D rotoscoped animation.. not true 3D. Speaking of which, a 3D remake would ruin the rugged look of the classic which can't be reproduced.
Re:tainting the classics? (Score:1)
Classically tainted (Score:4, Interesting)
I'd love to see a remake of my all-time favorite, Sword of the Samurai [mobygames.com]. Or maybe not. Everything I loved about the game was dictated by the limited technology of the time. Low-res EGA graphics? Make all the game screens look like a Japanese wood-cut. Junky MIDI music? Hire a good composer to write simple drum and lute pieces, then hire a clever designer to integrate the music seemlessly with the game action. Wonderfully beautiful. But if they remade it, it would have high production values and the playability of burnt toast.
Re:tainting the classics? (Score:2, Insightful)
Chuck Yeager helped pioneer space flight, but he wasn't an astronaut.
Re:tainting the classics? (Score:2, Insightful)
Call me anti-progress, but I'll never forgive Nintendo for ruining the Zelda series with their 3d based worlds. Just give me an epic 2d overhead.
Re:tainting the classics? (Score:1)
RE was almost exactly the original with all sorts of little extra things and boosted graphics.
Dragon's Lair was very similar too. Considering the source material, it was very good and it felt very familiar too. It was just dying over and over and over and over and o
Re:tainting the classics? (Score:1)
I'm really not trying to be bitter and jaded here, but sequels and remakes (just like in movies for the most part) are usually less than stellar. Sure, there's exceptions to the rule, but they're just that, exceptions.
Nostalgia and emulators (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Nostalgia and emulators (Score:2, Interesting)
After playing through the first Final Fantasy again (via Origins) with the SNES-quality graphics I was creamin'. I can only imagine the other classics: basically all the FFs, Xenogears, Chrono Trigger.
*starts to drool*
-Reed
Re:Nostalgia and emulators (Score:2)
Re:Nostalgia and emulators (Score:2)
FF4 (FF3 in America, if we're talking about the same thing) is my absolute favorite game of all time. I was a lot younger then, but Terra and Celeb... oo!
I don't really play computer games any more (expect maybe tuxracer once a month), but I'd buy that in a second (if i could manage it in wine/there was a gnu/linux port)
the good ol' days...
Re:Nostalgia and emulators (Score:2)
Meaning FF4 (2) = Cecil et al and FF6 (3) = Terra et al.
Easy way to remember? Take the real number of the game and divide it by two to get the Americanized version!
some of these DON'T need remakes (Score:2, Insightful)
Zelda - thanks but we've seen sequals to this one. I can't imagine the original being redone to make it any better.
Darklands - awesome game! I'd love to see a remake or something similar. I have fond memories of playing this on my 386. (=
ShadowRun - really needs to be remade. Now more than ever. There are too many fantasy rpg's/games and not enough near future/sci-fi ones.
The rest of the games in vol. 1 were pretty mediocre. I could do without remakes, thanks.
Volume 2:
Re:some of these DON'T need remakes (Score:1)
Bionic Commando: Only if they do a quality remake of the original music to go with it. In 3d would have to get around the minor problem that you can't look up to fire a grappling hook and aim forward with a gun at the same time.
Out of this World: Its funny, I was just playing Ico, and got a very strong flashback to this amazing game. No pun intended.
Don't think a remake would work though. The scenarios wouldn't really work in 3d, and a 2d version wouldn't be interesting enoug
Re:some of these DON'T need remakes (Score:1)
You're kidding, right?? Panzer Dragoon epitomized what was great about Sega - old skool, simple gameplay in a totally addicting and nice looking package. And Saga was a *spectactular* RPG.
As for Space Harrier, if you ever played it in the arcade, you'll realize why people loved it.
Re:some of these DON'T need remakes (Score:1)
Cyberball was cool because it was a combo of RPG stats and bizzare gameplay. It played more like a hybrid fighter/rpg than a sports game, and it was tons of fun (and nothing comes close to it today).
As for Final Fight, it was as much a remake of Double Dragon as Unreal Tournament 2003 is of Doom. Huge sprites in comparison, tons of animation beyond DD, characters that did different things and had different moves, better team moves, overall better graphics... etc. etc. But we may n
final fantasy (Score:1)
Re:final fantasy (Score:1)
Re:final fantasy (Score:2)
Re:final fantasy (Score:1)
Who really cares about the graphics in FF games? All I care about is that they work on hardware I have. As long as Sony maintains
Speedball 2 needs a remake (Score:1, Interesting)
Try "Deathrow" (Score:2)
It plays very much like a modern Speedball 2.
It's full 3D, the ball is not a ball (it's a disc), you may only have 4 team members on the field at once, etc.
But despite the differences you do get the same kind of fast, demanding and violent gameplay, with a futuristic feel to it.
I'd say it's the only game besides Halo that would make me go buy an xbox.
Unfortunately the game had no marketing and sold lousy despite pretty decent reviews,
Boulderdash (Score:3, Interesting)
It was remade, and very well! (Score:2)
Well worth it, and usually bargain priced.
One of my first games (Score:2)
Where's Starflight? MOM? Racing Destruction Set? (Score:3, Insightful)
'jfb
Re:Where's Starflight? MOM? Racing Destruction Set (Score:1)
anyway, MoM might even get a sequel [orionsector.com]. well, then again im not sure if i want a sequel like MoO3
Re:Where's Starflight? MOM? Racing Destruction Set (Score:2)
Re:Where's Starflight? MOM? Racing Destruction Set (Score:2)
'jfb
Master of Magic (Score:1)
There's a free MoM remake project at AgeOfMagic.org [ageofmagic.org]. Not sure what the development status is (last news is almost a year old), but I'm living in hope...
Re:Where's Starflight? (Score:2)
That game was AWSOME. Communicating with alien species, exploring planets...I wasted so many hours with that game, and its sequel.
Re:Where's Starflight? (Score:1)
Re:Where's Starflight? (Score:2)
Nah, in Starflight you fly around ina spaceship and talk to other spaceship. You don't conquer anything.
X-Com/UFO: Enemy Unknown (Score:3, Informative)
Check out the screenshots [lasersquadnemesis.com] - nicely updated and runs well on practically any spec PC - handily enough, they even offer a free trial.
I should mention, it can be dangerously addictive. Maybe not PlanetSide-grade addictive, but getting there.
Final Fantasy Origins (Score:2, Informative)
Duke Nukem Forever (Score:1, Funny)
Re:Duke Nukem Forever (Score:2)
The Summoning! (Score:1)
I'd like to see all of Event Horizon's early isometric RPGs remade, really. I know I'd gladly shell out for updated versions of DarkSpyre/The Summoning
Fruity Frank ! (Score:1)
huh ?
System Shock! (Score:2)
Re:System Shock! (Score:2)
System Shock 2 remake [Some screenshots not work-safe] [wanadoo.fr]
And personally, the first two games I thought of when I saw the topic were the Genesis version of Shadowrun, and Skitchin'.
Re:System Shock! (Score:2)
Re:System Shock! (Score:2)
Re:SS2 (Score:2)
Aztec and Wings of Fury (Score:2)
Commander Keen (Score:1)
3D first-person version of Commander Keen. Keen had several things
going for it. The characters were cartooney, and everyone knows that
cartooney violence is much more fun than stuff that looks real. In
addition, the pogo stick was really innovative and added a great
deal to the gameplay. I'd particularly like to see that item done
in a first-person 3D version of the game.
Elite (Score:2)
(Or anything not Microsoft, in fact. I'd buy a GameCube to play a state-of-the-art remake of Elite.)
Re:Elite (Score:1)
Joust (Score:1, Interesting)
The only challenge is finding a balance between
the old massochistic carpal-tunnel-inducing control
scheme and a dumb-ass flight simulator -- you should
still have to flap your wings IMO.
Chuck Yeager's Air Combat.... (Score:1)
I also see Archon is being remade. I have no idea why it took so long...
And last but not least, someon
Manhunter! (Score:2)
Must it be said... (Score:1)
Crush, Crumble, Chomp! (Score:1)
Bilestoad was another original concept I've never seen copied. It was a slow motion (but not turn-based) top-down fighting game, with weapons and shields. Very cool.
A few games I would like to see remade (Score:1)
Knights of Legend - or a sequel
Comment removed (Score:3, Interesting)
the best game(s) (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:the best game(s) (Score:1)
Magic Schoolbus (Score:2)
X-Com/Syndicate and other remakes.... (Score:2, Interesting)
Syndicate: I just found my install disks for this game not too long ago. I'd like to see it remade since I never did get closure on this game....that final mission on the oil platform (?) I could never complete....
My hope for remake is the soon to be orphaned High Heat franchise from now bankrupt 3DO. Last year's (HH 2003) had all the guts of a stats game and had a rather average set of gra
Awesome! (Score:3, Insightful)
Wish list...and a few are... (Score:4, Interesting)
Now, there is work being done on a Shadow of the Beast 3D [kickme.to].
There is also work being done on...
Space Racer [sourceforge.net] - Update of Stunt Car Racer
Trophy [sourceforge.net] - looks real close to Racing Destruction Set
GLTron [gltron.org] - one of many clones of the old tron cycles games
Vega Strike [sourceforge.net] - Clone of Elite (I know there's an Elite 4 [frontier.co.uk] listed on Frontier Development's page, but judging from the copyright notice at the bottom, it hasn't been updated since some time in 2001)
TrackBalls [sourceforge.net] - Clone of Marble Madness
and...
XArchon [seul.org] - Update of Archon
And they're all open source...which means that you can play current beta versions in most cases...
Eye of the Beholder series... (Score:1)
I would love to see a remake of them. Not that EoB III was that good. But EoB & EoB II was magnificent.
Another game that has been remade is Defender of the Crown. Which was released originally on the good old Commodore 64, but also on other system such as Amiga and the PC.
EoB for Gameboy Advance already available (Score:2)
http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.gsp?prod
I loved that game on the Amiga. Enjoy!
Re:Eye of the Beholder series... (Score:1)
http://www.nintendo.com/games/gamepage/gamepage
System shock 2 (Score:1)
Sadly tho, the company that produced it, Looking Glass, ran into serious difficulties during the games developement (both financially and of the technology) so the release version was a bit rough around the edges. Shame really... a couple of more weeks and a wee bit mor
Re:System shock 2 (Score:1)
http://perso.wanadoo.fr/etienne.aubert/sshock/s
RoboSport! (Score:1)
My list (long time list:) (Score:2)
#1. Kid Icarus. There are a lot of us who have been wanting this for years. My first NES game, and one that I still have a ton of fun playing. I see a 3d platformer with both vertical and exploration stages. The vertical stages would keep the play dynamic of the originial, with a "void" appearing a bit beneath you to keep every jump different. You would have the bow and arrow of course, and the ability to spend hearts to buy items. And don't forget the cast
Re:My list (long time list:) (Score:1)
Car Wars (Score:2)
I personally have a problem with emulators because they allow me to play old games from my childhood that I had fond memories of, and after playing again realize they really blow. Thanks emulators! I'm looking at you, Sword of Fargoal!
No one remembers... (Score:1)
I'd gladly kill you all... (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:I'd gladly kill you all... (Score:2)
Frankly, if MoM could get an updated AI and some of the unit restrictions lifted (1000 in-game units?), it wouldn't need to be re-made at all.
I've had no problem playing that gmae constantly for, oh, eight years. I didn't even get to truly challenging games until maybe a year ago Impossible Klackon Nature wizard etc.
True joy is Slingers with a 14 missle attack taking down demi-gods and Sky Drakes with one hit. Wh
Master of Orion (Score:1)
Roadwar 2000 (Score:1)
Re:Roadwar 2000 (Score:2)
So if you get a bad start, pffft. Gone. Once I dimly recall finding some scientists or something and I DID finally get good at the fighting, but that game turned into move, scavenge then starve.
Is there some reason I should have fonder memories than that?
Re:Roadwar 2000 (Score:1)
Add a few more to the list: (Score:1)
Rise of the Dragon, (anyone remember that one?)
Stellar 7 (not the Nova 9 crap Sierra came out with as a "sequal")
Gabriel Knight:Sins of the Father (In my book, the all time best adventure game.)
Star Trek/Star Trek:Judgement Rights
I'd really like to see some remakes of the old Lucasarts adventure games(Loom, Day of the Tentacle, and of course: Monkey Island!)
Trespasser and Alpha Centuri (Score:1)
Remakes Do Not Generally Work (Score:1)
Remakes usually are made in the spirit of "how else can we milk this cow?"
Take the movie industry for example. Usually if a remake is considered good, then that means the original may have, well, sucked; take Ocean's Eleven for instance, the original was eh, which made it easy to make a great remake. Expectations were never high. But then, a decent movie like The Italian Job gets remade, and whaddya know, it's crap.
So I think the same is true for the game industry. Designers may get wrapped up in making t
Re:Snake Rattle n Roll (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Pathetic (Score:1)
I must admit though, a new version of ShadowRun (Genesis and SNES) or Paradroid (C64/128) would probably get my attention.
Re:Pathetic (Score:3, Insightful)
Of course we do. The question is whether we have so many ideas better than these remakes that everyone making a game can have one, and whether there is some way to get all these ideas to the people making games. That we don't have.
Re:Some games that could just use some updating. (Score:1)