Downloading Games Not Just For Pirates 91
1up is running a piece entitled Digital Delivery, which looks at alternate distribution models for new titles in the here-and-now of fast download speeds. They cover outfits like Steam and GameTap, in addition to the ever popular Xbox Live. From the article: "Steam's birth came with some controversy, though. It was only in late 2004 that this happened, but if you missed it, a brief explanation might be in order. When Valve decided to embrace digital distribution, they didn't do it in half measures. The retail version of the game that shipped to stores was more like a formality to appease Vivendi Universal Games, Valve's megalithic publisher: for $50, gamers got a box containing five discs inside a sleeve. If players wanted a manual, they had to refer to the PDF version on the disc, and the irritation at this was nothing compared to the real bombshell."
Guild Wars did it best (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Guild Wars did it best (Score:3, Interesting)
Except at my house, where my internet provider rate limits both BitTorrent traffic and cumulative traffic. BitTorrent is rate-limited network-wide, and total traffic is limited on a per-port basis, where they start dropping 1/x packets, where x is approaching 1 until they stick you where they want you.
This sucks, as my wife plays WoW, and everytime they release an update, she has to either wait for the in-game bit-torrent-esque thing to download it at literally 3KB/sec, or go wait in line at file planet fo
Re:Guild Wars did it best (Score:1)
Re:Guild Wars did it best (Score:2, Interesting)
Funny how socialist Europe and Korea do so much better at providing a competetive communications marketplace where a variety of companies compete on quality, price, and service, while the supposed capital of the world economy languishes in the 1990s.
Re:Guild Wars did it best (Score:1)
Sure, it's a mild annoyance when you have to download a new area the first time you visit it, but it's very quick.
Re:Guild Wars did it best (Score:2, Informative)
Kind of reminds me of Linux version of Neverwinter Nights - the game comes with "aluminum-reinforced Windoze brand coasters" which, upon closer inspection, have some mysterious .cab files and shit like that that Linux tools have very little clue about - but if you want to play the Linux version, you just download a gigantic tarball, uncompress, and enter the serial number from the back of the manual.
Um, okay (Score:2)
Re:Um, okay (Score:2)
Re:Um, okay (Score:2)
So, what happens if Valve goes out of business tomorrow? All Steam apps are then rendered worthless, even single-player.
Re:Um, okay (Score:2)
Re:Um, okay (Score:1)
Answer: You're fucked, Valve has officially stated they don't care about people whose connection doesn't allow Steam.
Re:Um, okay (Score:1)
Re:Um, okay (Score:1)
Re:Um, okay (Score:1)
Re:Um, okay (Score:2, Insightful)
Most of the {closed-source} software in use in the world is pirated. The big corporations know this and turn a blind eye to it; because they know that it's effectively free advertising, and free training, for their products. If Caz sees Shaz's pirate copy of Word, there's a chance -- a slim one, but a chance nonetheless -- that she might buy herself a copy; there's even a chance that Shaz might win the lottery or something, have an attack of conscience and decide t
Re:Um, okay (Score:2, Interesting)
The GOOD sites let you re-download (Score:1)
Now, granted, this is only good so long as the website in question sticks around, but for something like this I
crappy cliffhanger summaries (Score:2, Funny)
Which was?!? Leave it to Slashdot to end the summary with a cliffhanger like that. I guess I'll have to wait for the dupe to find out what happens next...
Re:crappy cliffhanger summaries (Score:2, Informative)
Re:crappy cliffhanger summaries (Score:1)
Comment removed (Score:3, Funny)
Re:well, sure (Score:1)
Re:well, sure (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Yarrr! Matey! (Score:4, Funny)
Not when ye have a Galleon loaded with 20 cannon, 100 vicious men, and a cargo hold filled to the brim with ye backup tapes traveling at 5 knots due to a ragin carribean storm!
Yar! Thar be ye bandwidth!
Re:Yarrr! Matey! (Score:1)
It's better..... but (Score:3, Interesting)
After reinstalling Windows recently to start things fresh I put all the games I play back on, disk by disk while I browsed the web. That is, all but one game, Day of Defeat: Source. I forgot to back it up and dread having to go through all the bullshit Valve is going to make me go through to get it back.
Honestly, if I had a disk I would probably be playing it again.
Re:It's better..... but (Score:2)
the only good thing i've found about steam is being able to install games onto other computers while away from home.
Re:It's better..... but (Score:2)
Re:It's better..... but (Score:2)
Just like HL2, CS:S and everything. No need to pay once it is linked to your account.
Re:It's better..... but (Score:1)
Re:It's better..... but (Score:2)
Yeah I see no problem with that. Every gamer has hours to waste redownloading everything they've already bought.
I'd sure call that bullshit.
Re:It's better..... but (Score:1)
Also, this is nowhere near the point, but most gamers have surprisingly large amounts of free time.
Re:It's better..... but (Score:2)
There are a LOAD of disadvantages to steam, most really obvious and all well documented.
1) If your internet connection is down, so is your game.
2) If you're out of bandwidth for the month, you can't play your game.
3) Bandwidth is not free.
4) No internet connection is going to be faster than CD.
5) If Blizzard go bankrupt or decide to start charging for the use of their servers you're basically at their mercy. It'll happen in the near future and the argument will be that people pay t
Re:It's better..... but (Score:2)
I would also mention that while I'm sure there are people stuck with monthly metered bandwidth, the vast majority of people are unlimited in terms of total downloads/uploads. Many get hosed by their ISPs where they limit the bandwidth (speed) available to certain applications/ports but that's another topic entirely.
I'm a Steam Hater from way back (and haven't played HL2 despite a
Re:It's better..... but (Score:2)
Bandwidth however is a finite thing. It doesn't matter if you get it from company X or company Y either. (Well it may matter to your bank account but in the grand scheme that's your choice, provided you live somewhere where you can get unlimited bandwidth - not something you can assume is true for every
Re:It's better..... but (Score:1)
1. If its a multiplayer only/multiplayer component then yes. This is true of (almost) every other multiplayer game as well though.
2. No, in most cases you would just have to pay extra usage fees or simply have your connection capped at around 56k speeds (I find though that its actually faster then what one could expect from a 56k service (eg you get
Re:It's better..... but (Score:2)
2. Many if not most ISPs gouge for extra usage
4. What you think everyone has gigabit or ADSL2? How many people do you know that exceed 20 or 30 gig a month? They're not the usual user either.
5. I'm not willing to install HL2/steam to find out, but if single player isn't already crippled how long before it is until it phones home and authenticates? How long till some company decides it's costing money so lets charge for this? If you can't see the agenda you're being obtuse on purpose.
6. It'
Funny... (Score:2)
Before the reformat, I had HL2 + Deathmatch, CS & CS: Source, DoD: Source, FarCry, Doom 3, and a bunch of other, random games.
After, all I installed was HL2 + Deathmatch, CS & CS: Source and DoD: Source. Why? Because I couldn't find those damn CDs or the CD keys for the others.
When I went through this "bullshit," which was last Friday at 3:00, I just downloaded a 708KB installer and entered my Steam ID and password. Then I t
What bullshit? (Score:1)
Re:It's better..... but (Score:1)
Some of the comments here seem a little uninformed (with regard to the current state of steam)
For instance it is possible to use steam while not connected to the internet, it has an offline mode so you can still play single player games. Probably multiplayer too on a LAN (haven't tried it though)
Also, they recently added a back up option so that you can backup your games (plus all the patches, maps, etc you've downloaded). Admittedly, I just checked and for me this is 10GB of stuff to back up. But I do us
"here-and-now of fast download speeds" (Score:3, Insightful)
Online distribution is fine, just make sure that the product is still available on regular media that I can order online, or pick up at the store.
And before anyone suggests moving, living in a small valley just a few miles North of Yellowstone far outweighs not having large bandwidth available.
Re:"here-and-now of fast download speeds" (Score:2)
Broadband access is not universal. 56k is not universal. 28.8k is not universal.
As a Steam user. (Score:3, Interesting)
I also find it cool how they are serving up mini-content such as a free HL2 side scroller prior to the actual game and the free bonus level "Lost Coast." Plus, all those little apps hide under one button instead of further cluttering up my desktop and start menu.
My brother also recently bought another game using some service known as direct2drive which also lets you download the game directly. I don't actually know how that went, but it seemed easy. He's not that computer savy but still had it working the same night.
IMHO, these services get an A+ from me. I look forward to more distrobution models such as Steam (The one consequence I can see is having a million downloaders clogging up your machine.)
direct2drive (Score:1)
Re:Steam & 2nd user games? (Score:2)
Keep in mind that destroying the used games market is part of Valve's plan.
Re:Steam & 2nd user games? (Score:1)
Lockin (Score:4, Insightful)
Now, Valve is the pioneer with Steam, and while there are some great parts about it...unfortunately the downsides outweigh them significantly.
Downsides
Unreliable - I'm sure many here remember the first day woes of Steam as fans the world over all tried to access Steam for the first time only to be out of luck as it was down. This would have been fine, since there is a great single-player game in HL2....except for the fact that you need to connect to Steam initially to gain access to that.
No Hard Copy - While its great to be able to download the game whenever you want, this is a huge problem for people who like to sell their games when they move on to the next one. You can't sell your license to the download.
Lockin - This is my biggest gripe with them. Valve has proven time and time again to be a greedy company. Why should I trust them with this system, especially when they have a lot of my personal details? Additionally, this system lets them begin the process of charging for every single thing they can. For example, you now need to pay for the full versions of DoD and NS. That would not have happened without Steam. In the future, I'm sure all the good mods will be sold through Steam, thus taking what was once done out of love by fans and given out for free to enhance value of the game (and drive core game sales!) and turning it into yet another money making tool rather than the 'added bonus' it used to be considered by the community. And if you think charging for mods is bad, wait until you head down the EA path and start adding additional weapons that are useable in the core game but only if you bought the expansion. Can you say "pay-to-upgrade weapons in FPS"? Yeah, not fun.
All in all, digital distribution online is the way of the future. I just don't trust a company like Valve to handle it.
Re:Lockin (Score:2)
I disagree with you that there is no hard copy. True, you don't get nicely pressed discs or manuals (though HL2 only came with a quick reference card) but you don't have to deal with DRM to make as many copies of the game as you wish. If you don't mind connecting to the
Re:Lockin (Score:2)
Except you missed my point...when they have it set like this, you don't OWN the game, you're RENTING it.
"Finally, I also disargee with you about DoD. Ye
Re:Lockin (Score:2)
Well, isn't that true even of games that don't require the internet? That's the beef with copy protection like Safedisc or DRM. Consumers can't win. Either they must be connected to the internet to play or they can't make copies of their storebought media. Ultimately the decider comes down to which is the most likely inconvenience - a scratched\lost CD or shoddy internet. As the internet improv
Re:Lockin (Score:1)
And what's the problem with that? By using the software you are buying into their business model as far as it extends to that software. (Perhaps distributors/producers should make it VERY obvious though that parting with cash does not constitute ownership).
It's a free market you live in. The supplier can choose any method they like to distribute their software, and also set the parameters surround
Re:Lockin (Score:2)
Re:Lockin (Score:2)
Re:Lockin (Score:3, Interesting)
That's actually one big reason why game companies LIKE download-distribution methods like Steam. There was an earlier Slashdot article where publishers frustrated by second-hand game sales [slashdot.org].
Now, Valve COULD implement a method where you could sell your license to download. They would just
Simple SSo (Score:1)
Re:Lockin (Score:2)
Well, you can certainly sell your Steam account to anyone if you want to, for the value of all games you have registered. If you really sell every game when you're done, just create a new steam account for every download.
Valve is not the pioneer here . . . (Score:1)
The real bombshell (Score:1, Troll)
Here's hoping digital distribution gets 'figured out' before it gets 'fucked up' (again).
Re:The real bombshell (Score:1)
Re:The real bombshell (Score:4, Funny)
If you accidentally cut off your foot with an axe, don't cry about it and rush to the hospital, you selfish glutton. Some people don't have legs!
Re:The real bombshell (Score:1)
Re:The real bombshell (Score:2)
FFS - I had exactly the same experience - install from CDs, install steam, wait for steam updates to download, wait for steam to install updates, wait for steam to download HL2 updates, wait for those to install.
About four hours is correct. Then the game itself is like an interactive waiting simulation - why the hell were there so many loading screens? Walk for a minute, load, walk for another minute, load...
I thought PC games were past this kind of crap.
Personally,
Re:The real bombshell (Score:1)
Re:The real bombshell (Score:1)
I thought PC games were past this kind of crap.
If you're a PC gamer, you owe it to yourself to invest in Good Hardware. "Minimum" system requirements almost NEVER are what we would consider "adequate".
I've played the HL2 demo, and it behaved the way you described. So did Far Fry, and the Doom3 demo (though that DID scale very well). Battlefiel
something's wrong... (Score:3, Informative)
Re:something's wrong... (Score:3, Informative)
I like Steam (Score:1)
Steam is good and will be better when friends start workign again. How hard can that be? It has been a long time since friends worked.
Wolf3D 4 Free? (Score:3, Informative)
Hell yeah... (Score:2)
'Twas the same with Doom. The first part of it was free to download, to copy around, it was on every magazine coverdisk for months... I got to the point where I knew my way around Knee-Deep in the Dead better than I did my own high school :)
Never really got into the other two episodes, when I finally did get around to g
GarageGames (Score:2)
Similar attitude here (Score:2)
I don't think that is the sort of revenue they were planning for.
NetHack (Score:1)
Strategy First is not Russian. (Score:2, Informative)
Trygames.com (Score:1)
Re:Trygames.com (Score:1)
Digital distribution is not a sale, but a renting (Score:1)
If you read the Steam Subscriber Agreement, you'll see that with your $40 or so, you have never bought a game, not even a license to play the game like all for the other games you might have. What you have paid are subscription fees to access some contents on some online service.
And the differences are significant:
- First, usually you can transfer a game license, but you can't transfer a Steam subscription (section 1
Lineage 1 (Score:3, Interesting)
Lineage 1 came out in 1998; digital delivery is by no means new!
can't buy in a store (Score:1)
Double Purchase and Permanent Email (Score:2)